Rupkotha & Pakhi : Same fate? - Page 2

Originally posted by: blackhole

Ohh god! Did knew that it was like this... I don't know what hindi version holds in future but I don't feel that pakhi is at fault.

People here were like if she loved Virat how can she go in and marry samrat( when she didn't know the relationship that Virat and samrat shared). Like really? We fall in love but sometimes it's not meant to be... That doesn't give us a right to quit living.. yes sometimes we don't forget our first love easily... But that doesn't make is be unhappy. We bcome happy gradually in the relationship that has chosen us or our parents have chosen. But here things are diff. When pakhi came To know she denied marrying samrat. But Virat... I guess I am a bit disappointed in him. Not only He's okay to ruin the lives of his brother n lover by shoving them in what's going to be a loveless marriage more so because of his own presence about them but also he is going on and promising pakhi that he won't love anyone else! Like what the hell is he bloody doing😡

PS hi Arpi! Nice seeing you here😊

Originally posted by: Sarcastic_me

I don't remember d whole story exactly but in bengali one roopkatha came to know abt rano n vice - versa on d day of d shaadi ryt??? In bengali version rano was not a cry baby here when ever I see either virat is crying or sad. I guess dey will not spoil virat characterization like dey did in bengali one because dis show is promoted on virat Starting from first promo

Plus in bengali one dey took time to set things up at least one n half month dey took. Here with in second week dey started d whole thing. Very rushed characterization

Originally posted by: Aegon

Didn't watch other versions

In this one, I do like Pakhi so far

No matter how much time she spent with Virat, She is in love with him, she would've moved on with Samrat, if Virat didn’t clear her misunderstandings or didn’t tell her that he loves her too

He is leading her on, he is the one using love she has for him to force her into marrying his brother

I know she won't get happy ending because she is the other woman and Virat is shipped with Sai

Originally posted by: Arpita_De

Yes Virat is responsible for all the false hopes 🤔 It's easy to blame the other woman, I know in most cases it's the fault of other woman only but what we don't consider is may be that 'Other woman' too has a valid story, afterall who with a sane mind would want to be the 'Other woman' right?

Sad reality of our society, we expect women to be perfect in every situation, we pitch them against each other without thinking if these two women have same life story or struggle. Wont say men are forgiven easily because first we have to reach at a place where we put them responsible for something in order to forgive them.

Virat has to keep up an image of good brother so he forced Pakhi, good whatever to force Sai into marrying him

If he cares about his brother or Pakhi one bit, he wouldn't tell her about his sham of a marriage to Sai, Pakhi will hate him so what? She is just his bhabhi now, she can decide to get annulment or move on with Samrat thereafter

But Virat has to keep up the image of good lover too

I would have seen it as Pakhi's story but Indian dramas lack when it comes to taking story of two women forward, especially when they are in love with the same guy, it always will be Sai vs Pakhi for the position of Virat’s wife, not a story of Doctor Sai and mature Pakhi

Sorry, I have a different opinion here. I simply don't care about ViRakhi love story BUT neither Virat nor Pakhi have the right to cheat a third person (here Samrat) for whatever reason. I have seen such people in real world too. First they roam all around like they are never gonna part or nothing is going separate them. But if they happen to bid good bye to each other they so coolly cheat (yes, I call it cheating only) another person and settle in life. This is how most of the love stories end in our country. Sad but true!

I'm not saying Pakhi has no right to marry another man. But Pakhi is definitely wrong in hiding her love story before Samrat and his family. Even before things got cleared from Virat's side i.e., when she said ok for Samrat's rishta (thinking Virat cheated her), she didn't have the guts to inform Samrat that she for a certain period was in love with another guy and no longer wishes to be with him and want to move on in life.

Pakhi has the right to move on but not cheat someone because her so called lover was no longer in contact with her, hence I have no sympathy for Pakhi.

Virat is an IPS officer for sure but evidently is impractical at decision making. Even an ordinary person takes much better decisions especially when it is concerned with family & relationships.

All my sympathies are for Samrat & Sai only who will be unfairly dragged into this muddle named ViRakhi. Just imagine how heartbroken they will be, especially Samrat, after being aware of the truth. And I'm so sad to learn that this character will lose his life in near future.

Originally posted by: Arpita_De

Yes Virat is responsible for all the false hopes 🤔 It's easy to blame the other woman, I know in most cases it's the fault of other woman only but what we don't consider is may be that 'Other woman' too has a valid story, afterall who with a sane mind would want to be the 'Other woman' right?

Sorry but I don't think Pakhi has a valid story that we sympathize with her. There's something called moral sense of right and wrong in humans. It's not always like I'm in love with someone and I'm gonna do anything for their sake coz I'm in love with them. A person has to be thoughtful to every person around him. Even if I'm in love with someone I have no right to be unconcerned of others because it's their life too!

