Singers of Indian Idol and SRGMP!!! - Page 2

SRGMP singers r definitely better...dats because dey actually get training for der gurus whereas II contestants dunt get dat advantage. But I prefer to watch II cuz der is more emotional atachment....actually I only started watching cuz of EMON 😳..all my hope is in Emon and Amit 👏 i liek SRGMP cuz der main focus is singing and i liek II cuz it gives a chance for untrained singers to show der talent

i love both the shows but i agree tht saregamapa singers are so much betta!!!

Originally posted by: xaly

hi i dont usualy coment but... anywais
he singers in saregamapa are reaaly good!!! but i prefer watching indan idol...
saregamapa looks really cheap!!!
look at the way they dress their singers, the make up, its horrible!!!

ya i agree wth u buddy the contestants dance too horribly while one contestant sings why to show other contestants dancing awefully though they dunno dancing at all

i like their singing but it looks too funny when those ppl dance becoz atleast if they dunno to dance they shd not do it but it looks too funny when i saw aneek dancing like an hell last week he is an gud singer and i like his singing but his dancing makes me laughh like an hell

and the show really looks some wht scripted and the studio and the environiument wont look so decnt as indian idol looks

and the presentation of indian idol is far ahead and the results announcement of indian idol ius much much gud thn saregamapa

singers r gud like mauli,raja and poonam but the studio and the dances make it too horrible and the show looks more of an scripted thn an reality show making all stupid love stories especially tht himesh he makes all stupid love stories and it looks more bad to drag the love stories in talent hunts

in singing saregamapa is better and as an show indian idol is far ahead of saregamapa

[no offence to saregamapa fans i just stated my opinion]

yea sa re ga ma pa singers r lyke extremely talented, the only 1 from II3 that belongs there is emon

yeh i really belive that saregamapa is much better and its fun to watch and indian idol is the samething but the best show i like is saraegamapa

Ofcourse srgmp is much much better than II ... almost all sa re ga ma pa singers have already been selected to do playback for different music directors whereas ii singers r nowhere to be seen except for Abhijeet sawant..srgmp r producing genuine singers not just stage show which u watch for an hour waste ur money, like it as long as its telecasted n once its over u realize tht uve wasted three or four months of ur life being a diehard fan of sum nautanki who entertained u n just disappeared cuz he/she gave enough trp to the show n now he/she is not needed n have been thrown out 😛 n no music director approached em n they never really made name either in the playback singing nor in the concerts n live evenings

Originally posted by: amnalatif

Ofcourse srgmp is much much better than II ... almost all sa re ga ma pa singers have already been selected to do playback for different music directors whereas ii singers r nowhere to be seen except for Abhijeet sawant..srgmp r producing genuine singers not just stage show which u watch for an hour waste ur money, like it as long as its telecasted n once its over u realize tht uve wasted three or four months of ur life being a diehard fan of sum nautanki who entertained u n just disappeared cuz he/she gave enough trp to the show n now he/she is not needed n have been thrown out 😛 n no music director approached em n they never really made name either in the playback singing nor in the concerts n live evenings

ryt amna ryt

voice of indya bhii

Srgmp focuses on singing...and some of them even have had offers from bollywood...
so Srgmp singers are better...I mean they are soo talented
And not allll singers are trained...Poonam isn't trained...sumedha isn't...harpreet isn't...
and btw wasn't puja trained since she was 6...
srgmp is for everyone not just trained singers as some of the members have posted ...but the best voice and singing is appreciated...

II is good but it missed out on some of the fab singers and it focuses wayyy too much on performance and they sing so little😕 I mean for a minute...how can u kno they sing gud if they dunt complete their song but still I like amit n emon!!!
Srgmp rocks!!!