dudley = wizard?!

omg guys, ok u know how the howler said remember my last to aunt petunia? well, that was when dumbledore left harry on the doorstep, right? well....... i think that the only reason aunt agreed to keep harry was b/c dumbledore told her that dudley was a wizard and she didnt want the secret to be let out... i mean think abt it... why else wud she agree to keep harry, all the dursleys hate him! so technically, it was blackmail. thats why whenever the uncle always trys to throw out harry, aunt petunia always stands up for harry and is always making excuses. i think that duds is a wizard and only aunty dear knows. but i think that by the time duds finds out, it will be too late.

this is what my friend came up with. i find it to be a very clever theory😉😉

your views?😛

please comment😛

~Ashi

hmmmm....true....Dudley can b a wizard..so he himself wud ve got admitted to Hogwarts..but ofcourse Petunia mst ve refused straightway..so in 6th book wen Dumbledore refers to the mistreatment given to Dudley..tis is the only 1 hez referring to..though Dudley wud not b aware of the truth..

may b .....but den wudnt dudley receive ne letter 4 hogwarts or ne oder skul..wen he was 11

if dudley were an wizard he would have been able to see the dementor

Originally posted by: Snape

if dudley were an wizard he would have been able to see the dementor

exactly....when the dementors attacked harry and dudley(5th book) he shud have seen them...but when mr and mrs dursley asked him he dint tell them anything about the dementors..he told them that harry had used magic on him...

hmmm..sounds like an interesting theory..but i dnt think tht its true bcoz if he was a wizard he wud show sum signs of bein 1..like u knw wen neville said in buk 1 tht his family thought tht he wasn't 1 but thn sum incident happended n then they were comvinced tht he is 1..so if dudley was 1 he wud show sum signs 2

If he was a wizard, then he would have been showing signs of early, uncontrolled magic. He would have been able to see the Dementor.

Whn he was angry on Harry, when they were walking b/w Magnolia Crescent and Wisteria Walk, something would have happened to Harry coz of Dudley's uncontrolled magic.

So not likely

Maybe but he has showed no sins like Harry..... But I don know if all wizs show some unusual things.
Guess we will jus have to wait 4 DH.
-Aastha

Originally posted by: xMarauderx

If he was a wizard, then he would have been showing signs of early, uncontrolled magic. He would have been able to see the Dementor.

Whn he was angry on Harry, when they were walking b/w Magnolia Crescent and Wisteria Walk, something would have happened to Harry coz of Dudley's uncontrolled magic.

So not likely

y do i even bother opening these posts to reply cos u say all tht i need to say 😆😆😆