What is wrong with Shweta???

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Paulomi Debnath

@-Paulomi-

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: aadk
@multipaulomi At d end of d day,HD is just another serial buddy n twists and turns are bound to happen if d show has to survive! I wudnt be surprisd if shweta is shown mor n mor possessive abt indu in d coming days! Bt i wud badly dnt wnt dt to happen! For me,d charcter shweta has brought some kind of gudness in d show n i wud wnt her chrctr to remain b'ful.. I was just trying to convey dt shweta is nt at al wrong in her place! Her feelings for indu are justified for me!

ya she was not wrong but her attitude conveyed msg like that and yes its a serial and without twists and turns it will not go forward

Quote

Earnshaw09

@Earnshaw09

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

#22

Don't agree with you on this.I think Shweta has a very valid reason;and its a very difficult situation that she is in:even when she has given birth to the child,she is being asked[by Rishi] to not get emotionally attached to the baby;even when Shweta loves this child,she is not allowed to show her emotions.Whether Rishi approves of it,or not,Shweta is a mother to Indu;and I think if the writer and the CVs want to create a positive atmosphere in the drama,than they should let the mother-child bonding grow,with both Shweta and Indu,and Indu and Indira.After all we live in a country,where the best example of such a love and bonding is left behind by Lord Krishna,who had loved and respected both Devaki and Jashoda,equally.The question is not whose love is great;because love is love;and when love is pure and unconditional,like that of parents' love,it doesn't need to be proved.

Lets see how brilliantly,or how poorly the creator of "HD" handle this relationship.We can just hope that they don't make a mockery of it.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Paulomi Debnath

@-Paulomi-

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: Earnshaw
Don't agree with you on this.I think Shweta has a very valid reason;and its a very difficult situation that she is in:even when she has given birth to the child,she is being asked[by Rishi] to not get emotionally attached to the baby;even when Shweta loves this child,she is not allowed to show her emotions.Whether Rishi approves of it,or not,Shweta is a mother to Indu;and I think if the writer and the CVs want to create a positive atmosphere in the drama,than they should let the mother-child bonding grow,with both Shweta and Indu,and Indu and Indira.After all we live in a country,where the best example of such a love and bonding is left behind by Lord Krishna,who had loved and respected both Devaki and Jashoda,equally.The question is not whose love is great;because love is love;and when love is pure and unconditional,like that of parents' love,it doesn't need to be proved.

Lets see how brilliantly,or how poorly the creator of "HD" handle this relationship.We can just hope that they don't make a mockery of it.

ok i agree with u but for that both indira and shwetha have to live with indu and rishi,so is that practically possible?

indira couldn't give birth because of her BT and its not her fault

indira can't part her ways and why will she,she is the wife of rishi and biological mom of indu.

shwetha's relation can only be considered for a moment with indu but she has her whole life in front of her

is it justified for her to become radha or meerabai for her whole life,will it be a justice to her?

Quote

snow007

@snow007

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#24

my dear MultiPAULOMI
shweta ka indu ko pyar karna galat nahi hai
han Rishi k saat pyar karna galat hai (ager woh kuch demand karay tu)
well
ager ap k pass pet hai tu just in few day ap us k sath attached hojatay hain
woh kia hai ?
woh bhi tu pyar hai

aur shweta ki galti
tu indira ki bhi baraber ki galti hai
us nay kon sa bata dia tha rishi ko?
last msg k save our child
but how????

mayra matlb yah nahi hai k shweta indu ko inshi say alag karday
but usko pour haq hai indu ko pyar karnay ka

yahan pay Rishi galat hai

kal ko woh indira blame karay k ap nay tu hamaray bachay ko marnay k liay chor dia tha, bataya bhi nahi es liay ap ka koi haq nahi hai us pay tuuu?

my frnd yh jo discussion hum kar rahay hain (with some different point) yah intenationly bhoat bari debate hai (endless) 😊

sooo no faida 4 phada

Quote

lal_mirchi25

@lal_mirchi25

Beginner

Posted: 13 years ago

#25

Guys,

Help me out here, did Sweta sleep Rishi as she keep saying that she made a mistake. What mistake.. I was not watching the show for a while as I personally like the track of Indira and Rishi. I really don't want to see someone else stepping in the shoe of Indira..