Why didn't Pakhi inform about her love story to Samrat the day when he came to see her? It's after things got cleared from Virat's side during Haldi she became keen on doing so right? Isn't it called selfishness? When she came to know the truth she is all set to give up rishta with Samrat!? If Virat didn't turn up, Samrat's rishta would be acceptable!? What sort of saneness is this? Samrat is not a lifeless material that you keep or discard as per your preference. I wish he asks Pakhi the same thing once her truth is out.

I hold Virat and Pakhi both accountable here. Pakhi is 26, I expected her to be more mature with the whole situation. Even if Virat asks her to marry his brother, she could have simply said it’s my life, I get to choose who I marry. And she could have left. That’s all it took. And I would be happy if she married Samrat because she wants to move on, but she just wants to be with Samrat to stay close to Virat. I don’t care how hurt she is, this is just disgusting ! Samrat asked her if she wasn’t happy with the marriage and she could have told about virat then, but she didn’t.

Similarly, virat is the worst. He didn’t need to act all mahan and sacrifice (I don’t even want to call it love). What does he think? Samrat will be happy to know about this AFTER Pakhi becomes his wife? I wish he would tell at them, ask them what they were thinking instead of just leaving. Virat was like saying to Pakhi. Marry my brother but also be with me. You won’t lose me.

He might not have meant that but saying to a girl, especially the one who you claim to ‘love’, to stay with him as a friend. Like dude, it’s not helping her move on at all. You are just using her by this point.

They both are just thinking me, you, us, our nonexistant love. Nothing else matters to them after that. They both are selfish and self-centered. Even Sai who is younger that them, is more mature than them.

Originally posted by: I-Am-SherLOCKED

EXACTLY! If they think this infatuation is pyaar, god knows how many times I've been in love till now 🤣

This!🤣

Originally posted by: AnonymouslyS

I hold Virat and Pakhi both accountable here. Pakhi is 26, I expected her to be more mature with the whole situation. Even if Virat asks her to marry his brother, she could have simply said it’s my life, I get to choose who I marry. And she could have left. That’s all it took. And I would be happy if she married Samrat because she wants to move on, but she just wants to be with Samrat to stay close to Virat. I don’t care how hurt she is, this is just disgusting ! Samrat asked her if she wasn’t happy with the marriage and she could have told about virat then, but she didn’t.

Similarly, virat is the worst. He didn’t need to act all mahan and sacrifice (I don’t even want to call it love). What does he think? Samrat will be happy to know about this AFTER Pakhi becomes his wife? I wish he would tell at them, ask them what they were thinking instead of just leaving. Virat was like saying to Pakhi. Marry my brother but also be with me. You won’t lose me.

He might not have meant that but saying to a girl, especially the one who you claim to ‘love’, to stay with him as a friend. Like dude, it’s not helping her move on at all. You are just using her by this point.

They both are just thinking me, you, us, our nonexistant love. Nothing else matters to them after that. They both are selfish and self-centered. Even Sai who is younger that them, is more mature than them.

Exactly !

I like virat as an officer, NOT as the dumb and selfish brother ( I do NOT call him lover/boyfriend - which he is not)!

He is well educated officer, do not get that simple logic that he is ruining 4 lives !

Why he did NOT tell everything to Samrat and let Samrat and pakhi decide (their lives at the stake right now - only they have rights to decide).

I do not understand this itv mahan gathas (highly unrealistic)

- that's why - my favorite itv character is Kusum kothari of SM !!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by: AnonymouslyS

I hold Virat and Pakhi both accountable here. Pakhi is 26, I expected her to be more mature with the whole situation. Even if Virat asks her to marry his brother, she could have simply said it’s my life, I get to choose who I marry. And she could have left. That’s all it took. And I would be happy if she married Samrat because she wants to move on, but she just wants to be with Samrat to stay close to Virat. I don’t care how hurt she is, this is just disgusting ! Samrat asked her if she wasn’t happy with the marriage and she could have told about virat then, but she didn’t.

Similarly, virat is the worst. He didn’t need to act all mahan and sacrifice (I don’t even want to call it love). What does he think? Samrat will be happy to know about this AFTER Pakhi becomes his wife? I wish he would tell at them, ask them what they were thinking instead of just leaving. Virat was like saying to Pakhi. Marry my brother but also be with me. You won’t lose me.

He might not have meant that but saying to a girl, especially the one who you claim to ‘love’, to stay with him as a friend. Like dude, it’s not helping her move on at all. You are just using her by this point.

They both are just thinking me, you, us, our nonexistant love. Nothing else matters to them after that. They both are selfish and self-centered. Even Sai who is younger that them, is more mature than them.

I keep on thinking Samrat does not deserve this!