Gulaal...meri ek binti...? [CAPS by Nur Pg3]] - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

5.2k

Users

12

Likes

234

Frequent Posters

Anjalg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#41
I know this is a bit of a triviality but I wish she would sleep with her hair down minus the ghunghat as well. I have always wanted a scene where Kesu watches her sleep...Actually been waiting for a scene like that since the day they moved into one room...
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#42
Oh yesh!! Those are the bangles!

FINALLY she SEES how real his need is to be in her life! Doesn't matter if its 2nd or 3rd fiddle but he wants to be there for HER!

without-fathom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#43
Missed on a great night of the trio discussion I can see from the last 3-4 pages!

I'll comment here and not copy paste and repeat myself on Reemz and Ganga's threads - because the discussion pretty much remains the same!

Thanks for the CAPS Nur! I added a couple below myself cause I wanted to point them out and say stuff 😊

I sort of fall in between teams Anjali vs Nur and Reemz, I think 😆 I agree about the depressing finale feel that the episode bore - like this glaring reminder of how few days are left. In a way I thought of how thoughtfully the CVs had used the DV grace period as a means to evoke this sense of loss in us - on dual ends! This was the first time, since the day of the Panchayat when Kesar actually showed that raw pain in how little time they had together before it all got over. That day, he's said ab jab teen mahine baad saba khatam hone hi wala hai, to kya humj ye teen mahine dost bankar nahi reh sakte? ... and today he said - bas ek mahina? usse bhi kam... bas ita hi waqt bacha hai?! ... and then asks Gulaal again, to make the most of time... I thought the parallel was almost repetitive, and yet its reiteration at this point was such an impact of emphasis! Because last time, he had wanted a new beginning to bury the hatchet - and Gulaal had relented with half a heart of only relief and not his match of need of it! Today, he wants to mark a beginning to 'their end'... and she consents with her heart feeling every strain of his loss, equally, perhaps even more - given she still can't define it and find that peace like him, much less say it out loud... her watery smile to comply was so perfectly done by Mansi... she fills in the space of so many words with just that - because she doesn't know the words yet, and consequently, can't really say them. She would tell him she feels the loss in this countdown as bad as him, but how? Why? If she said she'd miss 'her friend' well - they could always meet up. So can she say she will miss his constant presence? Can she say she will miss living with him, bothering him, fussing and being bothered about and fussed back - can she say she will miss this first semblance of living life with a partner in a decade?! A happiness and bliss which was very short lived when she first got it, and then voluntarily shut all chances for herself to get ever again? Can she say she never imagined, but its beginning to look more and more everyday, like she could get used to living like this with him, for him, for them - for the rest of her life?! In what capacity would she say it? Unfortunately, he is no longer the child who needs his matron... He's a man, and yes he needs his wife, can she say she wants to be that, forever?!

Because she really hasn't sorted those thoughts even as they brim right to her surface waiting to boil over - she can't really organize and say them ... so she just smiles her yes. Because one thing she can probably distinguish in her jumble is, that making happy memories with Kesar would make her just as happy as him - she pushes away the why, and gives in - very unlike the hesitance of last time!

There was so much beauty in the depiction of that entire scene - like you Reemz, once I watched that scene, I sort of forgot about the JA wish being dashed 😆 I remembered it at other places (more on that later) but just in this scene, I was this spell bound GK fan, feeling the strain of their every word and gesture, so real - because it's not just a pit point in the plot, but also the realization of how the end is really coming - a happy end, is an end no less.

