Ishana's Re- entry In IB : Thanks to SSO - Page 4

Originally posted by: .bintAli.

Hello, dear 😊

You seem to have put some thoughts into this and I hope you don't mind me disagreeing with your theory. I don't mean any harm or offence and I will keep it short! 😉

Firstly, the Oberois coming down this early in the show amd before vanvaas doesn't make sense to me. Them losing everything should happen with a real dhamaaka and to the right time - which definitely is not now. And how could they all live with Anika? Anika can barely take care of herself and Sahil...

Secondly, which is my main concer - Shivaay hiring Ishana. Sorry, but just no. That would be one major character assassination, imo. Let's not forget that if there is something Shivaay puts above his obsession for family name and power, it's his brothers. For all three of them, they come first and everything else second. Ishana hurt Om, insulted their family and alongside Shivaay also Om and Rudra. Let's not forget that this is the same man who was ready to ruin Anika due to a meresuspicion that she leaked the chip which almost cost Om his life; here toh he knows that Ishana deliberately planned to hurt his brother. Why would Shivaay even consider taking her help? The SSO I know wouldn't even entertain such a thought. It goes against his character - heck, we have discussed a lot of times that Shivaay might be the one with Ishana (like Ani-Ru and Om-Soumya) but came to the conclusion that that would not be possible without ruining Shivaay's character(as long as Ish hasn't had a redemption) - so, a big No from me because I am very sensitive to the characterization of the brothers.

And lastly, and I don't mean to offend, but why should Shivaay trust her "conning" abilities? Let's be honest here: Even Rudra figured out she was a fraud within minutes of hearing about her. The most naive out of them. Anyone would think a 100 times over before hiring her after knowing this 😆

They can bring Ishana back however they like but please not at the cost of ruining one of the brothers. (Sorry for any typos, am not on my laptop).

Originally posted by: MFRanjini

The first thing that I disagree is Shivaay hiring Ishaana

Because

1. Shivaay loves Om so much, he has seen how Ishaana made Om sad. He will always try to keep Ishana away from his family.

2. Ishana couldn't cheat Om, she was captured by ShivRu... she is not a good con artist then why will Shivaay hire her?

I will be happy if Ishaana comes back as good girl.

Originally posted by: Illuminati07

LOL.. None of you offended me... Yea I told you before I cannot accept one chappal. I need a pair and stilettos are of no use either.. I'll just have to gift it to my sister🤣

As I said this was one ridiculous train of thought... And your points have a great weightage,... I mentioned in my post itself, CVs are the gods of the show.. They can show anything if trps demand it.. we have Ishana character assassination as a proof.

My main thought process behind the vanvas as u say, was only a saving face as far as Ishana is concerned..

I agree that Shivaye hiring Ishana will be inconsistent with Shivaye character but then again so will Ishkara,, A person like Om falling for Ishana is a major character assassination.

Its not like I disagree with you, I couldnt agree more with you guys. I'm no more vanvas pro then you are (not because of the reasons you sighted, they didnt strike me until now 🤣 but because I want this to be a little different)

As I mentioned before Cvs hardly consider minor character inconsistencies if they think the story demands it. When Gul said they were revamping Ishana, I was hoping they dont create another Anika for we already have two Anika's in the show (one whose name is saumya) And then I was like , 'what if they go about this way' Either which ways it was an errant thought.. I never expected it to take off till 4 pages before some sane voices spoke🤣

Btw the four/ five of you who commented before, throw the other pair..

Originally posted by: Illuminati07

@crazy4mayur

I hope something big comes out of that code thing.. at least with regards to Tia.. Its been so long that Shitya have been hanging around without any major developments to their relationship ..

Btw is it me or is there a possibility that the masked guy Tia brought in was actually Gayatri.. (And I am not saying it because the word gayatri has "guy" in it (pronunciation wise at least)