Siddh - can we have one more petition - Page 4

yeah he was rude to ankita also one day sayin tht a singer shud be chosen..not a person who has 50% singing and 50% performance...so i guess JA is doing it occasionally? 😕

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

i'm no anki fan and i never liked her singing but still even to my ears that day the critisisam ankita got seemed harsh. .

Then why didn't you make a topic on that? Why should it be questioned when we are talking about this particular incident which happened today?

Did any judge ever tell any contestant that he would reach nowhere?

Originally posted by: ManaliS

i see 😆😆😆

haha....i was so happy mini mentioned it....lolllllllllllllll 😆

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Then why didn't you make a topic on that? Why should it be questioned when we are talking about this particular incident which happened today?

Did any judge ever tell any contestant that he would reach nowhere?

exactly...no body stopped ankita fans from making topics on that issue....
btw i dun even remember when it was...

n alisha said that in context to II..that we are looking for a singer...javed ji said u cannot become anything...there is a huge difference..think abt it..!

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Then why didn't you make a topic on that? Why should it be questioned when we are talking about this particular incident which happened today?

Did any judge ever tell any contestant that he would reach nowhere?

😆😆😆yeah i remember dat too but i see if i had made post abt it in a good way also i wud hv blamed..so ididnt do it 😆

Originally posted by: ManaliS

exactly...no body stopped ankita fans to make such topics...

n alisha said that in context to II..that we are looking for a singer...javed ji said u cannot become anything...there is a huge difference..think abt it..!

priya aint sayin it as an ankita fan..she is just stating the fact..

Originally posted by: *allure*

yeah he was rude to ankita also one day sayin tht a singer shud be chosen..not a person who has 50% singing and 50% performance...so i guess JA is doing it occasionally? 😕

u said it urself...50-50....that has even been said about emon....that emon is just a singer...not a performer.....but we never said anything about that...

but now he goes....no future at all....did any1 ever tell ankita, or any1 else...they have no future in music???

hows that the same thing? 😕

that day javed did not say that 50% thing to ankita he didnt name her or anything. annu said we want 50% singing 50% performance and javed disagreed there was no mention of ankita it was only alisha who said ankita isnt better than the others in terms of singing hence she should be the one who should get eliminated

Originally posted by: srk_lover

u said it urself...50-50....that has even been said about emon....that emon is just a singer...not a performer.....but we never said anything about that...

but now he goes....no future at all....did any1 ever tell ankita, or any1 else...they have no future in music???

hows that the same thing? 😕

but tht vote out epi was quite harsh on ankita i agree..tho this n dat dun hv any connection wht i mean is JA was harsh on ankita tht day too..

coz when they said emon is safe among bottom 4..also JA said..ppl voted him cozhe a singer n coz ppl want him ..n not aperformer(which was against ankita)

Originally posted by: *allure*

priya aint sayin it as an ankita fan..she is just stating the fact..

I am Amit fan but this is not about any fans. This is a topic on Javed ji's take on Emon. Why to drag other names and incidents? I have seen and read discussions on said incident on II section.