SONU;s judgement is missed!

I am a die-hard fan of Sonu Nigam and his singing, but after watching todays episode of II3,am convinced that there is no one to replace Sonu's judging capabilities. Am not talking about singing here, mind you, its about the ability to judge. I like Udit and his singing a lot, but he's just an average judge, sometimes he comments and that too, he reinforces someone's else's comments most of the time. So am not counting him to take a strong stand ever, i mean he, in my opinion, likes to play safe!

Alisha is good, but she is not as powerful as Sonu, i mean, she has comments but since its her first time judging, she does not force her opinion, she reserves her comments for last and is very sweet, very sweet to be rude and frank like Farah.

So in my opinion Sonu's judgement cannot be replaced even with Alisha and Udit together. He is the best, i really liked the way he thinks and talks. Boy, there is not Zing to Indian Idol without SOnu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

10000000000000000000000000000001% trueee!!! 😳

his comments were the onli comments i really cared about for any contestant...he was just the best...along with telling the contestant his/her plus points/weak points...he wud also tell them how to improve and wat more to do...even sum1 was rejected...he wudnt be harsh on them, cuz he knew how they wud feel....he's been thru rejection as well...

his judgement really is being missed...his presence is being missed...

i agree with u...udit doesnt voice his own opinion...he usually follows the other judges' opinion...and usually says the same things again to every good contestant (u have a good voice, ur missing passion in ur voice etc)

sonu we miss u 😭

That judgement is missing right now and dunno if Udit can provide same with that authority too 😕 We will have to wait and watch.

Sonu is irreplacable..Uday too passive! Anu is simply overtaking all decisions.

I miss Sonu's judgment as well. He is really irreplaceable.

Lets see if Udit becomes less passive in the upcoming episodes. It might just be that he's nervous. I think II3 is the first reality show he's associated with it.

Yup.. I miss sonu n Farah Too 😭 😭

yeah me too. He was a better judge than all of these combined

yea sonu is da besttttttt ..while i was watchin passed 2 episodes of II nd i jus cudnt stop talking abt sonu & how sonu used to judge wit da contests compared to these 3.. i really really miss sonu..nd now i feel farah alsoo better some of these

i liked last year judges .they were much more efficient than udit.he doesn,t have his own opinion.he just blindly follows anu malik

Originally posted by: zoyamom33

I am a die-hard fan of Sonu Nigam and his singing, but after watching todays episode of II3,am convinced that there is no one to replace Sonu's judging capabilities. Am not talking about singing here, mind you, its about the ability to judge. I like Udit and his singing a lot, but he's just an average judge, sometimes he comments and that too, he reinforces someone's else's comments most of the time. So am not counting him to take a strong stand ever, i mean he, in my opinion, likes to play safe!

Alisha is good, but she is not as powerful as Sonu, i mean, she has comments but since its her first time judging, she does not force her opinion, she reserves her comments for last and is very sweet, very sweet to be rude and frank like Farah.

So in my opinion Sonu's judgement cannot be replaced even with Alisha and Udit together. He is the best, i really liked the way he thinks and talks. Boy, there is not Zing to Indian Idol without SOnu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

100% agree

alisha is good i like her but u r right she doesnt force her opinion she is extra ordinary sweet

n abt udit he is confused only aved akhtar is a good judge there n i think he wud come in some episodes

now who is left then only anu malik😕 dont think he knows much abt singing

really miss sonu he used to give fair comments