Slapstick COMEDY=Drop in TRPs-Lowest TRP in weeks

--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
So Guys,

The TRP ratings are out for the week of11th April to 17th April...and what do you know, the TRPs have dropped to 3.0 and the now IPKKND has dropped its ranking form number 4 to number 7, being upped by shows like Pavitra Rishta, CID, Balika Vadhu, and EKMMBH.

IPKKND during the wedding season had TRPs in 4s, because the track at that time was an INTENSE love story, then they went to the COMEDY track, and TRPs have dropped to 3.0.

What more proof does the Production house need to realize that there is an ISSUE here...the current story and slapstick comedy is not working. 😡

Please...Stop this track ASAP, and go back to the intense love story track!!


--Edited to add--

A reminder to CVs...IPKKND is
An INTENSELY DARK LOVE STORY of two people as different as Fire and Ice, but made only for each other, brought together by Sheer Destiny, and torn asunder by Man's need for Power, Greed, and Lust.

--Editing again to add--

3 Examples from today, where the same scene could have been executed differently to BRING in the INTENSITY instead of the comedy.

Example 1 of Missed Intensity - Toying with his food

I didn't enjoy the episode today because they stole from the intensity factor, and over loaded it with the OTT comedy factor.

i didn't like Khushitoying with his food at the cost of his health again...it doesn't make sense, and its not consistent with the ever vigilant wife who ensures that he doesn't eat sweet, so as to not fall ill...

I feel like these scenes are not well thought out...they use food at their whim, they use his health at their whim...there is no consistency.
I really feel the true Khushi character may toy with a bunch of things, but she would never play with his health. Why is the intensity in her quest to watch his diet dying at the hands of the CVs?

Example 2 of Missed Intensity - The Gupta Ladies:

The Gupta Ladies, like typical middle class families went above and beyond to make their Amir Damaad feel comfortable, trying to cater to his eating habits, and providing an environment of comfort. This would have been much better received had it not been served up in roll of comic revenge. I would have liked Arnav to recognize the love and efforts of these women, and realize the purity of the adulation they feel for their son-in-law...it would have been a humbling experience for ASR. It may have forced himself to ponder on why he think Khushi is a gold digger...how is that possible...if this is the family she comes from, and these are the values that have been instilled in her?


Instead all I saw was:

Granted that the Gupta ladies are not sophisticated and stuff..but look at all that love they were showering on Arnav, and all she did was ridicule that love today. What did Khushi gain by making her family look more stupid and low class in front of ASR?? Apne hi paair pe khuladhi maari na!!😡

This is not Khushi!! Before when she wanted to get back at him...she did it on her own...not at the cost of making anyone else look bad.

Example 3 of Missed Intensity - Arnav & Babuji Connection:

The Arnav Babuji scene...totally underplayed and depicted with such loose direction...that it made me gag!! In trying to show Arnav anger at being played by his wife...he lost his essential qualities to?? He forgot his upbringing?? Why...because showing that would have decreased the comedy element?

All i saw was a dud scene, where Arnav goes thru the motions of acknowledging her father's existence...nothing more...showing no respect at all.

What I would have liked to see:

I would have like Arnav to stay true to his upbringing, and honor that silent mutual respect and the connection that these 2 men have, by bending and taking his ashirwaad upon seeing him. This would have been an intense scene...where they both know and accept that the connection between them is the women they both love and related to...a daughter, and a wife...Khushi. That would have been intense.

Now for those of you who will argue that ASR does not bow down to anyone...let me remind you of Diwaali night...after he rejected Khushi...and hurt her, denied himself the luxury of her love...when he dropped her home and she left her wallet in his car. He came back to return that wallet, he was invited into the house...and upon entering, he took Shahi Babuji's ashirwaad...because that has been ingrained into him...a trait instilled into him by his Mother...one that he would not walk away from...that is the true Arnav.

For those of you that argue that Arnav is not an inherently religious being...i beg to differ there too. He may publicly not practice it, but he is familiar with all religious rites and obligations, and when push does come to shove...he honors them, because, again this is another trait instilled in him by his mother.


Its his fight with himself that brings in the intensity factor. Its her going out of her way to make his life easier, more comfortable..like bringing the plant that makes this relationship and this current struggle in their marriage intense.

Its his inability to explain how she can be so sweet, humble, caring, giving and innocent that makes the scenes INTENSE...

By intensity...we are not simply asking for LOVEY DOVEY scenes...we want intense hatred too...we want intense fights too...and of course we want some pure magical RABBA VE moments that happen as a result of denying these feelings...

Not the forces Rabba ve we got today with the Holding hand during Rangoli dance!!

Edited by --Nargis-- - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

130

Views

8.9k

Users

53

Likes

390

Frequent Posters

SankiPagal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
the past 2 weeks were so freaking boring according to the written updates.. thank god i didnt watch it on tv... i have stopped watching it on tv frm past 2 weeks
incandescent thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
UPDATED...

IPKKND during the wedding season had TRPs in 4s, because the track at that time was an INTENSE love story, then they went to the COMEDY track, and TRPs have dropped to 3.0.

What more proof does the Production house need to realize that there is an ISSUE here...the current story and slapstick comedy is not working.

You've said it all Nags !! I don't know what it will take for the cv's to realize this !!

What are they waiting for ?? 😕

They got it right in the past but now they are just not able to do it.


Edited by incandescent - 13 years ago
cantdoit thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 2 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
WOW. Your post just reminded me of the those times during the wedding episodes. Boy were those good times. It's ridiculous how good those episodes were and how much I enjoyed watching IPKKND then. I miss them so so much. They kinda used to make my days. Completely agree with you. It's about time. This is formulaic soap opera strategy, this dragging thing. Kinda had expected better from them.
SunoNa123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
They seem like they dont bother about TRPs.. They are back to OTT ness again.

Are they aiming to slip to TRP 2??

slapstick comedy is just not working.. Its rather irritating
--Nargis-- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: vaishiksg

the past 2 weeks were so freaking boring according to the written updates.. thank god i didnt watch it on tv... i have stopped watching it on tv frm past 2 weeks



I know what you mean...lately there is nothing to miss if you didn't watch the episodes...written updates are enough to see of the story has moved or not...UGH!!
shaam91 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
:\
low trp for continued period of time=> SP bloody axes the show!!:\
hope PH learns a lesson!
soniav thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
today's episode...sooo boring...khushi was annoying...if there is hope,that is barun sobti...is this they call 'comedy'...pls think again😡
music1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Slapstick comedy and IPKKND do not gel well...its better for the show if they stick to what they claimed to be in the beginning of the show.TRP are gonna drop more if they do not redeem the original track...but guess all our pleas will fall on deaf ears...there is nothing to miss in the show nowadays...
Edited by music1 - 13 years ago
gulaal1007 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
The TRP is going down mainly because IPL starts at 8:00 pm and no one misses the beginning of it. But then after some time if the match is slow people stop watching IPL and move back to serials. So the main losers are the 8:00 pm slot serials.
But then again it is the duty of production house to bring back viewers and this track is not helping at all. Story CV, story. At least start the process of Arnav knowing the truth! Come one, buck up! 😡

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".