coolmale3k thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Hello friends. I wanted ask a general question, without any offense to Prashant fans or Amit fans. I followed all final galas of II3 and to my judgement, they both were awesome. But still I think that Amit was going on a better track than Prashant. Three times judges and audience asked him to repeat his song. In finals judges gave him a standing ovation and he was fully supported on internet forums. On the other hand, Prashant was sometimes critisized by judges, Javed Akhter said him that his voice is not polised and i guess he was also in bottom 4 in some galas. And now after winning and becoming Indian Idol, I have noticed that on the forums people are still talking about Amit, on every website still a lot are favoring Amit.
My question is that what was the key factor that gave Prashant an edge on Amit? and if majority voted for Prashant, then why Amit is still bring favored?
My friends, I don't live in India and I don't really know that why people still support Amit whereas Prashant got the majority of votes.
Please my friends I didn't intend to be offensive to anyone. I really congratulate Prashant and his fans for choosing him II3.

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

Kanchhi_ thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Why not him??? my question to you....
scared beauty thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

i couldn't understand your main qs'' why prashant"?? 😕..both of them are gud singers.amit is a better singer so, maybe ppl like him more but prashant is not as bad as some ppl say cuz i have seen loadz of ppl like him. both have loadz of fans but the reason prashant won might be that he got more votes from the police department. maybe loadz of ppl like amit cuz he was not the winner. i mean, seriously, amit was better singer than prashant. the fact that the amit was better is the main reason ppl like amit more than parashant ????

oh yea, you find less prashant's fan here is cuz the ppl who voted dun visit this forum much.( guessed) cuz most of them were nepalese and it's indian forum.???

Edited by scared beauty - 18 years ago
movieman1111 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: coolmale3k

Hello friends. I wanted ask a general question, without any offense to Prashant fans or Amit fans. I followed all final galas of II3 and to my judgement, they both were awesome. But still I think that Amit was going on a better track than Prashant. Three times judges and audience asked him to repeat his song. Infinals judges gave him a standing ovationand he was fully supported on internet forums. On the other hand, Prashant was sometimes critisized by judges, Javed Akhter said him that his voice is not polised and i guesshe was also in bottom 4 in some galas.And now after winning and becoming Indian Idol, I have noticed that on the forums people are still talking about Amit, on every website still a lot are favoring Amit. My question is that what was the key factor that gave Prashant an edge on Amit?and if majority voted for Prashant, then why Amit is still bring favored? My friends, I don't live in India and I don't really know that why people still support Amit whereas Prashant got the majority of votes.Please my friends I didn't intend tobe offensive to anyone. I really congratulate Prashant and his fans for choosing him II3.



Welcome to the forum buddy, but you seem to have a view that whatever you see is right. You have given your answer in your question itself. The reasond is just like you liked Amit performance better than Prashants, MOST of the people liked Prashants performance better than Amits. Simple. Judges were just four people out of millions.
bandschanchali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: coolmale3k

Hello friends. I wanted ask a general question, without any offense to Prashant fans or Amit fans. I followed all final galas of II3 and to my judgement, they both were awesome. But still I think that Amit was going on a better track than Prashant. Three times judges and audience asked him to repeat his song. Infinals judges gave him a standing ovationand he was fully supported on internet forums. On the other hand, Prashant was sometimes critisized by judges, Javed Akhter said him that his voice is not polised and i guesshe was also in bottom 4 in some galas.And now after winning and becoming Indian Idol, I have noticed that on the forums people are still talking about Amit, on every website still a lot are favoring Amit. My question is that what was the key factor that gave Prashant an edge on Amit?and if majority voted for Prashant, then why Amit is still bring favored? My friends, I don't live in India and I don't really know that why people still support Amit whereas Prashant got the majority of votes.Please my friends I didn't intend tobe offensive to anyone. I really congratulate Prashant and his fans for choosing him II3.




u are so foolish. do u think that all people use internet? because you use forums in the internet, u think every people in the world use the forums. so stupid of you to raise this question 😆
coolmale3k thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: bandschanchali




u are so foolish. do u think that all people use internet? because you use forums in the internet, u think every people in the world use the forums. so stupid of you to raise this question 😆

I was just taking a general idea from the internet about the thinking and judgement of indian people. U r right not everybody uses internet, but if 2% of population uses internet, then majority in that should be with prashant which is i guess a common sense...but it is not the case. I have even seen people posting some topics saying to boycott sony tv because they played with people emotions. One person just mentioned that prashant is from police so he won, so what about his voice? performance? indian idol is of singing and performance and not of occupation.

VaRnI4Ever thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Both of 'em are great singers!! but the janta decided to make Prashant our next II. Hope that answers your question
~Poonam~ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
i think it should be like 1 vote per person just like when we vote for r president 😆
SolidSnake thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
How about one vote per tel no or an IP address.
abru07 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
Simple answer, because Amit, Deepali, Puja, Parleen, and Emon are better singers than Prashant. And there are gonna be liked more; no matter whoever gets the title based on bulk regional voting.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".