What Swaroop can do, can others do to?

Originally posted by: coolasice

I think swaroop should be in the show because he is working hard on his own. Being a Folk Singer he can sing movie songs but do you guys think that other contestants who are not a Folk singer can sing like swaroop? At least Swaroop is coming up by his hard work & not like Yashraj whose dad came & begged for him to make him a part of this show.

WHO ALL AGREE WITH ME?

Originally posted by: coolasice

I think swaroop should be in the show because he is working hard on his own. Being a Folk Singer he can sing movie songs but do you guys think that other contestants who are not a Folk singer can sing like swaroop? At least Swaroop is coming up by his hard work & not like Yashraj whose dad came & begged for him to make him a part of this show.

WHO ALL AGREE WITH ME?

Originally posted by: coolasice

</div>

Originally posted by <font color="#0066cc">Sunita182</font>

I do agree with you. Swaroop is very talented. BUT where did yashraj bashing come from ?
if we are talking abt swaroop, why cant we jsut talk about him.
Some body's superiority should come from within, not by comparing him to someone you feel is inferior.

and to be honest, ok his dad did beg. bt when he sang , he sang so well that Mr.Merchant claimed he was his top1. well tats something rite ?

But yh swaroop is really really talented and I do like him alot :)

I do agree that Mr. Merchant claimed that Yashraj is top 1, but when Shashi sang Jaane Tu then Hussain asked Mr. Merchant that does he still think that Yashraj is top1 & Mr. Merchant said now I cannot say that. Above that I read some where that Yashraj had already been on reality show & he had won as well. I think even Geetesh was a good singer but judges ask the good singer to leave and allow the person whose father came and asked for a 2nd chance, so in that case if all the contestants parents will come & ask for a 2nd chance will judges give the yellow card to all?

So what I mean is Yashraj is good but there are other singers who are better than him.

So it is not about comparing. When Abhijeet asked Yashraj before he came on stage that " your dad is going to come on stage today? Yashraj replied He has done his work & now it is my turn".

Y can't he prove himself in the audition round why does he need his dad. All the other contestants tried by themselves & when they were eliminated their parents did not came in running before judges & asking them to give their kids an another chance. Because they feel it is not good to do that.

It is not a comparison it is the reality.

No Offence

See the below link some one posted in this forum

Why should we make such people idols......
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZvIwsscEWY....


stop votin for such monster.......
on top of tat he makes his dad beg for gettin entry in indian idol..

<div>

Originally posted by: Sunita182

If i got to indian idol and my parents beg for me.. WOULD I GET IN ? a big fat no ..exactly. .when he sang for the second time, the judges thought ok may be yesterday was his bad day. he's a good singer. thats y he got in . its not like just becz ur paretns beg you get in .... :S:S

and i have seen the video you posted .... and funnily, it doens't change my opinion about him at all. who doesn't lose his cool once in a while and hten if you look at it properly, the girl was going nuts on him. He is only human. and at the end of the day I thought we were looking for an Indian Idol- a singer. Not a Mr.nice or Mr.ive never done mistakes before...

Yes tat fight was nasty. But ''Every saint has a past, Every sinner has a future''

and Im sure he's learnt from it, and I sure as hell dont think he is arrogant. He's confident but its good for him. I just hope he gets thru, and stands against all odd. Go Yashraj !
SWAROOP KHAN CAN WORK AS ACTOR, COMPOSER, DIRECTOR, AND SINGER.

Originally posted by: coolasice

I think swaroop should be in the show because he is working hard on his own. Being a Folk Singer he can sing movie songs but do you guys think that other contestants who are not a Folk singer can sing like swaroop? At least Swaroop is coming up by his hard work & not like Yashraj whose dad came & begged for him to make him a part of this show.

WHO ALL AGREE WITH ME?