lets be practical! who wont be II!

this is about who will not be II3!

i know everyone has his favorites..most of us know who can sing and who cant...and also i think few of us know how the system works..

only gayaki doesnt matter...no need to explain if u have watched II1 and 2.

smita unlikely to be II. …..

also richa is too young and may be naive ….. to deal with upcoming pressures..

Shifa,puja and vartika also seem not too mature enough (childish?)!

Rehan Khan ,Meiyang Chang, Prashant Tamang don't posses 'that' X factor
what can I say about Suhit Gosain? In all the IIs there will be/are few contestants who go almost all the way..Despite all those 'blatant-not-good-enough-singer-comments'...he might go through some more steps but won't be in the galas..

who is in your 'wont be II' list? Pls use brain not heart!

I HAVE NOTHING AGAINST THESE CONTESTANTS..SOME OF THESE ARE MY FAVORITES...AND THUS WOULD BE HAPPY TO BE PROVED WRONG!!!

who says meiyang chang has no x-factor....he is a really strong contender for the title....unless he really screws up and sings pathetically...otherwise i defiantely see him atleast in the top 3... 😳 and besides him..thr are emon, bhavin, charu and dipali..all of whom are really good and have given consistent performances....so any of these can becom the next II depending on who maintains consistency going forward.... 😛

oh good topic

I cant imagine listening to an album with Shifa, Richa and Puja as the lead singer . I mean their voices are not strong enough. They may be great in classical music but I for one cant imagine listening to their album as IDOL.

Amongst the guys , I cant imagine listening to an album by Suhit . The rest have good throw and voice so they are all competitive and all have a shot at it.

so heres my list

Suhit

Shifa

Richa

Puja

The rest all have a good chance coz they have that voice which u can atleast hear and listen to .

hmm well depends if the present participants perform at the same rate then:
shifa
richa
vartika
rehan
abhishek
smita
harsheeda
chang

Nandita is definitely not gonna be the II3