~KhaMoshiyAn GuNgunAne LaGiIi ManEEt Ve MaHiIi~ - Page 50

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

61.1k

Users

50

Likes

2.7k

Frequent Posters

mechantefille thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: -honeydew-


Both of you ... i jsut have one question ... how would you feel if you were told one day that you love your new found best friend more than your sibling just cos you spend more time with the friend?
I think no production house/maker would disregard anything that it would create ...
The problem with GHSP is it has served its prime, and no one wants to admit it... its about time the show came to a logical end...
it was about Geet and her justice right ... the day she realised she had Maan by her side and she wanted to forgive her sinner, and get on with life, they could have ended the story ...and shown that this is the way she dealt with it ... not necessary that she would set such an example that everyone would in the world would follow the same.. that was Geets way of dealing with it ...!!
when geet walked off, and moved to Amritsar a whole new set of characters were brought in and we all love/(d) them ... we cant stop raving and ranting about Mamey, Lucky and the beautiful Pammi and Teji track ...we come and have our share of laughs ... yes the Maaneet romance has come down and i have a problem with that as well... but i think Maaneet have reached a stage where they cant do anything else .. wad will they do ... show touch romance scenes like in Odhani? i find that couple way too sugar coated as opposed to Maaneet who are more real .. they are not a couple that cant wait to get their hands on each other .. yes, it would have been nice if Geet at times behaved like she were in love, but i attribute it to her comfort with Maan ... can you imagine anyone else getting away with doing that with Maan .. no way ?
its always a case of wanting more than what you can actually get ... got back to the best phase of Maaneet the so called golden period you would still find some people cribbing about it ...
and the audience gets to share their opinion with the PH, but not tell them how to do their jobs ...
their new show is about to start in three days or so, and they perhaps have managed to work towards it as obv its a bigger channel ...
tell me one person who can be at two places at the same time... may be they have gone a little easy on Geet at times.. but they have made sure they do their regular doses of romance in their own way ! i can bet, go back to November you will love all the episodes now... but back in November we liked August better ... and now three months down the line we will love May too ... !!
we just look for that unknown we cant have, cos its all playing in our head, but the remote is sadly not in our hands !!


So SO true Nihu!! WHo does Geet have but Maan...have you ever had that one person in your life with whom you could do whatever and that person wouldn't mind at all!!! That's the best thing bout Maan…he never says anything to reprimand her..he just lets her be. She's with him – he loves her, she loves him….aur kya chahiye use. It's umbrage against these silly things that cause problems in the 1st place. Maani s smart not to make it a big thing. And I love that about him!!

That is what Maan and geet are to each other...true Maan has become extremely lovey dovey -But I have never seen him get angry with Geet and her so-called brash manner...why doesn't he react?? simply because it doesn't matter to him. He knows that in Geet's life - he is NO. 1 - she'll do anything for him - even if it means staying away from him with her angry family, give up the comforts of her aalishaan ghar and try to make them change their mind about her patidev!!

DOes Geet not know what her husband is made of? If she's annoyed with him it's because she doesn't want beeji to think any less of him!! Helllo!!!

If Maan is not angry with her, why are WE??

We fans tend to be so overly-critical - give them a break...it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!

mechantefille thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: deniac

@Vinu - i was trying to send u a PM but ur PM box is full... so i'm finally posting things here

These are a few observations...
1. Please convey to the director that he isnt able to get the act properly out of Drashti. Either its Drashti's acting which director isnt able to get out properly or its the character which has been now written really OTT.

2. This story was about Geet and all fans are used to seeing a strong Geet. Most of the fan base is females and though most r awed by MSK, a weak and silly Geet is somethign which fans cant stand.
3. All actors have been a bit OTT. Lucky with his humour, Maan's anger, Geet's sharp reactions... nuthing seems to be in limits... :(((

You don't like Lucky??? Gouri!!! Nahiii!!...He throws my bad mood outta the window every . damn.time!!
4. The story should revolve around Maan and Geet but for the past few weeks we have been getting only lucky, jhugnu, nandini, dev. Supporting characters are very important to a story and I understand that but sidelining the leads isnt something which can garner TRPs. Maneet are the trump card and need to get their share. Geet with other characters and Maan with other characters wont get the TRPs. Even if Maneet scenes r only for 4-5 minutes, the silliness of Geet's character is irritating the fans and also like the yesterday's song sequence where the precap had shown maan's chin on geet's shoulder, the actual epi didnt show it... so nice romantic scenes of Maneet are getting edited and that isnt going down well with the viewers.
I toh think Nandini , Dev , Pammi Mamey should get some screentime..it's ok if Gurti get some respite. DId u see the bags under their eyes!! poor babies!!

5. TRPs will increase only if strong story unfolds. Drama sell but it needs proper promotion. It has been very hard for everyone to digest that Dev has escaped all the punishments. Maan talks about usul but how can he think that Devini will happen??? Shouldnt dev tell nandini everything he has done till now and then let nandini take the decision???
6. The PH has been blaming the channel for all the flaws. When fans showered praises, the PH took all the praises and now that ppl r bashing, everything is being pushed on channel and actors. I think that is highly unprofessional.
7. Despite slight change in wardrobe for Geet, her clothes still do not suit that of a wife of a business tycoon. Please get her some classy salwar kameez.

