(*SPOILER*) And if Dumbledore’s ________

mick thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#1

Well well well, listen to me!!

I've just read (in a site) some opinions about Dumbledore's death.

well well well, i start with a question. And if Dumbledore's death has been just a part of a gran plan?

We all know that Dumbledore's NEVER been wrong and maybe he wasn't wrong even this time! And now i will give u my reasons! If he's never been wrong, he culdnt have been wrong even about Snape!!!

In fact, if you read the pages with more attention you will realise that it could be really a plan organized by Dum and Snape!

When the Dead Eaters came into his office, he (Who knows why) stopped Harry with some kind of magic! And we all knows that if Harry hAd been able to protect his Headmaster he would have done it. So, maybe Dum DIDN'T want Harry's help. Maybe, as i said before, it was just a plan, his death was a plan and he didn't want Harry to save him.

And when Snape came into the office, when he showed that he was a Dead Eater...well, I don think Dumbledore was really surprised or scared about it. On the contrary, he said just "Snape..." and "Snape...please..."

PLEASE??? he should be angry, shouldn't he? everyone of us would be angry after realising that a friend of ours has betrayed us for all the time! No, he wasn't angry, ha said just "please..." and I could add "please kill me Snape" it's like he was asking Snape to kill him, like he wanted Snape to kill him, like he had to persuade Snape to do it, to kill him!

Here there are the things which make me think that it all had been planned before.

Yes, Dumbledore's words could just mean something like"please Snape don't do it, don't kill me..." but so, if he didn't want to die, why did he stop Harry?

I don't think Harry'd have been able to face all those Dead Eaters, but he could just run away and ask help, or save his life at least! But Dumbledore didn't make him move at all! yeah because he knew that Harry would have done everything to save him, to protect his favourite Professor, his friend...

And maybe Dumbledore didn't want to be saved.....maybe there was a plan, maybe Snape was really a good person, who acted to be a dead Eater, a Voldy's slave, just to give Dumbledore the informations he needed....I hope so

Now free your minds and guess, i'll be waiting!

Mick

Edited by PixieDust91 - 20 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2k

Users

9

Frequent Posters

mick thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
I've just a thing to add....I think Dumbledore IS dead...of course he is, or he wouldn't let anybody bury his body, don't you think so? But even if he's dead, it doesn't mean that he hasn't planned it before...
lucky_lakshmi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#3
guys,if a wizard is dead his wand will b destroyed right?but there is no mention of dumbledore's wand as far as i noe.
also "severus.........please ...." can also be "severus......please kill me"
maybe he n snape had some plan or the other
also when dumbledore body(so called body bcoz its not shown)erupted into flames,harry feltthat he saw a phoenix rise n fly away.(remember phoenix tears have healin powers.)if dd wasn't dead n only injured what if the fawks had healed him!
also remember that phoenix lament that they all heard!everyone thought that it was fawks lamentin over dd's death but it cud have meant something else.
also dd wuoldn't let hary to call ne1 elso apart from snape!that wou;d have been bcoz it was some sort of plan o something! 😉

this is only my hope! 😳
linkin thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 20 years ago
#4
guyz they say that rons got charlies old wand how exactly did he get it and is ti proven tht a dead wizardz wand HAS TO BE BROKEN.......
lucky_lakshmi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#5
its said somewhere in some book!i am sure!

maybe charlie brought a new wand n gave his old 1 to ron bcoz his mom n dad cudn't afford to buy a new one!
mick thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6
Yeah! You're right! i didn't think about the wand!
Dumbledore's one hasn't been destroyed as far as we know!
But everybody think him dead, and maybe he's really dead because I don't think that he would have let anyone set his own body in a white tomb...don't u think that? I prefer thinking about a secret plan behind all that! A reason for Dumbledore's dead!
We will certainly find out something about that in the 7th book, i am sure because thare are too many dark and unknown points in this story...Dumbledore won't leave us very easily!! Sirius ok, even anyone else ok, but not Dumbledore, not him!
Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#7
guys,if a wizard is dead his wand will b destroyed right? [/quote]

I've never read about this in the books. Do you remember where you read this?

Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#8
I agree with all of your points, Mick!

I also noticed that when Harry was chasing Snape and one of the DE's Crucioed Harry, Snape stopped him saying that he "belongs to the Dark Lord"...

Also, The fact that he still has the ability to feel emotional pain - especially when Harry calls him a coward makes me feel as if this was a plot.

Dumbledore was never afraid of his own death...so I doubt that he would be pleading to Snape for mercy.
|Persephone| thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 20 years ago
#9
i agree with mick!!!
dumbledore is not stupid....he would have known what is going on and i think he wanted to be killed or something!!!!

i think it is some kinda plan and in the end i am sure snape would not be evil just pretending to be evil to know everything about voldemort!!!

cuz if u remember they never toild specifically what snape did in the order!!! his job could have been to make dear ol' voldy think that he really was faithful to him and just spying on dubledore when it was the other way round.....



***hope u can make sense of what i wrote....lol***
lucky_lakshmi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: MysticaMagic

its said somewhere in some book as far as i am not gravely mistaken!i dont remember which book!

lemme think......!😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".