Seriously? Blunders galore.

Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I know this is a daily soap where situations and characters are magnified but come on!!! What on earth are the CVs showing? We know that Misha is faking it and the characters are shown to be oblivious to it all. But here we have some sensitive, thoughtful and educated characters that are shown to be be making some serious blunders.

Sid - I love the guy. He is kind and compassionate but what is he doing? His friend has suffered a (so called) ordeal and he is allowing her to become emotionally dependent on him. Really? Yes, I know Sid is kind hearted but this is not kindness. This is messy. He and Misha have history together but that doesn't mean he practically gives himself to her on a plate. Being there for your friend and emotionally supporting them is one thing. But to give yourself to the point that your friend wants you and no one else, that is a recipe for disaster. Send her for counselling!

And Roshni...I love this girl for always wearing her heart on her sleeve. But now CVs haven't spared her either. She's their next victim to become the sacrificial lamb. Ok, so she feels awful about what happened to Misha. But why would that mean she should sacrifice her love for Misha? Love isn't a charity. You can't just give it away to please a third party. It doesn't work like that. This decision is far worse than her not listening to Sid post MMS track (IMO)

SidNi's love is unconditional. But does that mean they have to kill their own desires for the rest of the world? This is foolish behaviour and nothing else. On the contrary, I would rather see SidNi fighting for each other against the world.

If for arguments sake Misha was telling the truth and was a positive character, I would STILL object to Sid's closeness with her because a victim needs time to recover both emotionally and physically. And I would never agree to SidNi sacrifice either because marriage should be the last thing on everyone's mind. A real victim would need professional help.

Being a huge JR fan from the very first episode, I just wanted to vent a bit. Hope no one minds :)
Edited by ..Bohemian.. - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.6k

Users

10

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

afghangirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
amazing post dear. agree with you.
Sidni should fight for their love. and all characters should use their brain, an abused victim wont behave as Misha is behaving.
I dont understand what CVs want to show.

Edited by afghangirl - 10 years ago
Harmony10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Who would mind Zinnia? Everyone is with you. We are all frustrated over this track. SidNi seriously need to think about themselves for once in the show. And all the blame goes to CVs for making our leads so Mahan. In real life no one would do anything like that. They are showing unrealistic and illogical things.

Misha's behavior doesn't suit her being raped. Real victims go through trauma but in here she is doing tamasha. Who would do that only a maniac person would behave like a physco after getting raped.
Edited by paru10 - 10 years ago
rosesidni thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Completely agree with u. Actually, I wanted to make a post about this after seeing the SBB episode but thought will it after the episode. But now since u stated everything, its the same I'm feeling..

What SidNi is doing is not sacrifice, its foolishness Mentally unstable people (if Misha was actually one) will demand unreasonable things, that doesn't mean u agree to it🥱 She threatened to commit suicide and SidNi agreed for Sid getting married to her🥱. What if she asked something else, like if she asked to kill someone whom both SidNi loved (DD or Shiv or Raj etc) and threatens that if they didn't do it she will commit suicide, would SidNi have agreed to that too for Misha's welfare??😕

Insane people say many things, but sane people should use their, brain which both Sid and Roshni is not doing now😕
madhuharini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
completely agree with u dear..abt Sid and Roshni, all ur points are true. Now I think it's time for JR to loose all it's die hard fans😕
candacy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
The doctor said she had a memory block and remembers tings before the accident,do we assume she has block the rape and hence she's clinging to Sid because she knew him and not behaving like a rape victim . I'm not supporting SidNi decision but to them she is the rape victim with memory lost . I tink he Is trying to there for her as a friend and Roshni is supporting him unfortunately the girl is playing them both.

Simran didn't even find out what this girl was up to all this while,her hatred for Roshni has not only put SidNi in danger but everyone including Simran herself and my sweetie Biji . This girl will go to any length to have Sid,we saw Simran get off easy but I feel Misha will make her life a living hell along with anyone who gets to close to Sid or even ppl who trys to hurt him . SIMRAN BEWARE U HAVE INVITED THE DEVIL HOME.


FOR THE RECORD IM SUPER PISSED AT THE TRACK TOO.
Edited by candacy - 10 years ago
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: afghangirl

amazing post dear. agree with you.

Sidni should fight for their love. and all characters should use their brain, an abused victim wont behave as Misha is behaving.
I dont understand what CVs want to show.



Thank u :)

I am fed up of seeing SidNi having to push aside their own wishes for others...ALL the time. It's high time they fought for their love.

God knows what the CVs are up to. Misha's plan was a real twist in the tale...but I don't agree with what's being shown.
Millerrr88 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: afghangirl

amazing post dear. agree with you.

Sidni should fight for their love. and all characters should use their brain, an abused victim wont behave as Misha is behaving.
I dont understand what CVs want to show.


agreed with both of yall...I just hate how sidni is seperated so long 😕

the cvs could of come up with something better
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: paru10

Who would mind Zinnia? Everyone is with you. We are all frustrated over this track. SidNi seriously need to think about themselves for once in the show. And all the blame goes to CVs for making our leads so Mahan. In real life no one would do anything like that. They are showing unrealistic and illogical things.

Misha's behavior doesn't suit her being raped. Real victims go through trauma but in here she is doing tamasha. Who would do that only a maniac person would behave like a physco after getting raped.



Thanks Paru :) I was just a bit concerned that some might think I'm bashing.

Indeed all the blame lies with the JR CVs for making our main lead mahaan. I mean, to this extent? 😕 It's too much now. The track is frustrating, along with the actions of SidNi.


Misha is behaving more like a deranged person who has a fixation with Sid. It doesn't make any sense.



Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: zoopassion

Completely agree with u. Actually, I wanted to make a post about this after seeing the SBB episode but thought will it after the episode. But now since u stated everything, its the same I'm feeling..

What SidNi is doing is not sacrifice, its foolishness Mentally unstable people (if Misha was actually one) will demand unreasonable things, that doesn't mean u agree to it🥱 She threatened to commit suicide and SidNi agreed for Sid getting married to her🥱. What if she asked something else, like if she asked to kill someone whom both SidNi loved (DD or Shiv or Raj etc) and threatens that if they didn't do it she will commit suicide, would SidNi have agreed to that too for Misha's welfare??😕

Insane people say many things, but sane people should use their, brain which both Sid and Roshni is not doing now😕



@bold: Exactly! One cannot give in to all demands made by a victim of such an awful ordeal. You just can't do that. But here we have Sid and Roshni bending backwards for Misha. This is taking love and support to a whole new level. If she had asked for something unreasonable or inappropriate...then what? 😕

I'm glad you share my sentiments :) I often end up nodding my head to your posts too 😆 They often mirror my thoughts...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".