Suffering from Amnesia, Are we?

LadyLaLa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Finally, I got the time to watch the last 2 episodes of IKRS where Vips confronts Dhani. What surprised me was Vips asking Dhani why she did not return tohim? Vips complaining aloud that Dhani has forgotten the promises they made together? Are you serious Viplav? Have you forgotten that it was you who dragged her out of Ayodhya? Have you forgotten you drove her to the Ashram to face alone the demons that you call your family? It's highly ridiculous to see the way he kept asking Dhani why she did not return to him. Viplav's character is suffering from Trauma which has erased his memory or the writers of the serial are suffering from amnesia. Why is Viplav trying to question the actions of Dhani when he told her aloud and clear that their relationship had ended and refused to hear her side of the story. CVs please pay attention to the script so that there is continuity.

I loved the way Vips told Kameeni to get lost. I wish he had told her so eons ago. That damsel lusting after Viplav is damn annoying. I guess they are desperate measures of a desperate girl to get laid 😃

As far as characterisation, I will stand with Dhani. She did the right thing by telling him that she does not love him anymore. What is the point in hankering after someone who left you on the lurch when you needed his support? What was the point in living with someone who is not willing to lend their ears - to hear her side of the story.


This story is ridden with holes. . Why has Viplav not investigated the bomb blast, why hasn't Viplav searched for answers to find out why Dhani behaved the way she did with DT.

Regarding the latest entrants to the serial, I like the acting of Parshia (do not know the actors name) but have no comments about the acting skills of Dhani. Even though her emotions are improving by the day she still comes across rigid and stoic. She has to make tremendous improvements to get accepted as the new Dhani.

Why can't Vips be the smarter lawyer he is? Why can't he put two and two together to figure out Vidha is his own flesh and blood?

CVs are making Kameeni the smartest of the lot because she figured out the moment she heard the child's name.

Film Farm has created a new zoo.The only thing they fail to realise is zoos all over the wold are outdated and are being shut down 😆

Edited by LadyLaLa - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1k

Users

11

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

Julianne thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Good comment..I agree with all your points, I've been wondering myself..especially about Viplavs total lack of curiosity about the bomb,Dasharath etc.
awida thumbnail
Deal or No Deal Thumbnail 12th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Nice post.
I didn't watch the show since 4 months..but watched the last 2 episodes too.

I think cvs just want the MU to continue. They don't give Dhani anything to say except some lies. If Dhani felt that she was right ..so why didn't she attack him back and throw all this on his face?

Any way..it is just a show. and what matters is keeping the viewers hooked, and I am one of those who won't give up now that Viplav, Dhani and Vidha came face to face.
fahmed thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: LadyLaLa

Finally, I got the time to watch the last 2 episodes of IKRS where Vips confronts Dhani. What surprised me was Vips asking Dhani why she did not return tohim? Vips complaining aloud that Dhani has forgotten the promises they made together? Are you serious Viplav? Have you forgotten that it was you who dragged her out of Ayodhya? Have you forgotten you drove her to the Ashram to face alone the demons that you call your family? It's highly ridiculous to see the way he kept asking Dhani why she did not return to him. Viplav's character is suffering from Trauma which has erased his memory or the writers of the serial are suffering from amnesia. Why is Viplav trying to question the actions of Dhani when he told her aloud and clear that their relationship had ended and refused to hear her side of the story. CVs please pay attention to the script so that there is continuity.

I loved the way Vips told Kameeni to get lost. I wish he had told her so eons ago. That damsel lusting after Viplav is damn annoying. I guess they are desperate measures of a desperate girl to get laid 😃

As far as characterisation, I will stand with Dhani. She did the right thing by telling him that she does not love him anymore. What is the point in hankering after someone who left you on the lurch when you needed his support? What was the point in living with someone who is not willing to lend their ears - to hear her side of the story. i agree with your points.


This story is ridden with holes. . Why has Viplav not investigated the bomb blast, why hasn't Viplav searched for answers to find out why Dhani behaved the way she did with DT.

Regarding the latest entrants to the serial, I like the acting of Parshia (do not know the actors name) but have no comments about the acting skills of Dhani. Even though her emotions are improving by the day she still comes across rigid and stoic. She has to make tremendous improvements to get accepted as the new Dhani.

Why can't Vips be the smarter lawyer he is? Why can't he put two and two together to figure out Vidha is his own flesh and blood?

