What a pity :( - Page 3

Emon-9.5/10
deepali- 9/10
Amit -8.5/10
Chang- 8/10
Puja -7/10
Ankita - 5/10
Prashant - 5/10

Originally posted by: madhy

i kno dis was her worst rendition i agree wit dis...but wen udit ji says ankita is off key den evry one say she is soo right..dis time same udit ji said she was in sur but she missed some spirit wich required in one line..

anyways she did mistake...nd ppl r ready to 4give others wen they were totally in offkey according to al judges nd even they 4get da lyrix😕

i kno ankita is leavng dis week..so im mentally prepared for da shock but i cant 4get dt she has given more consitance performances compared to some others..soo it matters👏

madhy..i hope ki ankita is safe this time..just for u 😳🤗

Well, i agree that Ankita was not at her peak yesterday, but inspite of the goof up she did she didnt give up and continue singing, she is undoubtedly a star performer, and all days are definetely not golden days!! Undoubtedly, Emon, Amit were the best singers of the day, really loved their voice!! Just my opinion😳

luv,

Shagun/JD😳

Originally posted by: sweet_shagun

Well, i agree that Ankita was not at her peak yesterday, but inspite of the goof up she did she didnt give up and continue singing, she is undoubtedly a star performer, and all days are definetely not golden days!! Undoubtedly, Emon, Amit were the best singers of the day, really loved their voice!! Just my opinion😳

luv,

Shagun/JD😳

Thanks Shagun. Emon and Amit were good.

Originally posted by: sweet_shagun

Well, i agree that Ankita was not at her peak yesterday, but inspite of the goof up she did she didnt give up and continue singing, she is undoubtedly a star performer, and all days are definetely not golden days!! Undoubtedly, Emon, Amit were the best singers of the day, really loved their voice!! Just my opinion😳

luv,

Shagun/JD😳

aww shagun chwtyy u here 🤗

yay 1st of all congrats u hv becum a mod..👏

dts amazingggggg bt shru has already told me dt😆👏

Originally posted by: ManaliS

madhy..i hope ki ankita is safe this time..just for u 😳🤗

for me????????bt thnx swtyy🤗

You know what Maya usually I have a feeling whether Puja will be safe or not but this time.. its just blank.

You said she was missing feel, and so did the judges, and most other people. However, I thought that it was rather her chocking on her voice that affected the song more?? I donno if I have a particular reason for it but Puja's performance really touched me today...a lot.

I am absolutely sure that Deepali and Emon are safe today (hopefully! hopefully!) They were fantastic today 👏

It's high time Prashant went out.. I know he has been improving but.. his consistency in performances hasn't fared well, and when you compare him to other singers he really does seem to be the weakest link.

All in all I REALLY want allll my favs to stay and perform in front of Sonuji!! BAHUT BAHUT REALLY!!!

what is CAPS? 😕 😆

Originally posted by: starsgo

You know what Maya usually I have a feeling whether Puja will be safe or not but this time.. its just blank.

You said she was missing feel, and so did the judges, and most other people. However, I thought that it was rather her chocking on her voice that affected the song more?? I donno if I have a particular reason for it but Puja's performance really touched me today...a lot.

I am absolutely sure that Deepali and Emon are safe today (hopefully! hopefully!) They were fantastic today 👏

It's high time Prashant went out.. I know he has been improving but.. his consistency in performances hasn't fared well, and when you compare him to other singers he really does seem to be the weakest link.

All in all I REALLY want allll my favs to stay and perform in front of Sonuji!! BAHUT BAHUT REALLY!!!

what is CAPS? 😕 😆

i don't think Puja will go, i never vote for her but after the horrible way the judges treated her i voted for her cos she was too good to be harresed like that.

Originally posted by: starsgo

You said she was missing feel, and so did the judges, and most other people. However, I thought that it was rather her chocking on her voice that affected the song more??

Aishu, I posted my views as per an audience. Didn't think about other factors. It could be because of her illness but as Shabana Azmi said 'the show must go on' and at this crucial stage no one gets second chance. In life people hardly gets second chance. Of course there are some lucky ones but mostly they need to prepare themselves to face anything.

Having said all that I still rated her high because I liked her rendition. She was in sur which is a must.

Originally posted by: Maya_M

At this stage we shouldn't be still categorizing them as trained and untrained. Each one deserves the same scale of comparison and Chang was very bad along with Ankita and Prashant.

Changu is our Chingu-Mingu but sach mein he was . If its any consolation he looked cute in that attire and his Hindi is excellent👏. He studied in a Hindi medium may be that's why.

whats that Maya?!! thats a news to me or I didnt get the underlined part but seriously, the term trained n untrained factor I was not emphasizing on - actually you mentioned it so was justifying with that😆... okay among boys keeping Chang aside somehow I feel Amit is far more better than Emon... Emon sings well but he doesn have the capability to accept criticsm or neither can he handle fame and I really feel he is going down with each of his performances... initially I was a great fan of him but the controversy proved one thing that he is incapable of handling stress... he sang well from begining thats why we couldnt see his reaction to worst comments... Prashant is the weakes link left - I dont at all like his voice it looks so weak to me... among girls Deepali is undoubtedly the best.. Puja can be but will not be an idol and if she becomes idol also she'll not be able to handle it... she is way tooo emotional to deal with the criticism... Ankita is someone I dont want to be one... so IMHO Amit Chang Deepali are best suited to be idol - everyone has flaws and practice make them perfect but these 3 are mentally strong and can handle stress😛