Thanks

Quote

Paulomi Debnath

@-Paulomi-

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: snow007
my dear MultiPAULOMI
shweta ka indu ko pyar karna galat nahi hai
han Rishi k saat pyar karna galat hai (ager woh kuch demand karay tu)
well
ager ap k pass pet hai tu just in few day ap us k sath attached hojatay hain
woh kia hai ?
woh bhi tu pyar hai

aur shweta ki galti
tu indira ki bhi baraber ki galti hai
us nay kon sa bata dia tha rishi ko?
last msg k save our child
but how????

mayra matlb yah nahi hai k shweta indu ko inshi say alag karday
but usko pour haq hai indu ko pyar karnay ka

yahan pay Rishi galat hai

kal ko woh indira blame karay k ap nay tu hamaray bachay ko marnay k liay chor dia tha, bataya bhi nahi es liay ap ka koi haq nahi hai us pay tuuu?

my frnd yh jo discussion hum kar rahay hain (with some different point) yah intenationly bhoat bari debate hai (endless) 😊

sooo no faida 4 phada

galti ki agar baat karo to sabki hai bhi aur nehi bhi

first indira,she just wanted to marry off rishi so that,he can be happy after her death,she didn't force shwetha,usne kaha tha ke shwetha ko agar ye manzur nehi hai to vo kabhi bhi usey nehi kahegi,par shwetha ne mana nehi kiya,to isme fault to indira ka bhi nehi hai

secondly rishi,shwetha ne usse indira ki pregnancy chupaayi,bohot natural hai usko gussa aayega hi aur usne shwetha ko 4ce nehi kiya surrogacy ke liye,vo khud aayi thi.Rishi ko ye pata hai ke vo usse pyar karti hai aur isiliye usne ye saare harsh word kahe taaki bachche ke prati uska feelings na bare varna aagey jaake usiko problem hogi kyuki agar thori thori shey mili to ye pyar obsession ban jaayega

thirdly shwetha,usne jo kiya,uske liye kaleja chahiye,bohot bara dil chahiye uske liye par uske saamne puri life pari hui hai,vo ye achche se jaanti hai ke indu inshi ki beti hai agar vo zyaada pyar dikhaayegi to baad mein ye obsession ban jaayega aur usne ye bachcha rishi ke liye surrigate kiya hai,muh se chahe kuch bhi bole aur baad mein uske attitude dekh ke aisa hi laga ke vo usey inshi ki beti kam aur apne aur ricky ki beti zyaada samajhti hai

Quote

Paulomi Debnath

@-Paulomi-

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: lal_mirchi25
Guys,

Help me out here, did Sweta sleep Rishi as she keep saying that she made a mistake. What mistake.. I was not watching the show for a while as I personally like the track of Indira and Rishi. I really don't want to see someone else stepping in the shoe of Indira..

Thanks

no no actually indira has brain tumour and at the last stage it was disclosed that she was pregnant also,so in order to save the child,shwetha became the surrogate mom

shwetha's mistake is that she hid the pregnancy of indira from rishi and so by surrogating their child,according to her,she is repenting her mistake

Quote

snow007

@snow007

Voyager

Posted: 13 years ago

#28

sooo
wahi howa jiska dar tha

Quote

... :)

@..Bebolove..

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: namratadesai91
What is up with her, man? She is just a surrogate mother. Why does she think Indu ( Love the name) is her kid!? 😡

She's so gonna create issues for Inshi!!!

i understand that she just gave birth to indu. But she must accept the truth that indu is indira's daughter!

Quote

Samanta

@iSakshi

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#30

First of all ANY WOMAN in shweta's place would've reacted the same, i see she did nothing wrong but wanting to love and care for the child she carried for months and gave birth to, it was indira who conceived but it was shweta who deliverd, without her the baby would never have been born... her reaction is natural, actually in REAL life a mother would be more possessive and aggressive towards those who wanna separate her from her child...no matter being a surrogate mother..

but shweta didnt she just quietly accepted all the BS rishi threw at her... so instead of taking a dig at her, just learn to THANK her..