Performance v/s Singing.... sum facts!

ria_dgr8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
hey guyz
im sick and tired of this performance v/s singin discussion!! and i want 2 finish it once and for all

just answer my questions honestly! b very honest and the performance v/s singing chapter will b closed once and for all but u hav 2 b really honest!

Q.1 Are the songs in the music album recorded in a recording studio before the music video is shot???

Q.2 If a besura person with a a so so voice wins indian idol can even the best music director make him sureela within the given time i think which is 1 months in which songs hav 2 b recorded?

Q.3 If the singer is bessura wont the quality of songs suffer as well ? the music director will hav 2 make easy easy compositions so tht the besura idol can sing it so so!

Q.4 If no then will u buy a music album with horrible songs which will be equivalent 2 noise pollution but with excellent dance movements OR will u buy a movie dvd of hrithik roshan or shahid kapoor which has excellent dance movements as well as gr8 music???

Q.5 What will b the future of our besura idol? we knw tht suhit couldnt sing! he was out and tht was a blessing for him as he has got a kit kat ad and has a bright future as a model or VJ! but the besura idol will b unsuccessful in watever he does later on as people will hate him for the elimination of deserving ppl!

Q.6 Apart from the indian idol music album cant these singers use models in their music video instead of featuring in their own albums?

Q.7 A music album is not complete without sad and romantic songs! what dance 2 u think tht besura idol will do in such songs 2 hide his besuri voice??

Q.8 In live concerts what dance movements do Lataji or Ashaji or AR Rahman or Udit narayan do?? still their concerts r super hit! what dance did alisha do when she was performing in indian idol??

Q.9 what dance movements does Sonu ji or Sunidhi does in his concerts? they just interact with the audience thts it and perform as well as they can! its the magic of their voice and sur tht attracts people!

Q.10 if u dont wanna hear a person singing then why not just go and see rakhi sawant dancin?? im sure she will dance betta than any besura idol!!

Q.11 If not so gr8 dancers such as sunny deol etc can be made 2 dance in movies cant a gud choreographers like ganesh hegde , shamak dawar etc make the sureela indian idol do sum gud lively performance???

i didnt want 2 hurt anybodies feelings i just wanted 2 present my point of view
if i hav hurt anybody then im really sorry! no offence to anyone!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

455

Users

2

Frequent Posters

ria_dgr8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Answers

1. yes!

2.no he cant

3. yes it will

4. a movie dvd

5. besura idol will just get hatered of ppl jst like sandeep got!

6. yes they can

7. no dance can b done in such songs

8. they dont dance

9. its just their magical voice tht gives them the confidence 2 perform lively

10. lets watch boogie woogie or nach balliye if we want to c dance

11. yes they can!
pungi123 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I don't think that any of the contestants left are besura or besuri - all the ones who qualify for top12 were good thats why they were there.
I don't think suhit was in top12, correct me if I am wrong. If any of these become an idol that means that have a huge mass behind them along with the surs. So this performance vs singing debate as baseless as they all have the potential to sing great given a chance including the ones who are no longer in the competition from top12.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".