y did judges do an u-turn? - Page 4

Originally posted by: samie123

Best advice just don't watch II3. I know I won't after what happened yesterday.

samie

I agree we shoudln't watch Indian Idol 3 or what ever its just a sick game and crap where talent goes away and looser keeps their position and at the end the biggest looser gets the Title....🤢

the judges comment hurt me more than the verdict itself. but if u give it a second thought u wud kno whats going on.well now that i think of it, this really isn't the first time that they contridicting themselves, hmmm seems like they hav temporary amnersia or somthing

sonu said stuff cuz he is jealous of karu, now tht he is not the II he will soon come into playback, thanks to ppl like vishal and shekhar, ab sonu ka kya hoga
anu said crap cuz he is jealous of vishal n shekhar for launching karu before him, somehow he thought it was his right to introduce karu....it hurt him to know that karu dosn't need his sahara
farah said crap cuz she wanted to earn more money, theses days her choreography is not going too well. agar sandy bangaya tho she can teachhim dance but karu, she cant teach uz he already knows it.

this is the dame way, the judges tried to justify sandeeps victory. now u really didn't expect sonu to lie down and faarh and anu to walk out after the results did u guys, they get paid by the damn channel...they can't do that. the only way u can praise sandeep is by praising his audience interaction n performance ( medicre and illusionary to some extent, IMHO)and demean karu.... so they juz did their job (at the expsense of values and beleifs but who cares)....deep in their harts, like every1 else, they know the truth 😉

Originally posted by: simpleguy

I agree we shoudln't watch Indian Idol 3 or what ever its just a sick game and crap where talent goes away and looser keeps their position and at the end the biggest looser gets the Title....🤢

ya not gona watch it either, i just can't see another karu loose, no hopes that the indina janta will change. not oly II, boycotting all reality tv compatitions.

i totalli agree wid u pragya-the judges just switching like that -has made me lose respect for them 2

judges need to justify the win to eat the pudding they get in the end 😉 😉 😉 even no one can argue with any of our points guys ......except saying sandeep rocks 😉 😉 no better explanation for it

lets leave karunya for a min ..........then they have to explain why Amey lost with good looks and talent and why monali lost for smiling always with pleasant performance and panna with cute smile and gentle personality .....connecting with audience ?????? 😆 😆 😆 what is this with people keep repeating the same thing again and again .......kuch aur bolo yaar .....he very well did not connect with me ...... 😆 😆 😆not with the udiji songs nor the way he moves his legs while singing .....well smile i can go gaga over but then i have panna and Amey competing with him equally 😆

Originally posted by: sreejan

judges need to justify the win to eat the pudding they get in the end 😉 😉 😉 even no one can argue with any of our points guys ......except saying sandeep rocks 😉 😉 no better explanation for it

lets leave karunya for a min ..........then they have to explain why Amey lost with good looks and talent and why monali lost for smiling always with pleasant performance and panna with cute smile and gentle personality .....connecting with audience ?????? 😆 😆 😆 what is this with people keep repeating the same thing again and again .......kuch aur bolo yaar .....he very well did not connect with me ...... 😆 😆 😆not with the udiji songs nor the way he moves his legs while singing .....well smile i can go gaga over but then i have panna and Amey competing with him equally 😆

😆 good one, arent they lucky that panna and amey were not in the finals with sandy😉 i luv ur posts by the way😉

i completely agree with u guys 😭 😭

If Karunya was from Rajasthan, he would have won with an even greater margin. Plain and simple. Sandeep had a motivated community voting for him. Karunya had the disadvantage of having a home-ground that doesn't watch Hindi channels much.

All the other reasons are superficial. Sandeep will have a hard time moving his albums, because you need more than just Rajasthan to buy them.

I am amazed..simply speechless.. This is what they said after the final result? wow.. they surely changed their colors within seconds. Oh well, loyalty can change on the drop of a dime, and that's been proven in all aspects of life in reality.

Originally posted by: smartc

I am amazed..simply speechless.. This is what they said after the final result? wow.. they surely changed their colors within seconds. Oh well, loyalty can change on the drop of a dime, and that's been proven in all aspects of life in reality.

...and the only thing that can remain unscathed is the talent and the drive shown by Karunya. Everything else is fluff.