Honestly, LOTR movies are better than HP! - Page 2

i saw the LOTR movies first..fell in luv wid aragorn....was veryyyyy impresssed wid gandalf......adored legolas...
den i read the books....mannn..i luved them..i loved the detail..i know sum ppl wud say they re 2 long..but thts wat i liked abt them..
the HP movies were very dissapointing..so much tht i swore not 2 see the fourth one...nd i havent...
dun get me wrong..i still think JKR writes awesumly...nd HP is still in my fav 5 books list..ill still wait desperately for every new book....hang on jkrs every word fer a spoiler ....but my fav writer is tolkien...

Misha i feel you are party correct.But harry potter books are intresting. 😎

But what so ever i am a fan of harry potter books they are brileant and easy to understand. 😉 😉

I've seen all the LOTR movies...and my aunt who is a fan of both LOTR and HP says that the LOTR movies are better than the HP ones also...She says that there are a lot of things that are in the book that are shown in the movies...I'm still reading LOTR so I can't say that that movies are true to the book...but it's a good book so far...

SIMI 😊

Originally posted by: misha

yup, agree with u.

U know the guy who plays aragorn in LOTR, i fell for him lol, until i came to know he is 40 sumthing😆 But still aragorn is my fav character.

And yeah , Elijah wood looks so much like Dan............

Yesterday i saw the 3rd lotr movie, I was crying at the end.. the part when frodo leaves his friends.

But yes HP books are much better than lotr books. While reading HP u will never get bored. But LOTR books get boring at some parts.

Yea I thought he was cute too. He was also in Hidalgo~! You should check out that movie. He looks really good in there. 😳

Anywho, I partially agree with you on the LOTR movies. They are nicely directed and nothing was messed up in the story but I get really bored 🥱 watching the movies for the 2nd time.

They're not as fun as the Harry Potter movies. In HP there's comedy and more hot guys (god bless you Robert Pattinson and Tom Felton)!

LOTR is sooo... middle earth fight the EVIL! blah blah~! Get the ring y'know?

I still think the Harry Potter movies are much better not based on content of the books but on the excitment and fun when it comes to watching them over again.

All I can say is that I get extremely bored just watching the LOTR movies over again. 🥱

I don't much care for Harry Potter as movies. The movies are great to get a visual imagery of everything in the books, but otherwise they're not particularly great.

But I still don't like LoTR. I tried reading the book, and I couldn't. Then I tried the movies, and trust me, I DID try. I watched some, got sooo bored, turned it off. Then I went back and watched another piece, but I got so bored I turned it off again. This went on for several times, and in the end, I just had to give up. I haven't even finished the first movie. Don't think I was close to. lol. It's just not... my type of story. I agree with Ami. It's too... middle-earthish... lol

misha i feel the same way, the first two movies wernet at all that great. the third was ok, but i luved the fourth movie. the lotr movies have soo much more excitment and suspence, but for me the story line is juss not as great as hp.

but if it was a choice b/w the books it do 200% with hp ova lotr!!

Originally posted by: MysticaMagic

I wish HP had been directed by ONE director instead of WB changing directors every year! 😭

Btw, we're not going to bash you, mish...LOTR is way better in terms of movies, though there are some inaccuracies as well in the storyline. Eg. Arwen-Aragorn romance pe bahut time waste kiya hai.

And yes, Viggo Mortensen does look hot! (without the long hair, beard and chain mail 😆 ) So does Orlando Bloom (Legolas)!

lol, haan , romance mein kafi time waste kiya.😆 but still i sort of liked arwen. Lekin use movies mein kam importance diya 😭 books mein bahut importance diya hai😉

There were so many hot guys in the movies, viggo, elijah and then orlando😳😆

Originally posted by: *Rashmi*

I don't much care for Harry Potter as movies. The movies are great to get a visual imagery of everything in the books, but otherwise they're not particularly great.

But I still don't like LoTR. I tried reading the book, and I couldn't. Then I tried the movies, and trust me, I DID try. I watched some, got sooo bored, turned it off. Then I went back and watched another piece, but I got so bored I turned it off again. This went on for several times, and in the end, I just had to give up. I haven't even finished the first movie. Don't think I was close to. lol. It's just not... my type of story. I agree with Ami. It's too... middle-earthish... lol

lol, it was same with my sis. lol😆

I did not get bored at all, but yes, it did get scary at some parts. The third movie was especially scary😳

Originally posted by: hazelgirl

but i totally disagree..sorry misha 😳

are yaar! no need for sorry.😆