Created

Last reply

Replies

126

Views

9.2k

Users

44

Likes

434

Frequent Posters

ishq30 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: rima

but your posts directly criticized LM and praised AK

so why can't LM lovers defend him
as far as I am concerned he is a fabulous director
and humble enough to be in FB and take bashing when people gave it to him
And AK got appreciation for the diwali and and other scenes
but he also needs criticism for the gobar and ladder rabba vey and the disastrous swami and GH tracks


tel me wen did i critisize his work?
i critisized him fr comapring barun nd sanaya in this interview..
wen did i say he din do his scenes well?
i have always said tat even sheetal track nd MRS india track were the results of bad writing nd directors have nothin to do with it..
nd also by saying arshad is director for barun does nt take away anything frm LM.. its just my POV
shadesofme thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#72

well apparently LM did the same !!
and as i said no one is taking LM his credit...that guy got more credit than any other person related to show!!
if he likes SI then he can praise on and on and no need to show barun in bad light
hell if he doesn't like baruns work the y take his name??
Edited by shadesofme - 12 years ago
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: rima

he also directed the worst episodes of IPK

does that take away the credit from AK? no
praise shud be balanced
if you see his best scenes
you shud see his worst too
same with LM
LM made magic with many scenes
how is it that he is discredited for it
or people say he is over credfited?

I dont think anyone is not givin him credit for his work..but he was not the only one... and definately frm his interviews..I do sense that he takes credit away from his actors👎🏼...specially barun..
spate22 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#74
Where are we trying to compare??!! We are just trying to defend LM!! Because people all of a sudden think he's self-centered?!! All of them have done a great job, why can't we leave it that??!! 😕


Shreya
rima thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: shadesofme


AND only he improved that by his angles and lighting ...
he is full of himself...

a person who is full of himself wont face people like LM does
i still remember during new year episode when barun and sanaya were in holiday
people bashed LM
he said sorry
AK never faces people
while people interviewed him in swami track
he refused to answer
that does not make AK arrogant
he simply did not want to answer
same as LM wants to answer
so how is people's character judged based on anything?
or is the real problem that LM is praising sanaya and not barun?
every director has their favourties
rima thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: riti4u

I dont think anyone is not givin him credit for his work..but he was not the only one... and definately frm his interviews..I do sense that he takes credit away from his actors👎🏼...specially barun..

ah
the problem is that he does not give credit to Barun
now I got it
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: shadesofme


well apparently LM did the same !!
and as i said no one is taking LM his credit...that guy got more credit than any other person related to show!!
if he likes SI then he praise on and on and no need to show barun in bad light
hell if he doesn't like baruns work the y take his name??

yes why does he have to compare ...in first place..
@bold- thats where my problem is..
rima thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: shadesofme


well apparently LM did the same !!
and as i said no one is taking LM his credit...that guy got more credit than any other person related to show!!
if he likes SI then he can praise on and on and no need to show barun in bad light
hell if he doesn't like baruns work the y take his name??

now i got the issue
u people are upset LM is siding with sanaya and praising her and not Barun
sad isn't it?
how people tear people to shreds just for their own favorites?
if we can have favorities can't a director have?
Even karan johar says his fav is Shah rukh
so does that mean he does not respect kkajol?
applesauce. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: pashna

If some one says how they have worked hard for their part in a show does that mean he is not giving credit to another director?? If barun says I did so much work for Arnav's role does that mean he is not going credit to sanaya😲 some people in this forum are just🤢



There was only one Barun Sobti dealing with Character Arnav,whereas there were two directors.
So I gues,ack other would NOT have snatched anythng frm LM.Thats just my POV,no offence.The show was team effort ,NOT ONE MAN!
archie_79 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: polly2312

Reposting from different thread. Pls note I am not comparing him with AK or saying that he is taking all the credit for himself...just feel he is trying to take credit away from the actor. Here's my take...

It was so difficult to read the interview. All the hindi written in english!

Seemed to me that this is a continuation of an old interview. What's the point of splitting it up like this?

Anyway...interview was ok. Too much technical terms...didn't understand the this slide, contra slide etc. Went over my head. As a viewer I see the final product on my screen.

Anyway, it was good to read how much hard work was done by the whole team and how detail oriented they were. This is why we fell in love with the show...because they used to present every scene with care in the initial months. Not sure why they stopped giving attention and time to details later...as this showed on screen as the overall quality of the episodes had declined.

So from what I understood, Barun had to give a LOT of shots for each scene...because they wanted to present ASR in a particular way. So that's why even if he had less dialogues, Barun used to get tired because of so many extra retakes that they did for his character so he had to put in more energy than others. I guess when they stopped doing that later, this is why ASR looked less larger than life.

But LMji...all this is not as important as the story in a daily soap. So even if you spent extra time doing all this in the initial months, it was the story and flow and logical progression that made the first 6 months memorable. When the story sucked even you could not salvage it.

Good to hear what he said about sanaya's acting prowness and dedication. Though I don't understand why Sanaya has to be always praised while comparing to Barun...even in this forum. Why can't she be praised and appreciated on her own? And I am confused about how Sanaya grew as an actress to the point of seeing the directors vision. Then why did Khushi seem more cringeworthy and unbearably OTT in the show later than what she was before? The answer is simple...it was bad writing...which neither Sanaya nor LM could salvage with their directorial vision.

And for someone who left the show for creative dissatisfaction when the show was at it's peak, I don't understand the attachment for it when it was at it's lowest. Maybe like Sanaya he was emotionally attached to the cast and crew. But the "dream" that he talks about losing was only in his mind as there was nothing of our beautiful show remaining after the remarriage.



Well said 👏

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: ILoveFF · 6 years ago

Hello readers, Thank you for your support so far. It has been overwhelming. I am deeply grateful to every reader; sweet silent ones and precious...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".