Javed Saab Super Rude!

did u c the way he made his judgement on suhit. i mean he may be right a bit,but he thinks he is the only one correct and everyone is stupid. i thought it was really rude of him to say that "his singing is flat, he is helpless" first of all he writes songs, doesn't sing them and come on you CAN be a little lenient. if any of you watch SA RE GA MA PA CHALLENGE you can see that the singers there are sooooo good, any indian idol singers are nothin compared to them, but they actually find mistakes, but that platform is different. if 3/4 judges are saying suhit is good, then i think he needs to understand that he's not the only one with brains, plus the public is the one who wants to decide about who they want to hear. im sorry but i thought it was really rude of him.

The other judges Alisha, Anu have suddenly gone deaf or completely out of their minds and Javed saab is shocked at their judgement as we all are.

and believe me im no FAN OF HIS! but javed saab could've said it in a nicer way!

hmm...maybe he's like that...blunt and straight forward...or maybe sony is makin him do that for trps..

Arre ye discussion phir aa gaya...i think this topic is like a bad rash every time u think it's gone..it comes right backkk... 😆

yah i really agree with u man i liked javed saab alot among all the judges he is my favorite but the way that he speak with suhit is.......really unfair 😕
even if he sing well his comments is always bad 4 him i don know y????? 😕
i m not saying this cuz suhit is one of my favorites but javid saab is being soooooooooo rude with suhit he always discourage suhit! 😕 😭

Umm I don't think he was rude. I think he's the only one there who's got the guts to say the truth. I'm glad he's not falling for Indian Idol politics.

i thought he was super nice

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

Arre ye discussion phir aa gaya...i think this topic is like a bad rash every time u think it's gone..it comes right backkk... 😆

rash? lol...

thats original 😆

he was right!!

he is experienced, learned(in music as well) and someone with brain - his abilities are not even close to all other 3 judges' combined together be it in experience or debating skills - he has seen the world

what was Suhit, I dont want to discuss but that disaster before his performance was much more bigger and controversial than his singing!! real gems left because of him & he came up with his usual style with a fraction of improvement then anyone in the world who respect art or music can never ignore that!!! I found Javed Akhtar was very sophisticated & honest in giving his opinion - he wasnt judging Suhit's improvement chart but comparatively analysing his stand there