HD lacks proper direction!!!

Page

mahkutty

@mahkutty

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

It was a good Inshi episode where we get to see some really cute INshi moments together and their love and care was beautifully shown where Indu can't see Rishi breath his last or say him he would die. Now, Indu has accepted him completely in her life and want to think of her, which is a good thing, but I was pretty disappointed with the way story has progressed.

We all thought it would be dream, but sadly not to be. So, that makes lot of questions to be asked and questions pointed at such poor direction.

Here are some of the following points I would like to know:

1) When Rishi left the court without informing Indu or saying a word to Vidit, he was shown as someone pretty hurt from inside, then within hours how does he forget the past and all that trauma he got in SN that he is back in barsaati waiting for Indu ? Does Rishi have any self respect or not ? Do you think anyone would lose their self-esteem so much in love that has no feeling of hurt being mistreated ?

2) Indu didn't utter a word of gratitude for Rishi for winning such an important case in her life... Yes, she publicly expressed her thankfulness, but in person she totally forgot to thank that person who made it everything possible.. If not for a fimi dialogue thanking him, a thank you would have done it, but rather raises question over Indira how can she not thank who has won a case without charging a penny.

3) Rishi was deeply hurt when Indira didn't stop Munna mercilessless beating him up, but Indira instead of feeling very sorry for that had no such feelings of guit and that sorry was very, very subdued and looked like a one school kid saying sorry to another when their moms force them to do so. And, Rishi was shown not being hurt and rather enjoying the apology.

4) When a couple reunions and burry the hatchet, emotions get high and not that they kid around about it. What we saw was of no emotions from either of them about the past.

5) All the above points point to one thing that is dreadful writing and dodgy direction.

Finally, we are already into next track with possible Mandira marriage track and the story has moved too fast to anyone's liking.

share your thoughts!

Edited by mahkutty - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Anju.

@ALUJNA21

Trailblazer

+ 9

Posted: 13 years ago

mahesh better not to discuss about them though it is a show you cannot search for 100% logic but something which relates to true life should have been added followed to make it seems true.

they really don't know where to go so the very same problems of the sharmas keep on repeating,there's

no food need to buy some groceries

not enough money

some small fights between the sharmas

Rishi-Indira meeting on the roof

Rishi -indira deciding their low budget marriage

they are already in wedding suits

Marriage is not completed due to some silly reasons.

these are tracks repeated again and again.

and what more since 5 months.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mahkutty

@mahkutty

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Anju,

As a viewer, I am finding it is disconnecting and there should be some sense or logic in connecting two things.

I loved as an Inshi fan to see the fast forward dream sequence, but as a story progression, it was totally disconnected... Rishi and Indu were meeting each other after such an epic battle in court and after a painful breakful, but instead of showing some emotions, we got to see Rishi being naughty and a dream sequence about future. How do you expect any sensible audience to accept it.

I just was hoping for a meaningful reunion of Inshi and one episode spent with how they felt for each other and the pain. everything seems too hurried.

Quote

Rabina

@raveena2807

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

@mahkutty how wonderful it would have been if we would get what we wanted, no?? there is one saying in hindi that goes something like sabhi ko mukammal jahan nahin milti , kisiko zameen toh kisiko aasmaan nahin milti or something like that.. i don't know the exact word and i don't it fits in the situation or not but it just popped into my mind after reading your reply to anju ji especially last lines..

but i do agree, HD lacks proper direction..

Edited by raveena2807 - 13 years ago

Quote

Mamta

@misty85

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Mahesh I'm very disappointed by the show... it's loosing it's path... Now I have no faith in it. They have made a mockery of everything... Indu's struggles, Marriage & what not... silly dialogues, poor direction, blooper, etc... my head is spinning due to all this. I'm thinking that I shouldn't waste my time on it.

Quote

Harshal

@harshal25

Navigator

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: misty85
Mahesh I'm very disappointed by the show... it's loosing it's path... Now I have no faith in it. They have made a mockery of everything... Indu's struggles, Marriage & what not... silly dialogues, poor direction, blooper, etc... my head is spinning due to all this. I'm thinking that I shouldn't waste my time on it.

@bold:
If we actually notice then we will see that all the above mentioned changes occurred after the holi episode... Was there any change in Scriptwriter/screenplay writer in March...???
Bloopers increased...Logic decreased...Tensions Increased...😕
😕

Edited by harshal25 - 13 years ago

Quote

Mamta

@misty85

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

@harshal: I have no idea regarding script change ... but yes talks of the change of director were around & then came Ilaji's most infamous interview. And since then spirits of all of us are down.

Quote

mahkutty

@mahkutty

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

Raveena, Mamta, and Harshal...

Right, things have definitely got worse... probably there is a change of guard in HD and other thing after that ILa bedi interview where she seemed distraught about TRPs, I hope not that she gave up her hopes from HD and pulled out her Ace director out ?

I certainly see the bloopers have increased, direction is wayward, flow is not the same, characters are not properly utilized, etc..

If not for Inshi and Rati, i would have stopped watching it long back... It is beyond our tolerance level to accept whatever they show...

I feel sad for actors like Rati and Sumit and how they would be acting when they know themselves so many things not in syn... and that interview of Rati was made obvious when she said she didn't know how Rishi became a lawyer ?

My message for ILa bedi would be set the house in order and the TRPs will take of itself... If your product is eye candy, then no need to break your head on TRPs.

Quote

Cynthia

@-Cyn-

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

nice post

sorry cant replay for some question in HD 😆

Quote

mahkutty

@mahkutty

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

@Sanam..

correct!

I feel the problem lies with Ila bedi... She needs to clear her mind first in what she wants ? It was her bold statement that HD is different from what is shown in television these days and it is not going to be a melodrama one.

On the other hand, Ila bedi wanted high TRPs and tried things like Macau marriage and Holi episode and failed marriage. She needs to chose one either settle for good content and original plot of the serial or if she wants to entertain us and want high TRPs then stop claiming it to be different and rather follow the successful formula used by others.

I don't mind HD not being hatke serial and goes on to entertain which is want we all want... If really, PH wants to show HD as Indira's struggle then fair enough stick to that but make sure the flow and story is acceptable and don't keep an closed eye on so many bloopers and story moving from one end to other like a headless chicken.

Inshi is the USP of the serial and use their track cleverly and give them enough screen space and move their story slowly and not rush the way done here.

Quote

HD lacks proper direction!!!

Related Topics

Explore Topics