IP REDUX; Smoke Signals !! Second thread

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Zoyafan

@Zoyafan

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

#461

I still have an issue with the PH as far as the execution is concerned. Had they been careful, aaj TRP 2.6 nahin hota. its only because the normal viewers dont understand Khushi and her reasons for lying...agar ek substantial monologue with DM de dete toh viewers nahin confuse hote and they would not gang up against her for her lies.

After all everyone fell for this ASR and Khushi only since the beginning of the serial...but now its only the execution which sucks and hence every other day its either ASR or Khushi being bashed ...

Quote

sunshine99

@sunshine99

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#462

Originally posted by: namedx

...there is an element of consistency missing from her character. It's not her traits I'm annoyed with, but rather the portrayal of these traits and the timing of them.

Shaz you have nailed it beautifully... her character gets lost in translation... the blame lies on the out of sync element between the director and the writer...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Kopal

@Chani123

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#463

Originally posted by: namedx

Absolutely! This is where consistency was not maintained - storytelling wise. The end is going to be work out just fine, it's the means or rather the route they've taken that I've got qualms with! They've made it far too hazy and chaotic!

I feel that what they showed then was for ASR to unite with Arnav.. If we had not seen that, then his complete trust in Khushi and her words would have been too much to digest..

The whole union of souls was fromArnav's realization of khushi's importance in his life...

And maybe to hint the amount Khushi is sacrificing her happiness...

See wasn't it Arnav who always said he will sacrifice her Khushi for his Khushi...

Khushi is helping him keep his promise without even asking... Hadn't she overhear him promise that..

Quote

geetmaanluv

@geetmaanluv

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#464

Originally posted by: sunflower52
If execution of Khushi was correct then no one would need to say anything negative about Khushi.

Just imagine what the lay audience must be thinking about Khushi right now. Not good I imagine. Not everyone has time and patience to analyze the characters.

agreed.. people connect with arnav more bec he has had monologs and numerous moments of quite reflection. esp. after he does something mean to khushi.

the cv's take khushi for granted and after a huge emotional upheaval in her life she is shown to go like nothing happened. and rarely any explanation is given abt the mask she puts on...

Quote

jenshadrocks

@jenshadrocks

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#465

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

in the morning..when redux pages were full of angst against khushi.. i withdrew..I thought why justify when ppl cant see the beauty of the sketch.. see the executions have come across as pathetic.. no second views about it.but bashing like this was too irritating. there was only once.. i remember when i said something negative against the lead that is in particular..ASR..because that day was too much for me as a woman to take.. but l;ater on realised that it is the character's nature.. and that whenever arnav or khushi make mistakes.. they are made to repent for it..see khushi's repentance will come too when she finds her anchor.. and wanted to tell ppl that if they don't relate to the characters then to use the option of the remote and not to spread negativity.. i was seriously put off and disappointed with the way redux bashed khushi in the morning..

Lizzy actually love the character Khushi a lot..She is a angel yaar but morning rant was all about her emotions not conveyed properly... They are not showing her thought process as they do for ASR thats it...you know they can give some FB's and dialogues to show her concern for him..Not that we don know that she loves him...Just to justify her character for lay viewers...

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#466

Originally posted by: geetmaanluv
👏

👏👏
i wanted to write something supporting khushi but i stopped myself. bec at this point if one is questioning khushi love for arnav.. or vice versa then i think we are not watching the same serial. i totally agree with the execution prob with this ph esp. with khushi

my views will remain the same if i were a big ASR phanka..there are execution problems.. big time..i agree but this morning was the heights of negativity.sorry.. thought i would never say this about redux .. which was always balanced in its approach.. i am upfront person.. anyone would tell u that.. thought i would never post here again if it continues in the same vein.but returned because of the friends i made here..i believe in calling a spade a spade..and believe in receiving criticisms and suggestions in an equal vein

there was a question about the lay viewer finding it difficult to digest a particular lead.. wanted to ask in the morning as to how many lay viewers do we know in person.. a handful.. ,,agree they don't analyse.. but in the morning it went too far is my take..blame the creators .. not the creations is my request

Quote

Ume Salma Kakal

@sunflower52

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#467

Originally posted by: namedx

...there is an element of consistency missing from her character. It's not her traits I'm annoyed with, but rather the portrayal of these traits and the timing of them.

She has good traits but they have not turned her words into actions. The words she sprouted to La during her training days. Can not see herself doing it.

Frankly I do not like self sacrificing heroines.

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#468

Originally posted by: sunshine99

Quote

Ume Salma Kakal

@sunflower52

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#469

Originally posted by: geetmaanluv

agreed.. people connect with arnav more bec he has had monologs and numerous moments of quite reflection. esp. after he does something mean to khushi.

the cv's take khushi for granted and after a huge emotional upheaval in her life she is shown to go like nothing happened. and rarely any explanation is given abt the mask she puts on...

I am blank about Khushi, take me as a lay audience. I hardly go to the depth or over analyze a character. The only reason I have been able to connect to ASR is because his emotions and reflections are shown properly.

Quote

dramebaaz.af

@dramebaaz.af

Sparkler

+ 6

Arshi Analyzers

Posted: 13 years ago

#470

hello ladies!

About Khushi, the execution and direction was pathetic for her! There should have been monologues to justify her lying! The main forum is in a uproar!

Quote

1 ... 45 46 47 48 49 ... 91

IP REDUX; Smoke Signals !! Second thread - Page 47

Related Topics

Explore Topics