Anyway - I really, really liked the transition in Kesar's expression, when Gulaal expressed her fear - that slight tug of a smile, it wasn't even a sad smile... it was just... so enamored and touched at her concern... not that he's not always known how much she cares. But its been so long - since she last got so verbal about how much damn she gives to his presence... He's just gotten used to understanding it in her silence, and being content with that. Being content with seemingly only half her affections, as opposed to his, being content with being the giver, being content with being the one to say she matters, and not hearing it back... the last time she told him she didn't care about the world, but him - he had shown surprise too... but the talk had been on another account, and Gulaal had been alot more the collected person just talking sense rather than emotion. Today she is all about nerves and jitters for him... Reemz, btw, we did get a very momentary glimpse of the DCH scene feel don't you think? When she rushed to check on him in the night, at getting that note ... and the way she woke up clutching the note... and finally, in the way she fret at finding his sleeping spot empty! She did have that moment of what if... and it freaked her out enough to rush to grab his hand, be so utterly at a loss of words that she just had to shove the note at him and of course, the shaken claim of main darti hu! We really really got a GK semblance of DCH there - I thought! Like Nur had predicted, it fits them so much more characteristically, that I did forget about JA 😆

Anyway - like I said, really liked the transition of that peep-toe like smile 😆 from Kesar, so here's the couple caps:


And again - I loved loved loved how this bit played out at the start of the Yeh Jeevan Hai song :


Only a day ago, he was seeking her permission, and giving her logic to share a plate... Give it to these actors, to play a silent scene with music overall, with so much to their body language, that you can 'hear the dialogs' without them being spoken... the entire bit of eating by the fire (a traditional version of candle light dining?! 😆 ☺️ ) and the way Gulaal looks at the fire and says something and Kesar looks like he's telling her he'll fix it after food, and then his never missed complimenting of the food of course! Such a natural play of just another day in the house of a couple who are so meant to be...!

Now for what I didn't like? I wont make this long because I got flustered enough watching my first run of the episode... The song was well chosen - IMO - and I would even let Kulli by! But why did we get Raman and Sudha ... the entire 'teary make up' play on RS was SO NOT NEEDED. For a show that has maintained such standard in tackling a very hard to depict love story like GK, some extremely complex characters like Dushyant - I really wish they'd just sort of ended the Raman track on him being an outcast. People like him don't change. And really, 'even the change' shown in him, his 'remorse' of it was so 13 year old... Just one ill fated attack his father suffers and one pep talk from his mother changes the man he is? Really now! Yes, I'm a sucker for happy ends, but I wished they'd left this angle realistic and just let him be. No one was going to mourn over an RS love story lost, really 🤢 For such a poignantly played out episode, I can't believe how far the Raman Sudha exaggeration annoyed me, I should have just let it be - but then it even ate into the song space, and I was miffed cause it came after such a beautiful beautiful scene, and a wonderful start to the play of that song. Like I said, I seriously didn't care about Kulli. As much as I want them to not eat into GK - I'm not troubled by the way their story is going... RS just went all the way to be my killjoy for such a profound episode. Annoys me all the more to think Dushyant's end is still a dangling something - with no assured knowing that it will be firmly closed... and Raman gets this!!! Ah unfair world!

Anyway - I'm calling myself off that case. GK were bloody brilliant and the move in their track was very very well done. Like you guys, I'm super glad the 15 day leap has happened and we will still have well over a week to get along Gulaal's realization, and not a hurried KJo style happy ending! And of course the Precap - breaks my heart, and yet, the way they bring out the shades in these characters... Kesar's words just remind you all over again, of why he of all people has managed to move that iceberg in Gullu's heart!

More on precap after the episode itself today. My expectations are very high.

On a conclusive note, I want to quote these words from the show Malaal - which IMO really applies to Gulaal's soon to appear future self (don't go literally for mention of calls and messages, but the essence of Zenia's words (from Malaal) would sort of really apply to Gulaal now...

Zindagi mein baaz dafa yeh pata nahi chalta... ki hum kisi cheez ko paa kar khush the ya fir kho kar? Jaise mujhe yeh pata nahi chala ke jo main chahti thi, jab woh mere saath hua toh phir bhi mujhe saari duniya khaali kyun lag rahi hai? Yeh jo khala mere andar agayi hai...uski waja kya hai?

Kya chaubis ghante aane waale uske messages ka ek dum ghayab ho jaana; ya mere messages ka jawab na dena; ya calls ke uss silsile ka khatam ho jaana...jo mujhe yaad dilata tha ke kisi ki zindagi mere wujood ke beghair incomplete hai.

