classical round

hi all,

there are just too many topics abt whether the judges are unfair 2 sandy, its making my head spin.

yesterday karu perfoemed on jhanak jhanak, it was my fav perf till date in indian idol.

i also love amey's chunari main daag.

dont u think they shud have a purely classical round.

a lot of u may argue tht the common man may not like it, but going by the response for these 2 songs, every1 has enjoyed it and have these 2 songs as their fav.

i also feel wen contestants sing classical songs it becomes easy 2 differentitae best from the god.

wat do u all think?

Originally posted by: pragya0

hi all,

there are just too many topics abt whether the judges are unfair 2 sandy, its making my head spin.

yesterday karu perfoemed on jhanak jhanak, it was my fav perf till date in indian idol.

i also love amey's chunari main daag.

dont u think they shud have a purely classical round.

a lot of u may argue tht the common man may not like it, but going by the response for these 2 songs, every1 has enjoyed it and have these 2 songs as their fav.

i also feel wen contestants sing classical songs it becomes easy 2 differentitae best from the god.

wat do u all think?

yah i agree with you pragya........

Then sandeep definetly goes out........i think even his fans vote him out.......

Yes they should have a semi-classical round.

Originally posted by: deepthisesh

yah i agree with you pragya........

Then sandeep definetly goes out........i think even his fans vote him out.......

pls dont criticize any contestant in this thread.

i started this thread so tht we can discuss a non controversial topic.

classicals are the best!!!

meenals folk song...mera piya ghar aya oh lalini isnt classical..but she added her own touch to it...i can maybe say a classical touch..correct me if im rong...but newayz...she sung it really well

oh ofcourse ameys laga chunri was ameyzing..

i havent heard karu's song...but knowing he's an excellent singer, and reading about it everywhere...i noe he did an outstanding job

they shud have a classical round!!! 👏 👏 👏

Originally posted by: srk_lover

classicals are the best!!!

meenals folk song...mera piya ghar aya oh lalini isnt classical..but she added her own touch to it...i can maybe say a classical touch..correct me if im rong...but newayz...she sung it really well

oh ofcourse ameys laga chunri was ameyzing..

i havent heard karu's song...but knowing he's an excellent singer, and reading about it everywhere...i noe he did an outstanding job

they shud have a classical round!!! 👏 👏 👏

yes meenal song was a folk song with a classical touch, thats wat the great nusrat fateh ali khan was famous for

yes they should have atleast in the final rounds .....may be not all the time but one song each week would tell us who is better....... 😊

I totally agree with you Pragya. There should have been a classical round. That would have raised the performance scale a lot higher. It would have been all the more challenging. and yes, definitely a lot more interesting. some of the songs in II2 were not all that good.

Originally posted by: luckyleo

I totally agree with you Pragya. There should have been a classical round. That would have raised the performance scale a lot higher. It would have been all the more challenging. and yes, definitely a lot more interesting. some of the songs in II2 were not all that good.

most of the songs selected in ii2 were mediocre, that is scope for improvement and creativity was ery less in most of the songs

i dont think a classical round should be forced.. there are many good singers who are not trained.. Rex is untrained and so is KK..

by explicitly testing classical skilss.. one may overlook these great talents who are excellent singers without a classically trained background.. 😊