Directors Good and Bad! - Page 5

Originally posted by: nethraa_99

I've been scratching my head over this too...

Somebody in EDT suggested that perhaps, before fever scene, she would have spoken to DIG sir and got the transfer cancelled

Even then, her exuberance is out of place....

They are showing Sai being clueless about Virat's hurt

Not possible.. because it's on the same night..she gets it cancelled after the cafe scene btw..

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

Well said asmi, I was disappointed with the show long back but still felt connected to sairat somewhere...but now it's not like that... No not even because of social distancing anymore... They look forced to me now, I mean even the roommates who live together for one year will be more close ... I am not expecting them to roll over eachother but atleast human tendency tho dhikaya, like sitting aliitle close while helping each other but here tho it's like there is unwritten rule that they are not supposed to touch eachother, I love both Neil and Ayesha expressions but only till the scenes where they are in distance but once where we expect them to show more closeness.... Ok I even don't want to comment on that...

KD mei this scene is literally you can feel emon and rano love for eachother, their passion for eachother, ghum can copy each and every dialogue of KD but they definitely ruined that passion and sorry to say sometimes actions speak a lot than words... Sitting near to you without even a single word will display hundred of emotions, but pages of emotional dialogues with 3 ft distance will ruin the whole scene...

Last one, I don't know who but they ruined sairat story... They ruined KD...

As asmi mentioned I respect the people who still loves ghum but for me it's the end of ghum I know

I completely agree with u mounika. This started with such promise and I actually thought it would go a long way but they have just destroyed it completely for me as well. Every scene looks forced or stretched or without meaning. Am really done as well.

Originally posted by: rac1

I completely agree with u mounika. This started with such promise and I actually thought it would go a long way but they have just destroyed it completely for me as well. Every scene looks forced or stretched or without meaning. Am really done as well.

And seems like there is no going back!!

I actually thought they have such a clearly thought out plan for drama elements. I was impressed when I read the synopsis. Devyani's illness, Samrat's entry..and through it all...Sairat's relationship progressing. Sai turning into more of a woman from being a young girl,is what I understood when I started watching the show initially.

I steadfastly refused to watch or hear about KD once I started watching. But when I read what you wrote about Emon's dialogues, she has so many layers, the conflict in her mind is so clear. Rono may misunderstand, but the audience understands both of them.Here, they are purposely keeping Sai at a childish level, 'immature' as people call her.

Totally agree with you. I jumped on this ghkkpm little late and was hooked on it by the initial epis. Out of curiosity I started watching KD. As I mentioned sometime back each and every character is so beautifully shown. Every action and dialogues between Dairat is so beautiful in KD it makes sense. And the Pp in KD is so awesome. RK is strong, -ve yet likeable. she has been there to enhance sairat. I loved her performance. She worked hard and rightfully drew sympathy unlike how it is forced on us by ghkkpm.

As I said Pp is necessary for Sairat growth, but the makers here should understand that without Sairat, especially Sai, there is no Pp or Sammy. They have to concentrate more on Sairat. The dialogues need to be much heartfelt and stronger like KD. They hardly show any monologues here. The writing, direction and performance of the fl needs to improve.
I too don’t know how long I can hold on. After binge watching to catch up, I feel so sad now.
Hope the makers take our rants in the right way.