Glad to see Alisha and Udit booted

These two were the worst judges in II3. Alisha was completely clueless about how the contestant performed. She had no idea if someone was singing on key or off. Her contribution was worse than zero.

Udit on the other hand lacks the personality to be a judge. He went overboard being polite and his analysis was superficial.

Kailash Kher (a very, very talented and trained singer) along with Sonali Bendre will be good replacements. Sonali will focus on presentation while Kailash can focus on technical aspects.

Besides...it's always a pleasure to see Sonali's radiant smile and compelling eyes.

Don't you think?

kailash kher wud b a gud addition to the judges panel...sonali bendre im not so sure abt...wish it had been sumone frm the music fraternity...another MD or singer...

Originally posted by: addyydda

kailash kher wud b a gud addition to the judges panel...sonali bendre im not so sure abt...wish it had been sumone frm the music fraternity...another MD or singer...

But you already have Anu Malick as the MD, Kailash as singer and JA as lyricist. What you need now is a person who can provide guidance in performance. II claims that this show is not ONLY about singing but performing infront of an audience. Sonali will help with that aspect.

judging the perf is fine but she has no background of muzik...im sure there r ppl in the muzik industry who wud b just as capable of judging the perf...we'll have to wait n c how she is as a judge in a singin compt(coz singin does cum over perf)...else we'll have the same prob as with alisha n farah to a certain xtent...anyway just my opinion...lets wait n c

i think the judges selection is good 👏 wish sonu was back but i am also happy that alisa is not there

yeh its good to hear that Kailash Kher will be judging! 😃
and theres no alisha this time! with her weirdest comments! 😕

but hmmmm.... not really sure about Sonali..... 😳


@miggie - yeh me too! - wish sonu was bck this year!

Kailash is a good choice...but Sonali...even i a not comfortable... 😛

We need sumone jisko sur taal aur leh ki samajh ho...aur jo ghalatiyan pinpoint kar sake sahi se..

I didnt think Uditji was that bad of a judge.. but yes he was TOOO nice and no one would ever let him talk ... Kailash would be a good judge but I dunno about Sonali... i think theres gonan be ALOT of fights again ...
I think Uditji would be good in lil champs or something where he does not have to be strict or outspoken 😃

ABout Alisha.... NO COMMENT 😆

aww im soo happy ALISHA & UDIT r booted out frm dis yr II
they both were da worst judge ever 👏

but i wish sonu also was thr as we all kno he is da best judge ever..donno wat to say abt sonali 😕 jus wondering how cum she is thr ?😕

Originally posted by: SonPan

I didnt think Uditji was that bad of a judge.. but yes he was TOOO nice and no one would ever let him talk ...

Yup he wasnt bad....and the bolded part is the reason why he didnt click..!!

At times his comments were to influenced by the rest...not his own..!!!

But....I'll miss hsi...'lekin'...😆