Judges are not consistent

Page

raj5000

@raj5000

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

No doubt Judges are unbiased and picking up good talent but at times after facing serious of bad singers if someone comes with ok ok singing level they pick him/her.

Also judges get emotional at times, the gurl who came today from rural background, she wasn't good even after Anu pitched favor for her, still she was INN.

Anu malik is a great judge but at times he just is biased based on his liking criteria.

What do you think, are these judges consistent in judging?

Quote

Frequent Posters

nitu

@nitu07

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

yeah.. well.. i agree..
the way he said she wasn't ready at first...
and again.. them saying she can come to mumbai...
well.... I guess.. they felt bad for her... and... thought maybe if given a chance... it'll so sth to her life... 😕
I hope she improves... 😊

Edited by nitu07 - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

6508

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: raj5000

What do you think, are these judges consistent in judging?

Noops, they never are consistent. They have upped the bar, as seen in very first wekend shows, but again seen by this they picked mediocre singer...Yes with training EVERYONE can improve, but yeah they are not consistent. If they see a talent can be improved, medium ppl are picked, but those who are very good are sometimes not picked, They IMO are never consistent.

They change their mind quite a few times on just one contestant 😳

Sonali - umm hmmm wat does she judge how consistent someone is in their personality? she just sits there, trying to chip in with her opinions but she has not made any impact in judging imo they dont even need her there she is simply there 2 b a pretty face and be 4th judge.

Quote

Chingu

@Chingaari

Elite

+ 8

Posted: 16 years ago

I dont agree,

they are nicely judging the talent,Lakshmi the girl from rural background have nice and different voice ,she sang beautifully,

Edited by kizley - 16 years ago

Quote

miggie

@miggie

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

i think it was nice of them to give her a chance

Quote

xanthimmortal

@xanthimmortal

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

I don't know about judging cause sum ppl we think gud today have gone to sing very bad ltr on so i will reserve my opnion but wait in gala rounds,normally i ve lot to say than,srry.but by than you seen n known how they sing.

Quote

Judges are not consistent

Related Topics

Explore Topics