Indian Idol 14 - Performance Discussion (23&24 Dec'23) - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

3.5k

Users

10

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

reborn-re thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago
#11

My favorite people performed so good today. All four of them were outstanding. Piyush what is he yaar and Menuka as always amazing. Ananya ka toh Kya bolu yaar this girl never disappoints me she is fabulous. Utkarsh I know he made a one mistake he was out of sync on that one place as Vishal said other than that he was amazing. Especially in first song I was little afraid that if he can pull that Dill jalaona part or not but he was so good and like Vishal said that was so cute when he accepted that he made a mistake because choti si mistakes Bhi Bhaari pad sakti hai since competition is getting more tough and I have also never seen in my life singer accepting their mistakes while performance was going on. I mean who does that too in elimination day but I hope he doesn’t make these kind of mistakes again in upcoming performances. Also I genuinely hope Ananya, Piyush and Utkarsh make it to the finale they have been so good from their audition to till now because Menuka definitely would that I am 100% sure of her making to the finale. Others were good too but I really loved those four today. Also glad elimination didn’t happen today because I really think it wouldn’t be good seeing yesterday’s performances.

Edited by reborn-re - 1 years ago
Tani91 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago
#12

Sorry I haven’t been watching I’ve been busy with my cousin’s wedding! Will catch up with the last few episodes soon

reborn-re thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Tani91

Sorry I haven’t been watching I’ve been busy with my cousin’s wedding! Will catch up with the last few episodes soon

It’s okay that happens but when you do share your opinion on performances.

Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago
#14

Rafi sahab episode was simply amazing.

Piyush & Utkarsh gets my 💕 vote for stealing the show.
mostly everyone was good but Piyush & Utkarsh did their job & they made Rafi Saab proud. I didn’t care for Anjana-Adhya performance.


Utkarsh-Ananya were amazing

Piyush-Menuka were superb


vaibhav-Shubho duo I liked Vaibhav’s singing as he rendered Rafisaab portion.

Mahima-Obom romantic song in shikara-boat so cute & funny. Obom tried being Shammi ji was 😍👏😂


Javed Ali was superb, Shreya singing was a great. Overall awesome episode & weekend 👍😊

Edited by Dabulls23 - 1 years ago
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago
#15

Rafi sahab episode was simply amazing.

Piyush & Utkarsh gets my 💕 vote for stealing the show.
mostly everyone was good but Piyush & Utkarsh did their job & they made Rafi Saab proud. I didn’t care for Anjana-Adhya performance.

Utkarsh-Ananya were amazing

Piyush-Menuka were superb


vaibhav-Shubho duo I liked Vaibhav’s singing as he rendered Rafisaab portion.

Mahima-Obom romantic song in shikara-boat so cute & funny. Obom tried being Shammi ji was 😍👏😂


Javed Ali was superb, Shreya singing was a great. Overall awesome episode & weekend 👍😊

Edited by Dabulls23 - 1 years ago
IbuHatela thumbnail
Navigator Thumbnail 2nd Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#16

It's been a busy weekend due to Christmas preparation and activities, so I had no free time until now. I am busy tomorrow (not sure about the evening) and Tuesday evening too, so I had to pick which episode to watch. The Ramayan/mythology episodes they do every year aren't priority viewing for me, while Rafi saab songs always are, so the decision was easy.

Hussain being back was great. He is so much better than Aditya in my opinion.

Obom and Mahima were fine. Mahima sounded off, but she tried. Obom sounds like a completely different guy when he's singing old school songs.

Muskaan and Dipan did a very nice job. Unlike Obom, who usually only excels at modern songs, both of them have voices and styles that allow them to be versatile in comparison. They sang two different genres of songs, both classics, and did a good job with both. Both have had better showings, but that's to be expected when the subject of the show is so different from what they're used to singing.

I usually don't care for forced drama stuff on Idol or SRGMP, but the stuff with Sanu da and Dipan was good. Sanu da always nails it and Dipan's answer was fun. Same with the way he got handled by the other guys. It was silly but fun.

Vaibhav and Subhadeep were fun together. They mesh well and their performance of Salamat Rahe Dostana Hamara was on point.

Utkarsh and Ananya's performance made me smile. Ananya deserves a finale spot for sure. Maybe Utkarsh too, but Ananya was a different level today. They sang a really fun song to start and then a soulful one, and did justice to both.

Shreya's reaction was so sweet 😭

I've said before that Menuka and Piyush are my top male and female contestants for the season. Their performance of one of my favorite songs was soul touching. I hope they both make it to the end.

Shreya and Piyush's duet was sublime.

