IP REDUX; Make- a - Niche (Mechanic) *updated*

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

redwine1

@redwine1

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#61

Hi am new to the forum & love the way every1 discusses the episodes ... i like all here am an ardent fan of IP ... been watching from day 1 & fav past time has been to watch old episodes ...

What i can't understand with every1's analysis .. isn't Khushi's heart already broken ... wasn't the forced marriage the biggest set back for her ...coz she doesn't know why he is being so nasty ... when she loves him so much ... clearing of the MU shud not break her heart but shud go towards mending it .. since she knows that Arnav dint know the truth ( which she has hidden) ... in a way his actions are justified since he did it to protect his sister ...

My second point is where is the question of trust .. when did Arnav ever trust Khushi ???? he has always thought that she is gold digger ... ...

For me the biggest question in this serial is whether the MU clearing will be in phases like only between the leads or will it be with the whole family ... going by the PH past record i think it will be in phases ... first between the leads ( am totally mad for Geet fan & this serial is amazingly similar ;) ) coz the moment the truth is out ... then u have to get into confrontational mode .. how long can u run with that ???

The repentance track that we all are expecting .. will it also coincide with a separation track ??? Will the raizada family let them separate even when they know the truth behind the marriage ... will Anjali let her brothers marriage break coz of her ...even if she is the reason of the marriage ???

So many ques & endless possibilities on where the story can go from here ...

Kudos to the entire team of IP ... its pretty open ended as off now ... the story can move ne place from here ...

I would love the MU clearing happening only between the leads ... since Arnav torturing Khushi was also just between them so should the repentance ...

Guys .. pls comment

Quote

newipkk

@newipkk

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: Lizzy2012

New-I answered As I felt Arnav's burden of mistakes is heavier than the gupta's...gupta's always did mistakes as they are to a certain extent naive ...Arnav is not that... AlOng with the magnitude of his mistakes

@Lizzy - Thanks for clarifying further. My whole confusion was why should Arnav apologize to Guptas for "messing" up their daughters wedding when the outcome of his actions actually have been positive. Also, do the Guptas deserve that given their behavior/ actions towards their daughters. In my opinion, intentions and outcome are more important than the action undertaken. But I respect your view about Arnav's actions here.

It is interesting that you think Arnav is not naive/ ignorant. In the context of the importance of marriage in a girl's life, he is actually more ignorant than Guptas. Also, Guptas have a higher duty towards their daughters than Arnav. So do not agree with you on who is more to blame in this sub-context. But I do agree with the forum in general that the gravity of his errors in judgement, his intentions and complete disregard for everyone else except his sister and himself make him most at fault except of course Shyam.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sree07

@sree07

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: newipkk

@Lizzy - Thanks for clarifying further. My whole confusion was why should Arnav apologize to Guptas for "messing" up their daughters wedding when the outcome of his actions actually have been positive. Also, do the Guptas deserve that given their behavior/ actions towards their daughters. In my opinion, intentions and outcome are more important than the action undertaken. But I respect your view about Arnav's actions here.

It is interesting that you think Arnav is not naive/ ignorant. In the context of the importance of marriage in a girl's life, he is actually more ignorant than Guptas. Also, Guptas have a higher duty towards their daughters than Arnav. So do not agree with you on who is more to blame in this sub-context. But I do agree with the forum in general that the gravity of his errors in judgement, his intentions and complete disregard for everyone else except his sister and himself make him most at fault except of course Shyam.

sorry to bump in

- Arnav's action's outcome has been positive! That's not a true statement I guess. The basic intention of his actions is definitely not positive. It revolves around his selfishness trait.

First payal marriage break up - Outcome was def not positive. It landed GH in soup.

Second payal - khushi wedding! - Outcome was public humiliation of GH in front of entire RM audience by Mami and the mental trauma followed.

So outcome was not positive as per gupta's. Being kind souls they may choose to forgive arnav. But apology is required IMO.

Edited by sree07 - 13 years ago

Quote

Nia

@Nia.D

Voyager

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#64

Hi folks,

Post has been updated on Page One https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/56389720

Loved the epsiode, not only cuz of the RV, but cause there was so much to decipher and write about!

Cheerio...

Nia 😊

Quote

sree07

@sree07

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#65

Originally posted by: sea.nymph
Hi folks,

Post has been updated on Page One https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/56389720

Loved the epsiode, not only cuz of the RV, but cause there was so much to decipher and write about!

Cheerio...

Nia 😊

Nia.. I think the WILL was just a copy. Main documents will not be kept so callously. It might be just a copy given by the lawyer to verify

Quote

tanthya

@tanthya

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#66

Updated, Dahlings 😊

Quote

sree07

@sree07

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#67

Originally posted by: tanthya

Updated, Dahlings 😊

thanks... I was refreshing the screen continuously... 😆. Friday ..no work..😉

Quote

Lizzy2012

@Lizzy2012

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#68

@sree-thanks for answering,my reply would be the same..intentions need to considered ...Gupta lied By omission but Arnav deliberately .
@ new-I was never talking about the sub context but the big picture reflects magnitude of Arnav's mistake