For me the whole rape thing was actually needed.
As far as Mandira is concerned.. then there are people who learn by mistakes that's the easy way out. Then there are people who learn things the way Mandira learned. She was always on the wrong path, and I said that after wacthing the 1st episode.. she had always been wrong. And she never learned. Take the ex. about Macau track. After going to jail she still didn't learn, then I dobt she would learn in any other way. The rape I agree was a terrible thing, no gilr should suffer through that. But to be honest it was the only way to wake Mandira up and show her the right direction. And she did change.. she learned her lesson, but in the most cruel way. And not just Mandira any girl that goes the same way, learn in the most brutal way. And I'm happy that the rape took place (in the show) because now we can finally see a real change in Mandira, her character will grow. And if we're lucky we might catch some sisterly bonding.
I surfed through the whole forum yesterday.. and I was really irritated, I mean yes.. what Sameer did was horrible, but it was the only way to change Mandira (CVs POV).
And I support it(just in fiction),
I also read something about that HD is turning into a saas-bahu saga. I can't believe I read that. HD is NOT a saas-bahu saga.. it never was and will never be.
I also read something about Indira continues to struggle and Rishis being "Mahan" in all this. NO you're wrong..
This is a women oriented show..where they show a girl struggling for her family. .. and now that will continue. They're showing young girls the truth... the whole rape... and then how to MOVE forward, not just sit in a corner and cry do something. And they're not showing that its a walk on roses, but they're showing the thorns on the way(the police scene today).
If this was a saas-bahu saga serial then indira, mandira and the whole hous would be crying.. and Rishi would somehow bring sam to hail do justice to Mandira. Because in those serials women aren't shown much value.. But its quite the opppsite in HD.
Women bringing justice.. what's wrong with it? Why are everyoen cursing the CVs? I think they're doing a fantastic job, showing us the real world... apart from the heavy saree's and jewelleries, and shoes and crying because of a minor issue.. that they can't fight on their own, but their husbands havee to.
For me its one of the strongest tracks till now, its NOW that HD is coming back. There are just plus points here.
- Manidra getting back on track
- Sameer getting what he deserved (later on)
- The heart touching scenes of 2 sisters
THis is just my POV. I think the show is going great, but this foums (NO offence) is the most negative thing.. the whole page is loaded with how unhappy some members are. I simply don't understand why?
I'm sorry if I'm sounding rude now, but I just don't get it.
Feel free to comment, critisize. I would like to know, another side of this...why this neagitivity?
.SilentPrincess