Jo bhi hai, main usse miss kar rahi hoon! Aur uski fuzool aur ahemkana baaton ko...uske saath bemaksad footpath pe chalne ko...aur unn tamaam pamper karne waali cheezon ko...jo usse pehle kisi ne mere liye nahi kein thien


Edited by JZephyr - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#44
Ohhh Jzee, you posted a Malaal quote *sigh*...I absolutely LOVED how Jawaad-Zeenia's relationship was developed in that show too...a class act...possibly only matched on Indian TV now by Kesar-Gulaal.

Yep, I feel we got our DCH-ish scene today with Gulaal expressing that fear of losing Kesar...in the coming days, I feel we will see this sense of loss magnified further...and it's needed. Personally I don't have any complaints regarding the GK development right now...the writers are on track and setting it up well for the final emotional high point.

I have big expectations from tomorrow's scene too so I'm going to save talking about that till tomorrow...love the cap Reemz posted...Gulaal's expressions are very telling indeed now.
without-fathom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#45
OMG Nur!!! you got the Aur Tu moment in your siggie box - wohooo to that! I want to chori it, but I also love love love the hug - oh why do they make choosing siggie dresses so so hard!!! GK are like this bolt of reality inside a fairy tale! Makes you want to throw away any chick flick you ever liked to love the love of these two!!!

And yes - isn't Malaal such a perfect comparison?! Even though Jawad and Kesar are a far cry?
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: JZephyr

OMG Nur!!! you got the Aur Tu moment in your siggie box - wohooo to that! I want to chori it, but I also love love love the hug - oh why do they make choosing siggie dresses so so hard!!! GK are like this bolt of reality inside a fairy tale! Makes you want to throw away any chick flick you ever liked to love the love of these two!!!


And yes - isn't Malaal such a perfect comparison?! Even though Jawad and Kesar are a far cry?



Thanks, Jzee...actually it's the bit after the "aur tu" in the scene...I loved that bit when he glances at her bangles (the ones he's gifted her), smiles and then turns to leave...wonderful subtle moment.

This is the actual "aur tu" moment from the scene:



I kinda had a nostalgia attack on two fronts...one, I missed Gulaal in her open hair😆...two, the fact that she was wearing these very bangles in today's scene...dunno if it was co-incidence but I thought it was a poignant touch.
Edited by nureat01 - 14 years ago
without-fathom thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: nureat01



Thanks, Jzee...actually it's the bit after the "aur tu" in the scene...I loved that bit when he glances at her bangles (the one he's gifted her), smiles and then turns to leave...wonderful subtle moment.

This is the actual "aur tu" moment from the scene:



I kinda had a nostalgia attack on two fronts...one, I missed Gulaal in her open hair😆...two, the fact that she was wearing these very bangles in today's scene...dunno if it was co-incidence but I thought it was a poignant touch.


Oh yeh - I meant you revived 'aur tu' in your siggie space! 😆 Eeeh! Can you do the aur tu moments too, please?! I'll line them up in my box 😆 There's the one from the time he just comes back of course, when he asks her is she missed him... and then there's one when he takes her to visit her family (after taking Talli first time, grrr!) and on the way back she's all gushy about how happy her family was and he goes aur tu... which other aur tu moments do we have? I know I'm missing something!

And yes - I swear i noticed those bangles too - in the episode, then in the caps - and I still forgot to say... I think it was intentional from the CVs, trust them to do everything right! Like you said, the GK track is shaping up very very beautifully... I did think parting would be a good idea at this point, but 'good' is never word enough for the way the CV's execute their plans!
ritukaprithvi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#48
The scenes with those two are always very well done.
EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#49
When Kesar asked to Gulaal that meri ek binti hai...the way Gulaal responded with " Kya"..i donno why i felt there was a hope in her voice. i guess she hoped that he is going to ask not to break the DV...something on those lines
VJ-LNMDJ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#50
Nice post ...

ya, I too found some parts heart-breaking and the song was very fatalistic , almost depressing (and too full of Sudha-Raman), I too would have preferred another song... especially as this is an old song with some old movie coming to my mind as it played..

VJ

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".