Sunidhi Irritating Comments - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

5.2k

Users

22

Likes

52

Frequent Posters

WreckLass thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: sunandshine

I think the most important things she tells the contestants is to bring a spark to their lacklustre performances. Her suggestions are brilliant. She tells them to emphasize on their voice modulations and all this is key to "live singing". I dont see her comments as irritating. Anu is the one who talks about "im best he is best, I best you best and some nonsense like that". Salim and Sunidhi gave the show a new dimension altogether.


i agree with SAS😃
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#22
Sunidhi's comments are mostly helpful ...and she really gives wonderful tips to the contestants' performances ..for them to do better ....
However I didn't understand her tip to Shivam....how a boy , who is performing on stage in front of judges for the 1st time (he is not in some concert ) ...and appealing to the audience to vote for him by sheer musical excellence could dance like shahrukh and sing ...thus making a difference????šŸ˜•
and also ..how would someone measure one's smile ??....I mean what she told Rakesh about his smile didn't make sense to me....
Otherwise , she is fine .....she is sweet and energetic...not irritating at all..................................
Angel-likeDevil thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#23
I'm sorry Paheli, but I find Sunidhi's comments to be really useful, sane and relevant.. She always tries to polish the contestant's singing.. šŸ¤”
I think she's being an amazing judge.. who not only corrects the technicalties in singing but also teeny-tiny trivial things.. which are sometimes unclear/unwated(??) .. šŸ˜• Eg : Rakesh's smile..
She has a bindaas attitude, which is actually "hatke".. šŸ˜› And I love such bindaas people.. 😳
If you guys think she's being partial to Tia, wasn't it Sunidhi who questioned Tia for the changes she made in the scales and all?? I don't think she would have asked Tia to change the scale and sing once again if she was being partial to her fan! šŸ¤”
Like SAS said.. she's the most SANE female judge on the show.. =]
But I like Salim better.. he is to-the-point.. ONLY related to technicalities of singing!
Edited by Angel-likeDevil - 15 years ago
*Woh Ajnabee* thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#24
I love Sunidhi! Her and Salim make such an excellent pair of judges that sometimes I just want to push Anu Malik off that chair. šŸ˜† Salim concentrates purely on music when commenting on performances and Sunidhi gives more general remarks regarding the performances. I think her comments to Shivam and Rakesh were just fine. She was just trying to get Shivam to loosen up on stage and enjoy the song. Idol looks for both a performer and a singer. Shivam isn't given much limelight on the show, I think, and he needs to learn to connect more with his audience. At the end of the day, I guess what she's telling him that its not just about singing, but also about compelling the audience to send in votes for you. Although, I do fail to understand how SRK's trademark step matched with Shafqat's qawwali. šŸ˜†

And Rakesh didn't do all that great of a job with Jab Se Tere Naina. If you listen to the original, Shaan's voice modulates and takes on different expressions - Rakesh sang the whole song in one tone, neither did his face expression change, nor did his voice. Although, I agree, the way she said that to him was a little, but it made sense. The line in the song "jabse tere naina ... mere naino se laage re" is sung with a different feel and a different expression than "jabse deewana hua, sabse begaana hua, rab bhi deewana laage re ...".

Having said that, I think, by far, Salim is an excellent judge and my favorite this season. Sometimes, Sunidhi is way too diplomatic, it gets annoying.
sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#25
I totally agree with Woh Ajnabee's comments šŸ‘ I share the exact same feelings about Sunidhi and her comments regarding Shivam and RakeshšŸ‘šŸ¼
*Woh Ajnabee* thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: sunandshine

I totally agree with Woh Ajnabee's comments šŸ‘ I share the exact same feelings about Sunidhi and her comments regarding Shivam and RakeshšŸ‘šŸ¼



Thank you ji 😳
_Anonymous_ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#27
My favorite judge is actually Sunidhi out of all three
I'm not looking ANOTHER judge on the show that will just give comments and get on with their lives
Im looking for a MENTOR, someone who will actually teach them, show them where they are going wrong, give them something to think about so next time they will have no choice but to improve
When I was watching Shivam's performance on 'Tere Naina', my very first thought was why was this kid looking so stiff and actually kept waiting for him to loosen up...so i was pleasantly surprised when sunidhi was the only one to actually put it out...and not only did she point it out, she went onstage to demonstrate herself and actually got him dancing!
she is a fantastic singer but even more important than that is that shes got the confidence to match! fantastic singers have gone down the drain because they just didnt have the confidence either in their singing or in their performing
Its completely pointless to compare shreya and sunidhi, they both have their own different singing styles and both have different qualities that work just for them
I also wanna add that I feel the Rakesh comment was justified and that I dont think Rakesh took her comment seriously, it was obvious when he scoffed it off afterwards which disappointed me,..like someone else above mentioned, there is a different expression needed for each phrase of the song and Rakesh just simply either didnt care for the importance of that or just didnt understand
and ppl stop saying BEST OF LUCK...she says ALL THE BEST..gosh that was driving me nuts LOL šŸ˜›
ashwik_arvi10 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#28
I think Sunidhi is a great judge! I love her comments on the performances!!! I love her judging and she does not need to improve it!! All she needs to improve is her dressing sense!!
debayon thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#29
Well, she's the judge, so she has the right to say whatever she wants to, considering she's the judge, sh should know better, of course. The comments she made weren't really harsh at all. All she said was that they should concentrate a bit on these aspects too, after they want a complete package, and she isn't saying so because she loathes them or something, but she saying so for their good.
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#30
Just because she is a judge she doesn't have the right to say anything ...But yes, she does pass comments to motivate the singers ...
and Debo, I don't agree that just because she is a judge she knows better ...we had terrible experiences with female judges before ...sp in II3 and II 4 ...even Farah was o.kk initially but later she continuously supported Sandeep over Karunya 🤢.....Like what the heck !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Apparently she found Sandeep's "cuteness" more appealing than Karunya's singing🤢😲
But yes ...Sunidhi is sensible on her judgement and without being rude she is showing some basic mistakes contestants fall for while performing....She is assertive and stands up to what she believes in...That's another plus point ...Hence Anu Malik doesn't reign supreme with his "I know best and I am the ultimate " attitude(though he tries hard) ....
And I also want to mention ..Looks like my comment on Shivam and rakesh created quite a buzzšŸ˜†....I meant it albeit lighthheartedly ( well , should have put smileys there ..realise now )....
Still I will maintain that song doesn't need him to dance like Shahrukh KhanšŸ˜†...but yes ..he should improve on his performance skills ...
At the end of the day ..most of us agree that Sunidhi is awesome as judge ...specially the way our lady judges judged in past seasons, Sundihi is like a breath of fresh air.... 😃
Edited by kuhu.kuhu - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".