A character you'd like to save ? - Page 2

Originally posted by: MjhtFan_Mahima

i cried the most at Sirius's death and he is my favourite too

but i would save Fred

reason being Sirius would join his friends James, Lupin and Lily

but Fred also took a part of George with him

Originally posted by: -Stephanie-

Even I'm going with Black!

Fred snape and sirus should have survived

I cried most when Sirius died..

I chose Fred because he was one of the youngest on the list and by process of elimination.


Dumbledore lived a very long fulfilling yet tragic life, I think it's about time he went on that great adventure.

As much as I love Sirius, Azkaban had a detrimental effect on him and then he spent the next year imprisoned in his ancestral house. Azkaban had stunted his growth and he was very attached to James so I think he's better off dead.

While I love Remus and Tonks, I don't like Remus/Tonks. Tonks as a character changed a lot for the worse especially in HBP and Remus gets to see/live with his best friends that accepted him as a werewolf and so I don't see the need to bring him back to a world that doesn't accept him but yah it would be nice for Teddy to have his parents.

I never really liked or disliked Cedrics character, he's one of those that didnt leave much of an impact on me but he didnt deserve to die that young. He's probably the second person I'd bring back cos he had a whole future mapped out for him but died cos he was at the wrong at the wrong time.

Moody lived a long paranoid life and was too much affected by the wars and his life as an auror, I think he deserves to rest and scare the crap out of the dead with his 'constant vigilance'.
I don't really like Snape and his life choices has led him to death at the end and hopefully Snape can restart his life fresh after death. I can't imagine him in these new wizarding world and I'd prefer if he wasn't around to bully kids in hogwarts. I think he's better off dead and hopefully he has the chance to make all the right choices and mend things with Lily.
I love Hedwig and Dobby but their deaths was pivotal for Harry's development.

As for Fred, there's a lot for him in the new world and I just felt it was cruel to tear him from George, they're we're very co-dependent throughout their lives and life for George must really hard especially looking at the mirror must always serve to remind him of what he lost

Originally posted by: BeShArAm

Voldy

if he didnt die we could have had more books

Simplee

Originally posted by: -mimi-

I cried most when Sirius died..

but some where deep in my heart I knew it he is going to be a tragic hero..

I would love to save Fred.. He just can't die.. Fred and Geroge should always be together..

I cried like a maniac when Fred died..

The way Rowling portrayed George's reaction made me cry even harder.. all the other Weasleys were crying but George was sitting on his knees.. a part of George died with Fred..😭

I just hate to remember that scene again..

I love to pretend Fred did not die.. it was one of his joke.. worst one..

Originally posted by: Ahlaam5

I chose Fred because he was one of the youngest on the list and by process of elimination.


Dumbledore lived a very long fulfilling yet tragic life, I think it's about time he went on that great adventure.

As much as I love Sirius, Azkaban had a detrimental effect on him and then he spent the next year imprisoned in his ancestral house. Azkaban had stunted his growth and he was very attached to James so I think he's better off dead.

While I love Remus and Tonks, I don't like Remus/Tonks. Tonks as a character changed a lot for the worse especially in HBP and Remus gets to see/live with his best friends that accepted him as a werewolf and so I don't see the need to bring him back to a world that doesn't accept him but yah it would be nice for Teddy to have his parents.

I never really liked or disliked Cedrics character, he's one of those that didnt leave much of an impact on me but he didnt deserve to die that young. He's probably the second person I'd bring back cos he had a whole future mapped out for him but died cos he was at the wrong at the wrong time.

Moody lived a long paranoid life and was too much affected by the wars and his life as an auror, I think he deserves to rest and scare the crap out of the dead with his 'constant vigilance'.
I don't really like Snape and his life choices has led him to death at the end and hopefully Snape can restart his life fresh after death. I can't imagine him in these new wizarding world and I'd prefer if he wasn't around to bully kids in hogwarts. I think he's better off dead and hopefully he has the chance to make all the right choices and mend things with Lily.
I love Hedwig and Dobby but their deaths was pivotal for Harry's development.

As for Fred, there's a lot for him in the new world and I just felt it was cruel to tear him from George, they're we're very co-dependent throughout their lives and life for George must really hard especially looking at the mirror must always serve to remind him of what he lost

actually I don't feel bad for Fred.. he had short life he did live it to the fullest