Originally posted by: incandescent
@ Debarati7 - I went through all the posts in this thread. You seem to have made up your mind that Sanaya is responsible for the failure of Chhanchhan, especially since you are disagreeing with the comments that the story, screenplay, characterizations are at fault and you feel Sanaya should be held accountable for the failure of Chhanchhan and she may not be as good as people say she is.
If you feel that way, then it's your prerogative but you already seem so convinced and I don't think you intend to change your opinion any time soon. So I don't really know what to say or why you are asking this to others.
Of course it's a free forum and you can make post any topic you want...so just saying.
Although u claim to have read all my posts..but its absolutely clear that have not read them properly and came firing guns like a blind Sanaya fan..its is not the case that i have made up my mind regarding her that she is the ONLY reason...i said she was a vital part of the show so she is also responsible for the show's failure..I dnt have some pichle janam ki dushmani with her to be blaming her without a reason..😛
And yes i am convinced about my opinion as are u in stating that she is not at all in fault..And yes ofcourse it is a free forum i have the right to present my opinion as u do..
If success of a show is a team work, failure should be considered as a team work too. I agree with that. But of course, an actor can't be held responsible for screenplay or the characterization and the major reasons for the failure of CC is the story. I feel she did complete justice to whatever material she was given but the show didn't click for a variety of reasons. It happens. Not every show will be equally successful.
Ofcourse an actor cant be held responsible for bad screenplay be she definitely should be held responsible for mediocre or lets just say bad acting..which holds a major key in making a show a success or a failure..yes there were variety of reasons ..but one of them was her according to me..
Let's wait and see how her next show turns out, shall we?
After this show..i honestly have a lot of doubts..
FYI, Sanaya was the lead actress in MJHT along with Rati. In fact all the four leads had equal amount of screen space in the show.
Of course, there is no denying that Rati was the star of that show and Mayank-Nupur were more popular than Samrat-Gunjan but she was also the lead. In fact Sanaya was the only female lead in the show for a few months when Rati was out of the show.
I never said that..it shows you did not read my posts..i said she was a parallel lead..hope you understand what that means..I said Rati was better becoz she is a fantastic actress and she will be garnering more limelight even if pitched against BW actress..she has that spunk..
But post MJHT, Sanaya has emerged as the most successful among the four leads.
Yes and that is becoz of IPK..so back to square one😉
And why are you saying that the success of MJHT was not completely her credit? In fact she has openly stated Rati/Nupur was more popular when the show was on air. When has she claimed sole credit for any of her hit shows?
When did i say she claimed sole credit..😕dont make up things please.. And Rati was more popular because she was better..simple😊And MJHT was not her sole credit anyways..
Coming back to the original topic,
Reason for the unprecedented success of IPK - the magic created by Barun-Sanaya Jodi and the exceptional acting by them, fabulous ensemble cast, beautiful story and characters, great music and a job well done by the whole team. Of course the script, characterizations etc. went downhill towards the end but IPK was magic that happens once in a lifetime.
Agree with this fortunately..😊
What did IPK have which Chhanchhan didn't have - good script and characterizations. Khushi was a meatier role than Chhachhan and that show didn't allow Sanaya to showcase much of her talent. Infact all the characters in Chch are one dimensional.
Is Sanaya talented - Yes.
I did not say she isnt..Otherwise she would not have been here..
Is she the best in business -She is extremely talented, versatile, and beautiful and she is a complete package. She is one of the most renowned actresses of her generation, has a worldwide fanbase which is enviable. So if you take all of the above into consideration, she can easily be considered the best and hardly any other actress can come close to her.
I would like to ask you though, who according to you is the best in the industry since you don't think it's Sanaya. How do decide who the best in the industry is...is the number of hits and flops the criteria for it or something else?
Yeah right..so that u can start World War III😆..I dont think any actress n Tv is talented enough 😉And FYI the criteria to decide who is the best and worst has always been on the basis of hits and flops they have given..hope u know this...
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
Current Affairs
45