So Barun was leaving in Feb Last Year - Page 6

Originally posted by: guturgutur

IMHO, arnav would have had a car accident on his way to the remarriage... missing-presumed dead... khushi heartbroken... but star plus did not like that track and had changed the storyline to make the marriage happen.

if barun had left then, he could have had a few months break ... while khushi comes to terms with the BFTP, every other family member would have something to act.. they could show the whole history of dad and his betrayal, anjali's perspective or something.. the story would last without arnav in the picture.. and then khushi 'feels' him.. knows he is alive.. and arnav will come back with amnesia or something.

barun would have had the 'break' , without sacrificing the role of ASR. but, well, the remarriage would not have happened.. and when star overwrote the PH's story, the PH threw up its hands and wrote the love letter to us fans.. and honestly, we did expect the BFTP..
and then we got the shital track and stuff just as stopgap, i think star wrote that story... because it had no connect to the previous storyline AT ALL.

Originally posted by: rima

hetal i agree on all points

ecept that I am still a huge LM fan

he made IPK magic

my be his interview was contradictory

but i respect his work

Originally posted by: CDlove

They couldn't change the story accordingly because barun was in two minds at all times!

didn't LM make it clear? He wanted to leave in Feb. Then he wanted to leave in June. He extended his stay because the show was going good

what does this tell you? he was never forthright about his decision.

I refuse to believe the creatives of the show would have forced Sheetal and Mrs India tracks down our throats had they known Barun would be quitting in two month's time.

It was always a decison that was pending and in limbo, a decision that was changed and postponed. LM made it pretty clear didn't he?

That was the reason we never got a decent track- because everything depended on Barun's decision.

How can the creatives bump him off or make a logical track WITH or WITHOUT Arnav if Barun's decision was never forthright and straightforward?

They had no freaking clue when Barun would leave/ or if he leave at all.

Originally posted by: CDlove

They couldn't change the story accordingly because barun was in two minds at all times!

didn't LM make it clear? He wanted to leave in Feb. Then he wanted to leave in June. He extended his stay because the show was going good

what does this tell you? he was never forthright about his decision.

I refuse to believe the creatives of the show would have forced Sheetal and Mrs India tracks down our throats had they known Barun would be quitting in two month's time.

It was always a decison that was pending and in limbo, a decision that was changed and postponed. LM made it pretty clear didn't he?

That was the reason we never got a decent track- because everything depended on Barun's decision.

How can the creatives bump him off or make a logical track WITH or WITHOUT Arnav if Barun's decision was never forthright and straightforward?

They had no freaking clue when Barun would leave/ or if he leave at all.

Originally posted by: hetalmkn

I totally agree on this. Its ridiculous to just throw the blame on fans or barun...

LM.. as a director did u even once speak to Gautam or GUL abt it? u knew the situation frm the very beginning... u could have advised them.. made them understand the situation and uproar that might break out...

it is very easy to give interview and answer questions that suits your taste but try coming out in open and take open questions!! i'm dead sure u will be shivering from the tip of ur hair till your toe...

GUL knew this hence she didn't conduct a Press Conference...!! And since all compare kyunki with IPK and amar leaving the show creating the uproar... then let us scan back.. uproar happened that time as well BUT the channel continued the track bringing in Ronit Roy and gradually people accepted it right..!! that time too people called to bring amar back or they will stop watching...

then why that time channel didn't take the decision of abrupt ending? why they went on with the story?? they took the risk of going on? clearly because the PH was interested in continuing despite any odds...

but over here story is different...same situation occurred.. uproar.. no replacing barun.. no dead track nothing as sort.. but PH didn't step up and take the risk because CLEARLY THEY WERE NOT INTERESTED IN IT AT ALL ANYMORE!!

So Mr. Lalit, Gul and the rest... we are very clearly on how much the PH was concentrating on the new baby QH!!! hence don't you even think we will buy the idea of Barun quitting and bla bla..

Okie let say we agree with the fact that if he had YRF offering him he would leave the show... BUT he clearly have mentioned he didn't not have any offer when he decided to leave in November... its not me who is saying this he gave an interview to Hindustan Times on it...

Even StarPlus said he wants to explore BW not that he has films in his hands.. so how to do justify the fact that he mentioned he will only do the serial for one year... JOKE rite.. coz of course when he joined IPKKND in the beginning he wasn't sooo popular that YRF will come and offer him a movie... so rewind back and think abt your lame facts!!

It is after IPKKND Barun gained his current fame ON HIS OWN!! ya you guys wrote, created, director whatever crap.. but he portrayed it with perfection!! he showed the world the character you wrote on just papers.. so don't you even once think we will buy the fact that its barun quitting drama leading to this!!

And now coming to fans!! Mr. Lalit Mohan.. let me enlighten you .. IT WAS RIMA's petition signed by fans that got you back here not because GUL KHAN missed you!! Arshad gave superb episodes too yet we wanted you guys back as duo but now you think u re sooo great that u can sit and throw the blame on we fans!!

Where were your sentiments towards your 200 workers when you left the show in between?? your direction was loved.. people might hav rejected the serial.. TRP could hav fall and IPK could have ended hence ending 200 workers ROZI ROTI!! but no.. u didn't care... we stayed by them!!

You are bothered abt that 200 people where the hell were your sentiments when these same 200 people could have lost their jobs when 4rats published the open letter!! NO STORY LEFT?? W*F... so much can be explored.. your parallel leads were as strong and as superb as you main leads...

we can list 100 tracks in just 5 minutes for u!! you people couldn't even do one? JOKE!! you people do research and mrs india track was loved? the way khushi's character was going was loved?? dude!! looks like the research was only within you group of people not public!! you guys are CREATIVE TEAM? lolzz a team that after 1 and 1/2 yrs can't even think of better tracks to continue the story?? mazak banadiya tum logo ne aapne aapka!!

Kyunki saas bhi kabhi bahu thi was watched more by household ladies but IPKKND is watched across all range of age and mind you EDUCATED once as well!!!

so my suggestion to you all now is.. instead of giving interviews and making yourself look 100X more stupid.. you guys can probably take an admission in St. Xavier for a fresh start of mass comm degree!! and then come and blame the fans and barun sobti!!

agar aaj barun aur sanaya nahi hote toh humein KOI FARAKH NAHI PARTA!! lekin BAAT SANAYA AUR BARUN KI HAI ISLIYE HUMEIN FARAKH PARTA HAI!!!

finally mr. lalit.. in your own style..

Cut it!!

Originally posted by: rima

I completely diagree

if I knew my employee is in two minds

i wud always not rely on such an employee

and plan for things

no one can explain swami, GH , DKS track

nd the time wasted in it

knowing an actor will quit

Originally posted by: hetalmkn

yes rima i agree.. in fact in other thread i mentioned that i loved him but he shouldn't have done this...

but from which angle is it correct to blame fans for this??

Originally posted by: Shru9ti

First of all a big channel lyk SP will never sign an actor who dey knw is goin to quit aftr one year

Next point is u hav decided to bash Barun no matter wat.Wen even Abbhas said in his interview dat d show ended coz of probs in executive level u all said he ws actin.Bt nw all of a sudden u believe LM's interview so wholeheartedly.Strange