What I LOVED: 3rd September 2012 - Page 3

Gr8 analysis Shalini.. also now one can understand why Arnav got touchy during initial episode at seesh mahal when khushi said " agar aap ki Di ki shaadi toot jaye tho.. Aap ki Di ke bare mein koi aise bole tho?...kya karenge aap .. boliye? hai koi jawaab? " only then he shatters the pearls of her dori.. for an answer.. so his Di also had a shaadi stoppage which caused a deep pain for him..

Originally posted by: skydome

??? The loose ends??? 1. 15 years ago - Did Anjali marry Shyam? Or was her marriage postponed/ broken because of her parents death, and at that time was Anajali's groom Shyam or someone else? When did Shyam come in the picture? If he was the origianal groom, why did it tak 15 years for Anjali to be pregnant?

>> Shyam was not the original groom. Anjali's wedding was canceled when her parents died.

Shyam and Anjali were married 3 yrs when Arnav and Khushi had first met.

2. During the events of the past (Anjali's marriage) where was Nani, Mama and Mamiji? How come Nani does not know anything about the event, about who the "aurat" was ? Why Nani is so much in the dark?

>> Nani may have been at the wedding, but Dadi obviously didn't tell her who the woman was.

3. Is Anjali the real sister of Arnav?

>> As of first and latest update, yes, Anjali is real elder sister of Arnav.

Why this question came up??

4. Who is Shyam, and when did he come in Anjali's life?

>> Buddy!! that's the big question, which may not be answered soon. That's the mystery.

As to when he came in Anjali's life - refer to Answer 1.

5. What is Khushi and her parents connection to the past scene? Or is Khushi the daughter of Garima?

>> No one knows as of now Khushi/her parents' connection to the past. As per original and latest info, Khushi is Garima's sister's daughter.

6. What is Garima's connectiont to Arnav's past?

7. If it is a murder for property - the story may be somewhat like the 'Bidai' story.

>> errmm... I'd rather not equate the story with any other.. IPK is a very different plot than most serials.

I hope the CVs get serious now and starts to tie these loose ends, and not forget ... these loose ends. They can now stop beating around the bush and get to work.

>> Buddy, with all the due respect for your view - I do feel the team is actually working and is focused on their plot. There may be issues but to say that they were 'beating around the bush' - i may not agree.

Wow fantastic analysis diii 👏 👏 👏
Loved it...

great work dear.. even i want to know the ans for every quest... shyam or his family must involved thats pakka cos he's the negative character of our show...

Very well written.Always love your post.Yesterdays episode was too good.

Wonderful post. The part "Arnav and Khushi" was the best. It brought tears in my eyes.

Originally posted by: ShaliniDp

Anjali: Nothing Remains

Once again, Anjali prepared for a happy life and ended up with nothing. She convinced herself she'd have her baby and, now with Dadi ji's help, Shyam would be back home.

Now, there is emptiness.

Anjali faced the truth of her loss. She didn't believe anyone until she saw the pain of her loss in her brother's eyes. And then, she was not consolable.

Yet, a greater pain awaits her. She has convinced herself of another lie - that Shyam loves her.

The revelation of Shyam's deceit may either break her or make her.

Some Questions...

... for which there may be no quick answers.

1. Arnav was outside the door when he overheard his mother and father arguing.

Arnav's Mom accused his father that he had an affair. She's herself seen him with 'her'.

Arnav's Dad asked 'With who?' - as thought he was genuinely confused what his wife was talking about. Now, if he was at fault, then he may have been doing a cover up.

If he wasn't at fault, then it is very much possible that just as Arnav misunderstood Khushi when he saw her with Shyam on the terrace, so did his mom.

Arnav may have been inclined to believe his Mom, because as she stated to her husband, that he never loved her.

2. Arnav had limited view of the situation between his parents from outside the door.

He heard a gunshot. Now, I may be mistaken and Arnav might have seen more. (The clippings from the past are still edited, it seems.) She told her husband about what she'd seen and then she moved out of view.

Did his Mom really commit suicide? Or did someone kill her?

3. Arnav told Khushi that his father blamed himself for his wife's death and committed suicide.

Arnav equates his Dad with Shyam. Now, if Arnav's Dad was as bad as Shyam he wouldn't kill himself out of guilt because his wife killed herself (because he had an affair). A person like Shyam would have simply mock mourned his dead wife, and then on the pretext of getting a mom for his kids, married the woman he loved.

But if he did kill himself, then he really wasn't Shyam-like. He apparently experienced guilt of which Shyam is (apparently) ignorant.

I wonder if Arnav's misunderstood his Dad too.

4. There wasn't much time difference between the deaths of Arnav's parents. Anjali was still in her wedding clothes when sitting beside her parents' bodies.

Only one gunshot is heard. How did his Dad end his life? How does Arnav know that it was out of guilt? Is it a fact that he knows or has he assumed it?

5. Arnav stated that he found rather late that the woman with whom his Dad was involved had come to his funeral.

Who told him that?

Was it public knowledge that his Dad was cheating on his Mom and with whom (the identity of the woman)? Such stuff isn't usually publicized, but yeah it's not impossible.

6. The woman, who peered from behind her veil, seemed like Garima. Whoever it was, she came with her face covered.

Public shame? Probably.

I wonder if she was afraid for her life too.

If Garima wanted to hide from public shame, it is curious that she'd tell her husband Shashi everything (especially if she'd married him after the incident). She'd want the knowledge of her past to be kept away from the possibility of having a secure and honorable future of a married life.

Following the scandal, she'd have wanted to hide. Garima, on the other hand, told Shashi her side of the story, apparently. Shashi accepts Garima's story.

Shashi, as we have seen, has a rather keen sense of judging people. As of now, it can be believed that he knows that Garima wasn't at fault OR wasn't the only one at fault.

Garima told Shashi that she did not want to lie in the past either - either she had lied, or she'd hidden from telling the truth.

Bua Ji mentions that - suddenly, Garima came into Shashi's life. Perhaps, Shashi married Garima after the Sheesh Mahal tragedy.

If so, Shashi knew of Garima's situation, knew the supposed lie or the hidden truth, and he married her. Why? To protect her? From what? Or Who?

7. What are the chances of a cheating husband meeting his girlfriend in a house was full of his family & guests on his daughter's wedding day - when some of those present actually knew that the woman was his girlfriend?

I'd say yeah there is some chance, if the man is of the same consistency as Shyam.

What are the chances of the woman (possibly Garima) to go to meet her boyfriend who was a married man with two kids, on his daughter's wedding day - when the house was full of his family & guests on his daughter's wedding day - when some of those present actually knew that she was his girlfriend?

I'd say yeah there is some chance, if the woman is of the same consistency as Shyam.

If Arnav's Dad was genuinely confused at being mistaken by his wife (for having an affair) and Garima, was who she is now - oh dear! That complicates stuff!

8. If Arnav's Dad was not involved with any woman, and Arnav's Mom was mistaken - who caused this misunderstanding?

Why do I feel there was a fourth angle involved?

Shyam is the current villain.

Who was the culprit in the past?

Two unknown people - Who is Shyam?