How fake are the comments on the Idol show?

Vishal Dadlani in a promo clip tells Sayli that he has suggested her name and Arunita's to a composer.
In yesterday's episode it turned out that he actually spoke to Arunita and also mentioned Sayli! Now I am not sure which is what? Who did he speak to?
How much of the same stuff goes unnoticed? Fake cheering, even standing ovations used for different contestants are regular. Maybe they even fake MBDs? Who knows? Comment edits, where they take away parts to change the meaning are commonplace. They will routinely do an edit like this:
"You sang well but it should come with feelings" to "You sang well with feelings" . I have seen that happen a lot in earlier editions of Idol that I used to follow more keenly.
My point is, don't believe anything that is said and shown in this show, Just enjoy the singing and make the life of at least one contestant better.

True... In Anandji episode also they shown Sawai's comments in Arunita and Ashish's promo

Also the reactions are edited... their reactions are not always for that particular performance and those are actually edited from some other performance which is clearly seen many times

Originally posted by: Realityshow

Vishal Dadlani in a promo clip tells Sayli that he has suggested her name and Arunita's to a composer.
In yesterday's episode it turned out that he actually spoke to Arunita and also mentioned Sayli! Now I am not sure which is what? Who did he speak to?
How much of the same stuff goes unnoticed? Fake cheering, even standing ovations used for different contestants are regular. Maybe they even fake MBDs? Who knows? Comment edits, where they take away parts to change the meaning are commonplace. They will routinely do an edit like this:
"You sang well but it should come with feelings" to "You sang well with feelings" . I have seen that happen a lot in earlier editions of Idol that I used to follow more keenly.
My point is, don't believe anything that is said and shown in this show, Just enjoy the singing and make the life of at least one contestant better.

Bold::::: Then, Arunita will not get any song from any composer and MBD is wrong for Arunita, according to you Arunitaa sang without any feel and may be eliminated. Because comments of judges for praises are fake.

I feel that's not judges fault may be editors play with the reactions to promote some contestants.

But MBD I believe it because until and unless they are creative and shown their talent I never saw judges going for MBD. As fans we may feel that's not worth for some contestants. But with the small music knowledge I have that seems genuine for everyone in most of the episodes I have seen till date.

Originally posted by: SK2014

I feel that's not judges fault may be editors play with the reactions to promote some contestants.

But MBD I believe it because until and unless they are creative and shown their talent I never saw judges going for MBD. As fans we may feel that's not worth for some contestants. But with the small music knowledge I have that seems genuine for everyone in most of the episodes I have seen till date.

I was joking about the MBD. Just saying even that may be possible - they are so good with their edits!

Some one is fake, either writer of this post or comments of judges i.f.o. arunita.

Originally posted by: Realityshow

Vishal Dadlani in a promo clip tells Sayli that he has suggested her name and Arunita's to a composer.
In yesterday's episode it turned out that he actually spoke to Arunita and also mentioned Sayli! Now I am not sure which is what? Who did he speak to?
How much of the same stuff goes unnoticed? Fake cheering, even standing ovations used for different contestants are regular. Maybe they even fake MBDs? Who knows? Comment edits, where they take away parts to change the meaning are commonplace. They will routinely do an edit like this:
"You sang well but it should come with feelings" to "You sang well with feelings" . I have seen that happen a lot in earlier editions of Idol that I used to follow more keenly.
My point is, don't believe anything that is said and shown in this show, Just enjoy the singing and make the life of at least one contestant better.