Dheere dheere na babe...we ask Vinu for some change - then he'll tell the team - them they'll order the clothes -they'll stitch -she'll wear - 2 more days to shoot - then a few more for the editing and then screening!!
8. Geet has become a typical house wife doing only the ghar ka kaam at beeji's place. She has forgotten that she used to be Maan's secy and has also done a few projects successfully with him. Maan also has forgotten that Geet used to be involved in his work and isnt consulting her for anything he does. He is putting up a water treatment plant in Beeji's name but geet is clueless about it. Fans watch Star one for the youth based show. If they wanted to watch a house wife, they casn very well watch Star Plus or Zee or Colors.

She doesn't need to work...did Geet ever express a wish to work...never...earlier she worked to survive...keep her baby safe...now once they get back to delhi, she could probably work.
Plus why would Maan want to stress her with work..he'd toh obviously want her to enjoy life naa. hehehe.
9. Maneet are married and geet keeps pushing and slapping maan... the scenes hv become repetitive and to an extent boring... if u cant show passionate maneet atleast avoid showing geet's silliness...

she's toh slapping him cuz she's terrified that Beeji will appear and show them the hand again when they're doing their angolis...she's more worried for Maan.
Vinu - my objective is to just let you know why the fans (including me) are disappointed and y the TRPs r low. whatever i hv written to u isnt my observation only of fans at IF and FB... these r the complains of the fans who are TRP viewers and who used to watch geet but now dont watch it since the time Geet touched dev during holi... Post holid, TRP has nvr reached an average of even 0.7. The show that used to have an average TRP of 0.8-1.0 suddenly went down... y??? think think... just coz none can accept a punishment free Dev...
Hmm ...Dev should clear things out..lets see.
I hope u r able to get some of the things rectified in the near future... am hoping to watch a strong and sensible Geet once again... Thank u... n yeah i am hoping to get to chat up with u on our IDIOTZ thread.
Take care... stay in touch... n please do respond so i know that u hv read this...
🤗
Gouri

TSharan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mechantefille


So SO true Nihu!! WHo does Geet have but Maan...have you ever had that one person in your life with whom you could do whatever and that person wouldn't mind at all!!! That's the best thing bout Maan'he never says anything to reprimand her..he just lets her be. She's with him ' he loves her, she loves him'.aur kya chahiye use. It's umbrage against these silly things that cause problems in the 1st place. Maani s smart not to make it a big thing. And I love that about him!!

That is what Maan and geet are to each other...true Maan has become extremely lovey dovey -But I have never seen him get angry with Geet and her so-called brash manner...why doesn't he react?? simply because it doesn't matter to him. He knows that in Geet's life - he is NO. 1 - she'll do anything for him - even if it means staying away from him with her angry family, give up the comforts of her aalishaan ghar and try to make them change their mind about her patidev!!

DOes Geet not know what her husband is made of? If she's annoyed with him it's because she doesn't want beeji to think any less of him!! Helllo!!!

If Maan is not angry with her, why are WE??

We fans tend to be so overly-critical - give them a break...it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!

Well having doing 2 shows might not be easy...but then when was life ever easy for anyone???? Is it easy for you or easy for me????? We all work hard, sweat and toil in our workspace!!!!! Also, ever heard never go beyond your means??????? So if they don't have the capacity...why venture into it??? Poor capacity planning...I would say as I tell my team!!!!!!😃
If they can't handle 2 shows...they are not fit to be in this industry...every creditable PH has multiple shows going on. That's the only way to move surge ahead of other competitors and grow...
I for one surely enjoy the show to the hilt!!!! Many of us here are good mature audience who empathize with our actors. I know the people involved toil to get the episodes to us...the audience...but if the product is faltering somewhere dont we have the right to point those things out??????
Let me know if you have never complained to your Cell phone provider about their service...this is a small example!!!!
Edited by Anshu_A - 14 years ago
-Deepzz- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mechantefille

So SO true Nihu!! WHo does Geet have but Maan...have you ever had that one person in your life with whom you could do whatever and that person wouldn't mind at all!!! That's the best thing bout Maan'he never says anything to reprimand her..he just lets her be. She's with him ' he loves her, she loves him'.aur kya chahiye use. It's umbrage against these silly things that cause problems in the 1st place. Maani s smart not to make it a big thing. And I love that about him!!

That is what Maan and geet are to each other...true Maan has become extremely lovey dovey -But I have never seen him get angry with Geet and her so-called brash manner...why doesn't he react?? simply because it doesn't matter to him. He knows that in Geet's life - he is NO. 1 - she'll do anything for him - even if it means staying away from him with her angry family, give up the comforts of her aalishaan ghar and try to make them change their mind about her patidev!!

DOes Geet not know what her husband is made of? If she's annoyed with him it's because she doesn't want beeji to think any less of him!! Helllo!!!

