Two serious doubts from Deathly hallows - Page 2

Originally posted by: sweetu

yeah , but in the chapter king's cross harry first guesses that the place is king;s cross then dumbledore says no .n harry says r v at deathly hallows n dd says yes.
i am sure harry said they were at deathly hallows

did he now??😕😳 Might have missed it😳 but even if he does, There is an explanation.😊

Deathly Hallows conquer death. N Harry has conquered death right? He has faced and escaped death. Thats why its said he is at the deathly Hallos(or so I guess)😳

as far as i can remember first harry asks DD whr r they & DD asks harry to guess harry says king's cross & DD nods hs head...
as far as deathly hallows is concerned harry asks DD d reality of deathly hallows
i hope that'll clear ur doubt... 😛

well since the doubt thing is going on even i have a doubt wen is the ravenclaw dideam(pardon me if i spelled it wrong) destroyed???

& wat u ppl thing i guess jkr made the king's cross chapter confunsing b'coz if later in her life she decides to write hp again she can start frm king's cross chap & maybe d start this time will be albus severous... wat u all think????????

take care
love
mudity 😉

^^^as for the diadem, it was destroyed by Crabbe accidently when he he cast the Fiendfyre while chasing Harry Ron and Hermy. Fiendfyre or cursed Fire I think...is one of the things thats can destroy a Horcrux.

N I doubt if she is gonna continue HP series though buzz is that she is gonna write an encyclopedia..If So I am dying to noe more abt Dumbledore's past and also Severus-James and Lily Triangle too 😆

Btw..I read the Chapter King's Cross again to see if Harry says they are at The Deathly Hallows and DD says Yess...
actually thats not what happened. Here is the part: read carefully:

Well, I was going to ask you that," said Dumbledore, looking around. "Where would you say that we are?"
Until Dumbledore had asked, Harry had not known. Now, however, he found that he had an answer ready to give.
"It looks," he said slowly, "like King's Cross station. Except a lo cleaner and empty, and there are no trains as far as I can see."
"King's Cross station!" Dumbledore was chuckling immoderately. "Good gracious, really?"
"Well, where do you think we are?" asked Harry, a little defensively.
"My dear boy, I have no idea. This is, as they say, your party."
Harry had no idea what this meant; Dumbledore was being infuriating. He glared at him, then remembered a much more pressing question than that of their current location.
"The Deathly Hallows," he said, and he was glad to see that the words wiped the smile from Dumbledore's face.
"Ah, yes," he said. He even looked a little worried.

SO It was not the location that they were Talking abt..when Harry says King's Cross,, DD just agrees and then they discuss abt the Deathly Hallows as Harry wanted tp know abt it. He wasnt saying that they were at Deathly Hallows

Here's what I think:

1. JK answered this question in an interview and said that Griphook was lying about Godric Gryffindor and that the sword would come to any true Gryffindor who is in need of it

2. I personally think that it had either something to do with Harry's blood being within Voldemort or something to do with the Elder Wand---I think maybe since Harry was the true owner of the Elder Wand--the wand would not kill its owner so instead it went for the piece of Voldemort's soul within Harry?? Kind of like how Harry defeated Voldemort---he made the spell backfire on Voldemort because Voldemort wasn't the true owner of the wand

the book is quite flawless but i need an explanation for one thing and thats abt ron speaking(or copying harry as wht he said in the book)parseltongue.i mean that is something weird....if it can be done in this way then why dont other wizards try it?
however the book is great and i enjoyed each and every word of it!!

Originally posted by: sweetu

can i ask my doubt here?
in chapter kings cross what was that thing making noises n wat looked like a small naked baby ,wid raw skin n wounded body under the chair? wat was it because harry was about to go near it but he was stoppedby dumbledore. n this thing wasnt explained afterwards in the story.but dd said its beyong our help.was it the dying horcrux of voldemort which resided inside harry.?

n in this chapter how can they be at the deathly hallows i mean its not a place its just a collection of 3 objects.?

pleaz clear my doubts

que 1 later when harry asks voldy to to repent 4 his doings he says i have seen what u will u b after death then he remembers this child

so it can be a very bad person being punished 4 his doings

Originally posted by: avril15

the book is quite flawless but i need an explanation for one thing and thats abt ron speaking(or copying harry as wht he said in the book)parseltongue.i mean that is something weird....if it can be done in this way then why dont other wizards try it?
however the book is great and i enjoyed each and every word of it!!

Ron wasn't able to speak parseltongue--he only copied/tried to copy what Harry did to open the locket--he used the parseltongue he remembered Harry using to open the locket

i still have not read the book. but i will come back as soon as i have