CVs are making Kameeni the smartest of the lot because she figured out the moment she heard the child's name.

Film Farm has created a new zoo.The only thing they fail to realise is zoos all over the wold are outdated and are being shut down 😆

Edited by fahmed - 9 years ago
tahera57 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
hi TM, I like many others was not watching the show regularly but now reading people's comments I have gathered VT treated Dhani badly , he also slapped her , now he's asking why she hid from him she survived , I think if Dhaani doesn't say anything at least Dulaari should remind him in no uncertain terms how he behaved with her daughter, she deserves to after all the suffering they had to endure probably after leaving banaras
premparbat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Hello Lady , a post from you ... A rare occasion , I keep away from the forum lately but your post tempted me to respond .

The writing of this show is its downfall . After the first maybe 50 episodes the writers have been scrambling to create a smooth flowing show. Trps have been blamed but I think otherwise . So many loopholes that are hard to keep up with .

The biggest victim has been the character of Viplav . He has been dumbed down so much right from the time when Trip told him someone in your family is responsible for your dads death to Why is wife is stressed in the days before the blast ... So it's not a surprise that he has conveniently forgotten how he threw her out .. He did not even mention it ... Did not think of apologizing ...

Kamini was made to be the smartest more than DT , KT or anyone else . Convinient right ...even now planting the thought of a son ... Wonder if there really is one ?

As got VIPs behavior towards Kamini I saw it repeatedly just to soothe my heart but honestly if he does not get along with her they can't he divorce her ... Specially now when he knows his first wife is still alive . But NO we the audience is stupid ..we can digest anything .

Bottom line dint question anything just ENJOY if you can .
Nuttyme thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
You know ratna ... I have a different view to the whole scenario...
1).. Why dint Viplav see his stressed wife... Why did he dump her? Ok let's face the answer... Viplav always stood by dhaani. Even in the night classes he kept asking but dhaani Wundt budge... So he investigated and got the truth out. Even when dhaani went to complain about dt... He stood by her. At every distress she was ... He stood by her. That was his impossible love for dhaani.
It's obvious that he would get annoyed if he sees her behaving rudely with the most respected man (act to him).
Viplav to me is the most realistic charactar on screen... Hence I am able to accept his flaws. It's human... We do it so many times in our lives.
2)... If you watched yesterday's epi... He very clearly asks kamine... Why is it necessary for her to be around everytime when he is with dhaani... That's a clue...nth at kaminee was always a third person in his circle. Neither did he love her nor will he ever. Circumstances in which he agreed to marry her is def a mystery .

3)... Realize that in the last epi before leap... What Viplav said and what dhaani heard were too separate things.. So whom will you fault here. Kaminee. As far I see... Kaminee is nothing to Viplav. He would rather die wit dhaani and her memories than sharing a bed with kaminee.

4).. What stops dhaani from voicing her discontent. Give him a reason and tell him why she doesn't love him anymore. Cmon dhaani... Viplav has been crystal clear... Never hidden facts. But dhaani has always... So she is also equally flawed. As charactars they are real.

Coming to story writers... I hope they have some grand plan... As much we think... And better than what we think. They have disappointed me always... But I am still hooked to this show coz of Viplav and dhaani and mishal as Viplav.
With the reigns now with the producer... Hope she creates some valid storyline.
JaZzs thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
completely agree with ur every point...

viplav will never put two n two together on why dhaani behaved that way or the missed cd case...i have totally given up on that..

atleast for the confrontation part i expected dhaani to retort him once how he broken the ties and dumped her ... but they seem to be completely brushing that episode also under carpet...neither viplav has thought about it once even when he goes on saying how easily dhaani said she did not love him breaking the promises nor dhaani has ever recalled that scene...whenever she gets flasbcaks it's only vip-kamini scene and not how viplav himself also said those words to her ,they are trying to make viewers think dhaani leaving viplav was only due to her mu and vip was totally a victim of kamini's saazish ... so they will never make dhaani to confront him for that (may be since they think they won't be able to justify viplav on that)... they just want the viewers also to forget that episode 🤢
Edited by -JaZ- - 9 years ago
LadyLaLa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Nuttyme

You know ratna ... I have a different view to the whole scenario...