If Maan is not angry with her, why are WE??

We fans tend to be so overly-critical - give them a break...it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!


An good audience leaves honest feedback whether good or bad... A feedback is taken for the sole purpose of improvement of the show...It gives a clear idea of what majority of the viewers want...If a PH cannot juggle 2 shows at a time without literally sinking the show...then they better forget having long career in showbiz...They are not ready to join the big leagues..May be they should go back to school to learn some time and resource management...

I prefer being a critical fan .. giving my honest feedback for the betterment of the show rather than a couple of Chatty Kathy's who waste time praising crappiest of tracks..
Edited by kadydeep - 14 years ago
liv2laugh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mechantefille


We fans tend to be so overly-critical - give them a break...it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!



We fans tend to be so overly-critical - give them a break...

It is kind of like being a friend. What kind of friend would you be if you only praised your friend but you did not tell your friend when they were wrong. It would mean you do not really care about your friend. I believe in giving feedback because I believe when people do a good job they deserve a pat on the back. By the same yardstick, when they mess up it is our responsibility as loyal fans to let them know that they went wrong. That is what loyal fans do because they want the show to get better and reach new heights.

Sometimes being a good friend means telling the hard truth which may be unpalatable. But if you are a good friend and you want to save your friend, you will tell the truth. This is exactly the same. Praising someone falsely will not do them any favors, instead it will lead to disaster. They say it is only when you are in trouble that you know who your friends are because your true friends will tell you the truth to your face. If you are a true fan, give them honest feedback, but be polite. Sometimes you may need to be firm, but that does not mean you are being negative. People have often realized later that the truest friends are those who told them the truth to their face.

Again the point I am trying to make is, just because people give critical feedback does not mean that they are enemies of the show. It means they are really interested in the betterment of the show.

.it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!

Never bite off more than you can chew. If you took on an extra job because you wanted to move up in life, can you slack off and not do justice to your old job. Nope if you want to keep both jobs, you will concentrate on both. Bottomline, if you cannot manage 2 jobs why take them on unless you can do justice to both? You will be left high and dry. If you cannot handle both jobs, don't take it on. Be happy with what you have or go the distance and do justice to both.




Edited by liv2laugh - 14 years ago
Taiyo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
What is a show's forum for to enjoy * WHAT* : Discussion based on episodes and if someone is analyzing it -- even if over-critically -- and is expressing unhappiness over a track: WHAT is Wrong in that? It's the Forum and everyone has the right to post their opinion without a group having the attitude of "I know it all" so you better shut-up.

Yes, the dignity of language should be maintained.

Infinitedreams thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
Guys chill, you all have all right to give your honest feedback, but directly or indirectly, no one has right to attack...It's LV post, if anyone wrong here, i dont think so it is wise to somehow you all follow the same...It's better everyone just come here, give their feedback and honest views and leave, rest on LV to decide.

I dont think so anyone has right to attack, and i see that every single person is coming and quoting Amru. It is better if 1 already did, cause end of the day you are the gang, so why each and everyone quoting her and giving same bhashan?

Leave the poor soul, and better talk about show, waise hi fed up with this whole track😭, so bring some constructive ideas...





Muniza
Edited by muniza75 - 14 years ago
fatim30 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
.it's tough enough having 2 shows on at a go...relax..enjoy the show...don't keep dissing it, just because yo can...be a good audience!!

ok those who say this ...then this PH doesnt deserve to be in telle industry...balaji telefilms running too many shows at same time...well this is no excuse😕
swan20 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: mechantefille




@blue bold...This is not the 1st Production House to handle more than 1 show nor will it be the last. They are doing business here and if the customers/ viewers feel that something is amiss then they have every right to voice out their displeasure. They receive praise when things go right then they should be able to accept criticism too.


And what is the definition of a ''good audience''? For me a good audience is one who gives a honest feedback. If I'm not happy with what's presented to me I will say it. I'm certainly not dissing it just because I can but because I genuinely love the show and would like to see it do better. Isn't that what we all want?

liv2laugh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
@ Muni

One of the issues is that the constructive feedback gets lost because everything else. 😳

I have given constructive feedback also - please check page 67 😳

No one is attacking anyone. If you are replying to someone, you have to quote them. Otherwise how do they know you are talking to them. 😳

Quoting is not allowed in the den, but her since people were double quoting, I assumed that was the way to go. 😳

Infact when I read through the thread I noticed everyone was quoting multiple times.

That was the only reason I quoted her. I rarely come on this thread because I do not feel welcome here.

I am not trying to start a war of words here. Muni you know me better than that. All I am trying to do is make a point.

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: priya_21 · 4 years ago

When Two Hearts Are Meant To Be Together... No Matter How Long It Takes... No Matter How Far They Go... No Matter How Tough It Seems... Love...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mg13 · 1 years ago

hey guys... here is my new thread...my previous threads got removed so links will not be opened... so will pm you update link soon.. wait for a...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: amrutha11 · 5 months ago

Hi everyone, I forgot tthe name of the story of maan and geet. The story line is maan dadhi force geet to marry her grandson maan whose half...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".