jerriblank thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
I've been thinking, probably a little too much, about the current track. And honestly, I kind of love it. I'm surprised at this because at first, I wasn't the biggest fan. Some of you probably wont agree with my thoughts but I needed to express them.

I think the writers are doing something that's pretty ingenious. And this isn't sarcastic at all.

Like most of you, I was pretty put off by Anjali's pathetic state. I understood that it's only logical that she would be feeling that but something still seemed a bit off. And I couldn't help but compare her to Khushi.

I've read some posts that lament that the writers are sexist or that they are trying to portray women as weak beings. But I think that they are doing the exact opposite.

Lets think about it:

Khushi- Strong, independent, loving (unconditionally), caring, resilient, and humorous
Anjali- Dependent, trusting (blindly), loving, caring, and sweet.

Khushi is very independent when things are falling apart for her. Even when they are she chooses to overcome them by thinking about others and adding laughter in her life. Partially because nobody is there to share her pain with her and partially because she doesn't want others to be burdened.
Khushi also bounces back with amazing zeal. No matter how bad the situation is, she lets it go and moves on with her life. She is an optimist-- everything will get better one day.

Anjali, on the other hand, is quite the opposite. She's always been dependent. After the tragedy, her younger brother took it upon himself to fix her problems and to care for her, almost as an older brother would. This was the major starting point of her dependent nature. After marriage, her husband "took care of all of her needs" and doted on her, he even called her "Rani Saiba." They put her on a pedestal, she was a china doll. Everyone she interacted with took care of her and she had huge faith in God. So her blind trust formed, she didn't ask questions she just went with what people were saying.

Khushi- Her husband hated her for 6 months of her marriage. Even before they married he was terrible to her. He had some moments which made her believe that he care for her but for the most part he was pretty evil to her. No matter what his reasons were, there's no denying that he overdid it most times. Even though she loved him, and it tore her apart when he was cruel to her, she still moved forward. I think the writers aren't saying that Khushi is dumb; rather, Khushi is an admirable character. Her characteristics mirror many amazing Indian women I've had the fortune of living with and learning from. Her character highlights that women are, in fact, amazing creatures. We have the ability to overcome things that may knock us down, but in the end with have the ability to succeed.

She really is a new type of Bahu, she's independent from her husband. And before you jump up with indignation. Here's my argument: Khushi LOVES Arnav, there's no denying that. She loves him A LOT. BUT She can live without his support. (I'm not saying she can live without HIM) Remember, he hated her for 6 months. And even though she was upset, she didn't sit around depressed that nobody cared about her. How many characters in Indian television can do THAT!?

Now, about Anjali. I think the fact that the episodes last week were so centralized around her made the comparison more visible.

Anjali said it herself, that she has never been that strong and that she doesn't ever want to be so strong that she wouldn't need Shyam. When I heard this, I gagged a little. I was disgusted that she could say that. But then I started to think about what she said. It wouldn't leave my head.

I came to the conclusion that Anajli and Khushi are foils. They are supposed to show two different extremes.

Some have been disgusted by the portrayal of Anjali but I think its necessary to show what kind of mental state she is in and WHY she's there. She never became independent. She never had to hide the pain from others. She never learned that. Whereas, Khushi HAD to.

This doesn't mean that Anjali is weak, per say. I think she has the ability to become an amazingly independent character. But that can only happen once Shyam's truth is revealed and when Arnav takes a step back from acting like her older brother.

I like to think that the writers are showing that the Anjali dependence is something EVERYONE (male or female) should stay away from. And the Khushi independence (maybe not to her extreme) should be something to learn from.

I hope that some of you share your thoughts on this. I find it to be amazing. I'm kind of in love with this track. And I can only hope that you may start to share the same feelings for this track.

Please let me know what you think!! Thanks!!

**Sorry it got a bit wordy!😳

Edited by jerriblank - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

2.2k

Users

15

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

kernal thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 2 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Thank you! This post has just made our day! Couldn't resist the urge to respond :)
jerriblank thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
I'm glad! 😊 And thank you for responding!!
751891 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Wonderfully analysis, very balanced and made complete sense, thank you
LucyLindaDew thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
One Word... WOW! Awesome-ly analysed!
NothingLasts thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Well written and the points you put across are very true. But the CVs have made a weak attempt at execution. There are simply too many loopholes and the direction is poor. They need to focus on details, consistency and continuation. If they nail that then things will be a lot easier for them and us.
bepatient thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Good analysis ! What you have written does make sense but these points are not readily understood by the viewers by and large. That just tells us that the direction is not very good. I also am not against the track but against the poor direction, loopholes, unexplained abrupt scenes.
merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
yes you are right, the fact that Anjali is so dependent also has a different effect on those who are around her, while her brothers and family are overly protectiv, Shayam take's full advantage of this weekness.
though Shyam tired to have some assemblence over Khushi, he never successed, he only uses her concern for others to manipulate her to a small extent. he never had a hold on her. and her innate independence and strength will always keep her out of his reach.
now for Arnav Khushi is a whole different ball game, the only thing Arnav has going for him as far as khushi is concern is that she LOVES HIM UNCONDITIONALY. Arnav controls everything because everybody listens to him, everybody except Khushi. Arnav is always afraid to loose Anjali, and the fact that she is so dependent on him keeps him in control of her life. but not Khushi he has to work doublely hard to control Khushi and the fact that he has no control on her makes him afraid of loosing her. so he has to have a symbiotic relationship with Khushi, so far Khushi has proved to be his strenght, she has been there for him, be it trying to rescue him from kidnappers, or his support in Anjalis present situation.
Arnav has yet to prove himself where Khushi needs are concern. may be this track to for that reason, to make Arnav prove whether he can standby Khushi, as she has stood by him time and again.
ToujoursPur thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
brilliant job...by the way have u read tia.o's analysis on anjali...woman behind the illusion? plz read it if u want to...it was similar to yours...and helped understand anji like urs did
jerriblank thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: N.Mussarrat

Well written and the points you put across are very true. But the CVs have made a weak attempt at execution. There are simply too many loopholes and the direction is poor. They need to focus on details, consistency and continuation. If they nail that then things will be a lot easier for them and us.


Thanks for replying! But I wanted to ask you what loopholes and inconsistency are you talking about? I'm not trying to cut your argument, I'm actually interested! Personally, I think the details are in their dialogues. I think that fact that Anjali's dialogues are pointing to this quite clearly.
Her attack that she always listens to Arnav and never questions him, her acceptance that she isn't strong, and that she doesn't WANT to be strong.

Conversly, Khushi shows the details in her actions. She pushes aside the attacks she is getting from Dadi, and she's focusing her energy on supporting her family. Even to go to the extent to bring back the man who basically destroyed her livelihood by creating these misunderstandings.

What direction do you think they should take?

Thanks!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".