1).. Why dint Viplav see his stressed wife... Why did he dump her? Ok let's face the answer... Viplav always stood by dhaani. Even in the night classes he kept asking but dhaani Wundt budge... So he investigated and got the truth out. Even when dhaani went to complain about dt... He stood by her. At every distress she was ... He stood by her. That was his impossible love for dhaani.
It's obvious that he would get annoyed if he sees her behaving rudely with the most respected man (act to him).
Viplav to me is the most realistic charactar on screen... Hence I am able to accept his flaws. It's human... We do it so many times in our lives.
2)... If you watched yesterday's epi... He very clearly asks kamine... Why is it necessary for her to be around everytime when he is with dhaani... That's a clue...nth at kaminee was always a third person in his circle. Neither did he love her nor will he ever. Circumstances in which he agreed to marry her is def a mystery .

3)... Realize that in the last epi before leap... What Viplav said and what dhaani heard were too separate things.. So whom will you fault here. Kaminee. As far I see... Kaminee is nothing to Viplav. He would rather die wit dhaani and her memories than sharing a bed with kaminee.

4).. What stops dhaani from voicing her discontent. Give him a reason and tell him why she doesn't love him anymore. Cmon dhaani... Viplav has been crystal clear... Never hidden facts. But dhaani has always... So she is also equally flawed. As charactars they are real.

Coming to story writers... I hope they have some grand plan... As much we think... And better than what we think. They have disappointed me always... But I am still hooked to this show coz of Viplav and dhaani and mishal as Viplav.
With the reigns now with the producer... Hope she creates some valid storyline.



Thank you Julianne, Awida, Fahmend, Tahera & Ratna for your posts. Appreciate your responses.

@Nuttyme, you have some valid points here.

My grouse is that Viplav is shown to be intelligent only at times while the villains are shown to be smarter than a leading lawyer - all the time.

Vips had blind faith in his wife. Her righteous nature had been put to test not once but many times. This has been evident to Viplav. Therefore the character of the girl called Dhani is tried, tested and True. Even though he was curious about her night outings, not once did he suspect her to be unfaithful. Viplav knew that even though Dulari was not well to do, she has instilled a good qualities in Dhani.

Yes its human to err. But Dhani tried not once but many times to explain matters to him many times. Not once was he willing to listen to what she had to say. We can also let this pass by. When the last MU occurred between the leads, they made a pact to always standby each other no matter what and to hear the other out. But we did not see him stand by his promise.

As you mention above he too is human and like us he too is bound to err. But then, why those questions today? It should not come as a surprise that Dhani did not want him to know that she was still alive. Why would she? Who would want to go back to a husband who unceremoniously dumped her?. What guarantee would she have that he will listen to her. What is the guarantee that he and his family will not turn around to say that the widows set fire to their own ashram to garner sympathy?

Writers are to be blamed here. They are not consistent with the charaterisation of Viplav. From time to time they bestow spark of intelligence to Viplav only to fuse it the next moment. If he did smell a fish why does he not probe Kaminini's return? He seems to be dropping the ball on the many clues which when explored, could lead to the mischief maker.


mthiru thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Nice post. Disappointed with last 2 days episodes as the CVS completely killed what was good and admirable left in our much loved character of VIP. It's no secret how we all love VIP mostly because of mishal's portrayal. But I was so waiting for him to repent his actions both physical and verbal towards dhani even before this stupid leap. But he didn't once recall that action in his mind and feel sorry maybe then his question to dhani would have been easier to accept. All his anguish in past 2 episodes seems pointless as were the ones done by Eisha before the leap. Both did a great job as actors but the scenes added nothing to storyline. So much talent wasted on weak script.
They dumbed down VIP and dhani for km so much.
Ever since VIP brought dhani into his family he was not standing up for her at all. Dhanis education track was a nightmare. I mean everyone including VIP made dhani feel bad for being uneducated. He should have helped dhani instead he behaved selfishly and offer to teach km!! Err so angry with that dbhua how much she humiliated dhani and VIP was nowhere to protect her. Worst butchering of chracter. Regarding night school I think VIP should have been responsible and questioned dhani and km why they did this. Come on it was so foolish to See him act supportive and lovey dovey, when he should have questioned km and ask y she send dhani to night school and all that. Then he should have exposed km. But all he did was too praise her help for what??
Don't let me start with that judge molestation drama what was the point behind all this? Where is dt for who the separation and leap happend? They killed all widow's, replaced FL, butchered ML chracter, made the leads parent to a 5yr old child by taking a unwanted leap. But still not exposing any villains??
This is not impossible love of VIP for dhani rather the impossible love of ph for kamine..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".