Whats wrong with Anu?? - Page 4

Originally posted by: raunaq

he could have said it in a better way like javed saab, he could have toned down a little bit, he could have said you cannot be indian idol becoz your sur is not good, or something like i hope you get what i mean why he had to compare and mention his work? but i felt bad for the guy, this is the first time i am feeling bad for someone in indian idol 😭 😭 😭

Different personalities.. both excelled in thier fields and masses like them. No doubt No comparison of Javed Saheb....But, One has to cut the cold ice with hot knife... Ohh rather then him see other people ... who were close and were out... I feel said for them...

Originally posted by: raj5000

Different personalities.. both excelled in thier fields and masses like them. No doubt No comparison of Javed Saheb....But, One has to cut the cold ice with hot knife... Ohh rather then him see other people ... who were close and were out... I feel said for them...

he should have done this to the dhoom guy or the guy who created noise pollution. this guy was humble and he was not bragging about his potential, i believe he should have been a little easy on him and not bring his work in the middle 😕

Originally posted by: raunaq

he should have done this to the dhoom guy or the guy who created noise pollution. this guy was humble and he was not bragging about his potential, i believe he should have been a little easy on him and not bring his work in the middle 😕

Well with 100s of auditions goin on right state of mind is hard to determine.. also why people are feeling bad is coz.. the channel projected it... with music / sequences etc... There were others who needed consideration or thought, are ignored. In this case See no reason, ok if he said stuff rosy rosy that guy must have lifed a bream life.. atleast he knows the level. One time disppointment is better then life long false dream. Agreed??

Originally posted by: raj5000

Well with 100s of auditions goin on right state of mind is hard to determine.. also why people are feeling bad is coz.. the channel projected it... with music / sequences etc... There were others who needed consideration or thought, are ignored. In this case See no reason, ok if he said stuff rosy rosy that guy must have lifed a bream life.. atleast he knows the level. One time disppointment is better then life long false dream. Agreed??

nope. i am not saying that he should be given false hopes, neither i am talking about those flowery talks being delivered at the person. all i am saying is that he should not have mentioned about his work, ke tum truck chalate ho and blah blah. he could have said it to him flat out that your tune is not good, you need more practice, you cannot sing,or you can sing at work for fun or something similar, what he did was downgrade him imo. i agree with you on 100s of audition. they do boiled up with clumsy people coming in but i still feel he could have said it in a better way. rolling my sleeves up now 😆 😆 😆 perhaps lets take this to debate mansion 😉just kidding

i do like anu maliks clumsy style etc. but that doesnt mean i am trying to hide his flaws too, he does come about as a rude person sometimes

Originally posted by: raunaq

nope. i am not saying that he should be given false hopes, neither i am talking about those flowery talks being delivered at the person. all i am saying is that he should not have mentioned about his work, ke tum truck chalate ho and blah blah. he could have said it to him flat out that your tune is not good, you need more practice,or you can sing at work for fun or something similar, what he did was downgrade him imo. i agree with you on 100s of audition. they do boiled up with clumsy people coming in but i still feel he could have said it in a better way. rolling my sleeves up now 😆 😆 😆 perhaps lets take this to debate mansion 😉just kidding

No its not debateable - if you feel with goo / rosy talk won't have inculcated wrong expectations then u r right. Reat my case. Thanks!

by the way anshu i totally agree with your last statement 😛 even though anu malik was rude

Originally posted by: raj5000

No its not debateable - if you feel with goo / rosy talk won't have inculcated wrong expectations then u r right. Reat my case. Thanks!

i think we both have different perception about rosy talks then becoz for me rosy talk is something that is flattery giving false hopes, giving right opinion in easy tone is not rosy talk for me example if anu malik would have said tum gaana nahi gaa saktey kyonke tum mein woh sur nahi hai ya becoz tum me woh potential nahi hai ya x factor nahi ya tumhe practise ki zaroorat hai but to me when he mentioned about his work etc. that was kind of little overboard, especially that when that guy appeared to be humble and he was not bragging about his talent i rest my case here too but thanks for your opinion 😛

Originally posted by: raunaq

by the way anshu i totally agree with your last statement 😛 even though anu malik was rude

I hear ur point also Raunu.. bass cann't help some people's nature.. also when string comments are needed for good of individual. If Anu said same for a medium talented person then I would have been the first person to point him out.. anyways.. 😳

Originally posted by: raj5000

I hear ur point also Raunu.. bass cann't help some people's nature.. also when string comments are needed for good of individual. If Anu said same for a medium talented person then I would have been the first person to point him out.. anyways.. 😳

now i see why you hold a different opinion now, you might be right then in your opinion 😛 i agree he was not talented but may be i was looking from a different angle more like javed saab 😆 😆 😆

😆

Originally posted by: raunaq

now i see why you hold a different opinion now, you might be right then in your opinion 😛 i agree he was not talented but may be i was looking from a different angle more like javed saab 😆 😆 😆

Raunaq Saheb 😆😆😆 ... Javed sir is gem yaar.. kitna wisdom hai amazing..👏.😊