Originally posted by: Priyrabha
They are not improving Imlie ckt. Her so called gussa is irritating me. If she is right for demanding the reassurance then Aditya was also right when he wanted Imlie reassurance.
Hey, Priya! I will just comment on the bold.
So, since the whole forced marriage track started, I've seen a LOT of people say this that if Imlie is right in asking Aryan to tell her the truth and saying she'd believe him, then Aditya was also right in asking Imlie to speak up and saying he'd believe her if she did. But is it really as simple as that? Both these situations are quite different.
The AdiLie equation had a third person in the picture, the AryLie equation doesn't.
Looking at the AdiLie equation first...
During that whole demanding the truth scene, Aditya needed to make a choice about whether he believes Imlie or Malini – Malini said Imlie shot at her to kill the baby, Imlie said she didn't. For someone who's known Imlie for a year, seen her sacrifices, knows her nature and claims to be in love with her, it shouldn't have been a difficult choice for Aditya to decide who to believe. And here, it was a life, no, two lives hanging in the balance.
The AdiLie relationship started because Imlie could not see an innocent man being killed. Just to save that man, Imlie went ahead and ruined her life. She took on the choice of marrying a stranger, traveling with him to the city, choosing to be his family's maid and giving up her wifely rights for his fiance/girlfriend of seven years. That alone is more than enough for Aditya to know that Imlie could not do what Malini was accusing her of.
On the contrary, Malini had a history of games, and even if Aditya wasn't aware of anything else, he at least knew the whole Janmashtami drama and what followed. For anyone, anyone with a brain, all of this is more than enough to identify and understand the character of the two ladies in question and choose who he wants to believe. There is no question of saying, tell me and I will believe you. Why does he need to be told that? Doesn't he have half a functioning brain for an award-winning journalist with an experience of over a decade to decide for himself? Why does he need to be told who to believe?
There was no point to that question. If Aditya truly believed Imlie, he wouldn't have let Imlie walk out of the house by letting his ego take over. He wouldn't have let Malini hang around the house and then also go ahead and marry her. If he believed Imlie, he would not have needed Malini's pardafash to go back to chasing Imlie. The whole gist of this one seemed like, if you want me to believe you, then you got to beg for it.
Coming to AryLie...
The whole tell me and I will believe here is between the two sides of Aryan for Imlie – and before I go into the details, let's us remember that AryLie have known each other barely a few months, are not in love with each other and nor have they made any claims of loving each other. And neither is there any third person involved between them, as such.
From whatever Imlie has seen of Aryan, she's seen two contrasting sides of his. She's seen the harsh side, who constantly reprimands and pushes her, and she's seen the soft side who is reduced to tears at her smallest pain and is constantly caring for her. She's seen him throw her out of the office, then take her into his house. She's seen him hate Aditya and then buy the whole T house for them under Imlie's name without expecting anything from the Ts. She’s seen the boss, she's seen the friend; she's seen the mentor, she's seen the partner. The problem here is, basis everything she's seen of his softer side, she can't reconcile it with the fact that he would go back to portraying his harsh side for her.
According to her, if he could let go of a 6cr amount to buy a house for the Ts at Imlie’s behest, he should also let go his revenge just like that, at Imlie’s behest. So, why isn't he doing so? Because they have progressed to friendship, that is all that she's seeing Aryan as – her friend. But what she forgets is that Aryan is still the man who dons different hats in their relationship as the situation demands. What she's now seeing is the man who fought the entire village in PD for her right to choice of marriage, and that of the girls after her, actually forcing her to do just that.
Despite all this, she knows he can't do this and just wants to know the real reason behind his charade. Her problem is not with marrying Aryan, her problem is why isn't he being straightforward with her. Her problem is that Aryan wants her to see him as the harsh guy, while she only remembers his soft side. Under the pretext of tell me and I will believe you, she's actually asking why are you doing this.
Edited by -Sarcy- - 3 years ago