Round 1: Tulsi Kumar - Page 4

Its not a listener friendly song in my opinion......Tulsi's pitch is way too high and her word delivery is also bothering me....and even though its a fast paced track she seems to be singing a bit too fast!

Below Average for me! 4/10

I was expecting for a Himesh song here, as Tulsi Kumar started her career with Himesh. Hhhmmmm..

Originally posted by: xobile

You've pointed out 3 mistakes (in red). You constantly repeat the same voice quality praise (in green). So you have given her all 6 marks JUST for voice quality!

Plus an extra mark (in blue) for Himesh!

Wow - didn't think we'd see this level of prejudice from you, ssk.

This is what I was saying, judges should not be biased. One should judge only when they dont see their favoritism clouding their judgement. Simply because she sang with Himmy who happens to be ssk's favorite, she gets a 7..if she was singing with either Udit or Kumar Sanu maybe she would have got 5 or less from ssk!

Originally posted by: cosworthkid007

five on ten.

jhalak dikhlaja,
jhalak dikhlaja,
jhalak dikhlaja,

ek baar sur mein aaja aaja aaja..

Suron ko liye tarse mere kaan...
Na laha guzre na kate suraiyaan...



jhalak dikhlaja,

jhalak dikhlaja,

jhalak dikhlaja,



ek baar sur mein aaja aaja aaja...

LMAO🤣@ Ek baar sur mein aaja

xobile- Voice quality is the most important quality a singer should have. Her voice quality is great, and that alone is 6 worthy


sunandshine- I feel as though Himesh brings the best out of his counterparts. He compliments everyone really well, and they had good chemistry. So thats why an extra mark, for the good chemistry and complimenting with Himesh.

6/10

I think she was only sung in handful of movies till now. Choosing 11 songs for her will be impossible.
Of course being the daughter of Gulshan Kumar must have helped a bit. Karzzz (you can remove the 'Kar' by the way) was produced by Tulsi's brother Bhusan Kumar.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

xobile- Voice quality is the most important quality a singer should have. Her voice quality is great, and that alone is 6 worthy


sunandshine- I feel as though Himesh brings the best out of his counterparts. He compliments everyone really well, and they had good chemistry. So thats why an extra mark, for the good chemistry and complimenting with Himesh.

Absolute rubbish! Most spoeakers, like actors, news anchors and hosts have great voices. Just take Amitabh Bachchan or our very own Hussain as an example - they have great voices. Comparatively, you might say Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan had 'bad' (unconventional) voice quality!!

The most important quality as a singer is voice CONTROL!

And as for Tulsi's voice quality - is it THAT great that she deserves a 6! In that case all the singers in this competition have that or better quality in their voice - so your scores will all be a minimum of six, will they?!

Originally posted by: ssk13809

xobile- Voice quality is the most important quality a singer should have. Her voice quality is great, and that alone is 6 worthy


sunandshine- I feel as though Himesh brings the best out of his counterparts. He compliments everyone really well, and they had good chemistry. So thats why an extra mark, for the good chemistry and complimenting with Himesh.

Let me rephrase that voice quality is one of the important quality a singer should have. But definitely not the most important.

You and Himesh think that even versatility is not important in becoming a singer. I think its completely rubbish to say that. I clear remember Anu ji saying on Indian Idol 5 Auditions that we are looking for a outstanding and versatile voice. This is what a true music director will always tell you.

Amin Sayani has a great voice quality and so does Harish Bhimani, but they would not qualify as Singers!!

@SAS

This is the first time I've seen such open partiality from ssk! He's actually saying that he awarded her an extra mark (despite all her flaws, which he also acknowledged) for Himmy!

I hope he doesn't do such a thing again, so that people still have confidence in the way the game is being run...