Anjana and Adya's performance made me feel conflicted. it was a fun performance and I enjoyed it. Anjana finally got to show her skills without screaming and shrieking, and she dominated over Adya. But why do we get to see this kind of performance so rarely from her? Why do they always give her screaming SMP type songs? They're doing her an injustice and an injustice to viewers as well. Please let this show be the one that leads to her singing more songs where she's genuinely fun to listen to, and not grating and making me reach for the remote.

Javed Ali was a terrific guest. He's always been a favorite judge of mine whenever he's on shows, so him being a guest was a nice change. It's always nice to see him on shows. Annu Kapoor is also great and while I wish he had more words to say, in the first half but he still left an impact on the episode.

The game at the end of the show was a fun alternative to the medleys they usually do on this show for major singers.

I'm glad Adya didn't get eliminated today. It's holiday season for most of the world and ending the weekend with an elimination would be sad. Plus it gives Adya a chance to try and redeem herself, maybe enough to get her off the chopping block. She's been mostly good lately, and this second chance could be big for her.

Happy holidays guys. The Rafi episode was a good part of the weekend. Let's hope next week's New Year's episodes are of a similar quality.

Raina101 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#17

Quite enjoyed the Mohd Rafi special episode. We had some lovely singing, and some lovely stories from Annu Kapoor.


Obom and Mahima - hawa ke saath saath and oh haseena. Loved it. Obom was clearly the star of this performance. I’ve never been a fan of his, but this performance was fabulous.


Dipan and Muskaan - mujhe teri mohabbat ka sahara/ chhup gaye sare nazare. Two different songs and Dipan sang them so well. The first song isn’t forgiving and can sound like a poem if not sung well. I did think Muskaan had a little trouble with the high notes.

Vaibhav and Shubhojit - Jaanu meri jaan / Bane chahe dushman. I’ve always said that Vaibhav is a great performer but not that great a singer and today I’m convinced. Shubhojit completely overshadowed him. I do enjoy Vaibhavs performances, he’d do great at stage shows, he has that vibe. Shubhojit had a certain maturity and calmness to his voice. Shreya read my mind when she said his voice sounded very strong manly (for lack of a better word).

Ananya and Utkarsh - Achcha ji main haari and Jo vaada kiya woh nibhana padega. Easily the best performance of the day. Ananya can give any playback singer a run for their money! Utkarsh was fantastic too, but for no fault of his, he was overshadowed by Ananya. But then that would be the case with anyone. I think this was easily the best performance of the day.


Piyush and Menuka - Tum jo mil gaye ho/ teri aankhon ke siva - Menuka did surprise me with Tum jo mil gaye but then she sang so little. The moment they give her a song out of her comfort zone, she sings so little, I mean it’s better she doesn’t sing that song at all. She did well with the second song, but again that’s her style. Piyush although he sounded brilliant, sounded a little subdued, like he was matching his voice/tone to Menuka. The performance was a little underwhelming.


Adya and Anjana - Baar baar Dekho and badan pe sitare - Anjana can sing most songs fairly well, don’t know why she’s being typecast into a certain genre. There was a point in the second song especially when she qas enunciating each word so clearly, that it kind of changed the song a bit for me. Not sure I liked it. Adya was bad. Her voice quality only suits certain songs and these weren’t for her. Clearly the least versatile of all.

Adya was extremely lucky to be saved yesterday. Don’t think she’ll survive the next elimination.

Meredith thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago
#18

So let me get this straight,

just to save the channels ladli, they had no elimination? smiley3

This happens in ALL reality shows. smiley3

Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Meredith

So let me get this straight,

just to save the channels ladli, they had no elimination? smiley3

This happens in ALL reality shows. smiley3



For your information Channel’s ladli isn’t Adhya. It’s horrible singer Anjana. Anjana should have been eliminated b4 Surinder. They all have to go. Only one can bea winner. So neither Adhya or Anjana matters at this point.

Edited by Dabulls23 - 1 years ago
reborn-re thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 1 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

For your information Channel’s ladli isn’t Adhya. It’s horrible singer Anjana. Anjana should have been eliminated b4 Surinder. They all have to go. Only one can bea winner. So neither Adhya or Anjana matters at this point.

I don’t know if she is channel ladle or not but she is favored by Channel there are some of her underwhelming performances which judges and guest have praise so much she is definitely weekest one among 12 this is her third time coming in bottom that too almost back to back in a row. So to me she deserves to go home next. About Anjana she is not bad Infact her last week performance was ver good and this week she totally overshadowed and was much much better than Adya.

Edited by reborn-re - 1 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".