Here is what i posted on the other forum. Since it applies to both the forums i am posting it here...
okay, so i am another person who watches both the shows and love them both... and its a bit sad to see ppl fighting over the shows... i am not defending any of these two shows, but stating what i feel about this whole problem...
About who copied whom- this discussion itself is pointless because both these shows come from the same production house that is 4lions films... the makers are same... the writers are same... so if they choose to recreate scenes from their own scripts, who r we to complain? the only thing i am bothered about is that we r getting good scenes...
And about including trps- i do think that it is a bit unfair to include trps in IF rankings because the channels are not comparable in their reach... Star Plus is a channel with a very wide reach all over India, while star one is a comparitively new channel which is not available in many parts of India. So obviously the trps wouldn't be comparable for a show in SP and for the one in SO..
So I feel that IF rankings should be based on the shows fan following on IF... which can include chaskameter, facebook and google plus likes, comments on forums, fanclubs etc..
BTW, i have a sincere doubt😕... what exactly does staying loyal to a show mean? Is it like staying loyal to ur boyfriend/husband? I mean if i am chatting on the ArHi AT, and Maaneet's Paradise at the same time, does that mean I am two-timing???😕
On this Friendship day, here are the reasons why i think we should all be friends...
1. We all are 'loyal'( i still dont know what that means... but nevertheless) fans of two shows that come from the same production house... i repeat, same Production House...
2. The shows are different, some scenes might seem similar, but well the brains behind the scenes are the same so, thats quite ok...
3. As mentioned somewhere above, the heroines of both the shows are really great friends. I remember reading somewhere that Dhrashti and Sanaya are really good friends... And i'm sure, Gurmeet and Barun also would make great friends if ever given the chance... They could even exchange views on how to play a ruthless businessman onscreen effectively...😆
4.And Finally, It would do some good to have some peace in both the forums... So please, lets exchange some friendship bands or maybe declare a ceasefire for our own health. You see, our BP levels are already affected by certain handsome and ruthless businessmen who have landed from the 4lions planet ( you could choose whoever appeals to u more.. as for me, i choose both). Why add to that by these fights...
Happy Friendship day everyone!
Dedicated to eternal peace on both the forums...
Harsha...
That's two posts from me on this forum... hope i have contributed to our show's ratings by this...
Edited by phoenixgirl - 14 years ago
63