Sincere Request

This is an earnest request to the people in India...

Please vote wisely.

It was very very disheartening to see extremely talented people like Amey and Meenal in the bottom 3 yet again.In spite of being such fabulous singers,why are they being subjected to such humiliation by the junta time and again??

Its not like they are unappealing or unimpressive as was in the case of say Yashashree.These two have the right amount of X-factor combined with an abundance of singing talent.They are both mature and humble.

Since I live in the US,I cannot vote.But I request all of you who can vote to please think twice before you decide whos good and whos not.

Like Sonu Nigam rightly pointed out,Indian Idol is a singing competition so the onus should be on the singing talent and then only followed by performance and X-factor etc.

WE shouldnt become responsible for booting out real talent....

Smi.

No one agrees/disagrees with me??.. 😊

i completely agree with u please people please i can't vote because i live in canada . as u probably heard what sonu said in the 2 gala that the crown of indian idol is yours and i think that what he said to meenal was absoulutly right . like u guys voted for abhijeet sawant vote for the right person cause this person is going to be the india's music future . it is a request please .
if i were in india i would vote for karunya , meenal , ameey or monali now you guys think don't u guys think that these singers have the quality of being an indian idol

I am in the US and agree 100% with you.Can you believe when a talented singer like hema chandra in SA RE GA MA PA who is so good in his sur laya and singing ca[pabilities is voted out by the indian public.CAN THERE BE A GREATER INJUSTICE.I hope they will be sensible enough and vote properly here for the best singers.At the end of the day what we land up with dancers who cannot sing properly up to the mark.Pl go by Sonus remarks and not Farah.

I think in a show like II its difficult to define wisely. What you think is a wise decision may not seem to be for the rest.Sonu likes Ameya and he is being biased which is not right in a judge.

They are all talented and have a lot of potentials. Just because someone has not learnt to sing do you vote them out or do you vote them out as they do not have x factor. If they did not have the talent and x factor they would not have reached here. But the combination of who has more in which category differs from person to person. There a lot of others who have learnt singing like Sandeep and Ravi. Different teachers have different ways and styles of singing and each teacher needs to be given their due respects. Sonu comments has always not been for their singing which is not right as they have spent years in pursing the art.

Last year when Rahul Saxena who is a winner from SRGMP and has learnt classical music people reacted like they voted the II out. But hey Abhijeet Sawant proved them wrong. He is so loved as teh Indian Idol and people cannot stop asking for more.

i also totally agree with u.....i live in pakistan and can't vote like you 😕

n yes...i literally have no idea that we all here keep paising amey n meenal...but that thing doesn't reflect in janta's voting at all...i mean c'mon...atleast atleast show some respect to talent....what do amey n meenal lack?...i guess only luck

A singer isnt a good singer just because he is trained.
But on II2 the better singers happen to be trained..like karunya,amey and meenal...its just a coincidence...on the other hand,i dont know if antara has learnt classical music but she is a good singer too..
priya,my point is not to vote for people who have learnt classical music and hence they are better singers...my point is vote for better singers period...its difficult to become a good singer if you do not have a knack for it...unlike performance,dance and makeovers which can be acquired anytime to an extent with practice...

on that particular day,if someone hasnt sung well enough then he has a right to be in the bottom 3...where did amey and meenal fit the bill in this gala?all 3 judges praise them...it was pretty obvious to us audiences too that they were outstanding...and compared to others like ravi and sandeep they were far better in this particular gala...

what do you say people?

smi.

PS..i totally agree with Ahmed about the luck factor!!!

Originally posted by: smi_muks

This is an earnest request to the people in India...

Please vote wisely.

It was very very disheartening to see extremely talented people like Amey and Meenal in the bottom 3 yet again.In spite of being such fabulous singers,why are they being subjected to such humiliation by the junta time and again??

Its not like they are unappealing or unimpressive as was in the case of say Yashashree.These two have the right amount of X-factor combined with an abundance of singing talent.They are both mature and humble.

Since I live in the US,I cannot vote.But I request all of you who can vote to please think twice before you decide whos good and whos not.

Like Sonu Nigam rightly pointed out,Indian Idol is a singing competition so the onus should be on the singing talent and then only followed by performance and X-factor etc.

WE shouldnt become responsible for booting out real talent....

Smi.

Hi,

I am agree with you. I am from USA and I can't vote. In my opinion, Karunaya,Meenal,Amey are best singers among all contestants but I have seen all of three in bottom three. What the hell is going on? I don't know. It is a singing compedition not dancing or a beauty contest. First think about singing quality then about X-factor or anything else.

Thanks

they dont deserve 2 b in the bottom 3. they sang so gud yesterday.

i totally agree with you, i dont know what the indian junta is thinking, but its quite scary that they are definitely NOT voting based on talent...i love amey