IP REDUX; Smoke Signals !! Second thread

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#491

Originally posted by: sumeeta

Hey Lizzy...

sorry for butting in...
but just want to say that we all need to stand at some distance from the characters to see them in totality 'coz thats how we'll see their perfection -imperfections together and wonder how lovely creations they are...rather than just breathing down their neck and starting-off the rant at the slightest surfacing of some flaw...
I agree it gets a bit too much at times and when its illogical its ok to rant-off.I too hv donen it on an occassion ...when ASR questioned Khushi why did he meet her in the first place..and that she is the cause of his sister's miseries... coz I think that went a bit too off-track..he was so in-love with Khushi ...trusting her, caring for her, feared losing her, stood by her side in front of the family...and then spoke the harshesht words ever..I think there wz some loss of integrity there... But Khushi..have'nt we known her to be in the sacrifical mode since forever...so why this bashing against her...
So, Guys..maintain a distance from the characters...like smbdy said in one of teh reduxes.."story bolne to do..."

thank u for understanding what i said fully.. u know what i love about the show.. the imperfections .. the warts and all of the characters .. love accepted with imperfections.. if the story is fashioned this way, and ppl want perfections,, then better not to view this show..

Quote

Ume Salma Kakal

@sunflower52

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#492

Originally posted by: nebuna

his character has not changed but softened
that has to happen else there s no growth in character
if he s the same pigheaded person who we ve seen a year ago
think it will become boring
just like a stage where trip catch fall was boring
this part will come in when the next track will play
now it will be the junoon part of ASR

Let's see about the junoon part I want to see how they will pull it off. I guess we will see the ASR who does not take NO for an answer and can do what he says.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tanthya

@tanthya

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#493

Originally posted by: nebuna

his character has not changed but softened
that has to happen else there s no growth in character
if he s the same pigheaded person who we ve seen a year ago
think it will become boring
just like a stage where trip catch fall was boring
this part will come in when the next track will play
now it will be the junoon part of ASR

I think Nebuna..U have put ur finger on the crux on why Khushi is not preferred by few viewer's .. while Arnav has had n is having his growth , Khushi firmly stays put with none of the events touching her , ...That's one reason she appears to have become unreal for many !!..Show the changes happening to ehr too n u will find ppl rooting for her...

Edited by tanthya - 13 years ago

Quote

Kopal

@Chani123

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#494

Originally posted by: tanthya

😲 Kops I always look out for ur posts cos there always gem hidden in them .. I did not see u , Yaara ...

For all the time u said Hi...A Big HI !!

Episode was good !!😛

😲

Thanks... 😃

I hope we will see a proper post today..

For many IPK has lost its charm.. But I dunno.. I am happy.. I was confused yesterday, but I think they are going to be just fine...

Quote

Erika

@Erika1

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#495

Originally posted by: nebuna

his character has not changed but softened
that has to happen else there s no growth in character
if he s the same pigheaded person who we ve seen a year ago
think it will become boring
just like a stage where trip catch fall was boring
this part will come in when the next track will play
now it will be the junoon part of ASR

Yes but my thoughts are that when he is dealing with outsiders, aka, the doctor, his assistant, etc he should maintain the ASR persona as per my POV.
He couldn't have changed so drastically!

Edited by Erika1 - 13 years ago

Quote

Supna9

@Supna9

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#496

If there is any significance of kkg story which she told doc n buaji said whole family is unhappy which family?

Quote

nebuna

@nebuna

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#497

Originally posted by: tanthya

Acha Girls,

M here now.. tho chalo lets start ..

Lizzy , Nebuna , & others ..

Please fill me in, if u don't mind ...

everyone have their opinion but no character is perfect
if perfect then we will def have to see other sp shows
both characters are flawed
its just we dont want to see through kushi s character

i am not a kushi fan nor asr fan
i am just ipk fan
when all the blackmailing and hate track was
justified to his character
why not take OTT behavior too
its justified to her character

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#498

Originally posted by: tanthya

Could U please explain, Geet

satya. i dont feel like typing all over again.. sorry about that,, but the crux of the matter is that redux i felt was negative this morning instead of being constructive..and the moment i felt this i with drew..the remaining u will understand once u go through the posts in the last three to four pages

Quote

Ume Salma Kakal

@sunflower52

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#499

They should show ASR soften up with Khushi and Gupta's only. For the rest he should remain what he was shown originally. The ASR which they are failing right now.

Quote

tanthya

@tanthya

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#500

Originally posted by: Erika1

Yes but my thoughts are that when he is dealing with outsiders, aka, the doctor, his assistant, etc he should maintain the ASR persona as per my POV.
He couldn't have changed so drastically!

Erika,

I agree with u on this, he shud retain the attitude when he is dealing with strangers