Geet's blood is inferior? Nope - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

2.8k

Users

16

Likes

125

Frequent Posters

happygolucky thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: LuvScooby

Maan and Geet were both wrong.........However, MSK's anger always overtakes his wisdom and that makes him weaker/inferior than Geet


I do agree with u😊
Serenity_me thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#32
both maan n geet r wrong to some extent,,,,first geet shouldn;t hv allowed dev to put rang on her,,even i couldn't digest this idea of cv. so i will blame cv 4 this mess....they r butchering all characters....

maan was right in his anger,,,his anger s justified,,,he questioned geet, about dev,,it was also justified.he has full rights to ask geet. but maan shouldn't hv raised gairat issue to geet.


both need to hv a mature talk,,,why don;t they just sit n talk straight,,,,chalo now geet has left d KM, now maneet can start their romance on road once again,,,,😆 n i know they will bounce back, cv make dev negative or close his chapter 😆,,
Edited by SlovHanda - 14 years ago
happygolucky thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: SlovHanda

both maan n geet r wrong to some extent,,,,first geet shouldn;t hv allowed dev to put rang on her,,even i couldn't digest this idea of cv. so i will blame cv 4 this mess....they r butchering all characters....

maan was right in his anger,,,his anger s justified,,,he questioned geet, about dev,,it was also justified.he has full rights to ask geet. but maan shouldn't hv raised gairat issue to geet.


both need to hv a mature talk,,,why don;t they just sit n talk straight,,,,chalo now geet has left d KM, now maneet can start their romance on road once again,,,,😆 n i know they will bounce back, cv make dev negative or close his chapter 😆,,


What a powerful analysis 😆
bobby13rocks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#34
Hey Avi,acc to me the cv's were wrong coz Barry has clarified in fb that he never scripted that Dev would put colour on Geet....so if the scene was not there such circumstances wouldn't have arisen that would provoke Maan to utter those words.........still I think that Maan's anger overpowered his wisdom....I'm quoting the words of Barry..

Barry's reply to a fan...on his FB wall


Barry Dhillon Akeelah i never wanted dev to touch geet... in fact i was strictly against it... but then I m not the only one who takes the creative calls... i never wrote it in my script.... it was call taken at the last moment on sets by CVs from production house and channel!!
AnuN thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: kuls11


What you think sure is not what all think right! Like see i don't think of it as you do nor you as I ... as i said to each their own.

exactly ever crime can be forgiven but not sin,

what Dev did is not a mere crime but sin & since you have brought in both Bible & Ramayan by mentioning Rishi Valmiki i could like to add robbing a innocent girl of her virginity is a Sin not crime coz it not just kills her trust but marks her soul & brings on her a daily death....were as killing people is crime since here man dies once not daily.

God who is spring of forgiveness He too has built a place as Hell as a place for sinners. Why did God do that if giving forgiveness is so easily!
yes repentence earns you forgiveness but how can a woman ever forget the man who raped her, can she forget as a woman i cannot if i were her. forgive him sure she can as she has a big heart but welcome him as family no woman can.

Maan had heard her forgive Dev not that day but the day before & every single frame after that in none of them he questioned her self respect ...

when did he do that..

only when he saw her allow Dev to celebrate holi with her, to touch her with those same hands that had once stripped her of her innocence instead of cringing she applied tilak to him which again according to Hindu religion is mark of respect shown.

Did Dev deserve this respect from her! Its this acceptance & showing respect to Dev that makes Maan question her self respect ... not her forgiving Dev

You are totally mistaken.. As per all religions, sins are forgiven.. crime is just a legal term for the same. Even killing some one is a sin not just crime. And Hell is for ppl who dont seek forgiveness.. like Hiranakashayap.. since its Holi time, remember his example..
When God can melt and make you a rishi from a brutal murderer and give you devine respect of being able to write Ramayna even before it actually took place, why Geet a human can not forgive and give Dev respect...
As per Islam, the sin of idol worship which is considered highest level of sin can be forgiven if one seek forgiveness.
happygolucky thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: AnuN

You are totally mistaken.. As per all religions, sins are forgiven.. crime is just a legal term for the same. Even killing some one is a sin not just crime. And Hell is for ppl who dont seek forgiveness.. like Hiranakashayap.. since its Holi time, remember his example..
When God can melt and make you a rishi from a brutal murderer and give you devine respect of being able to write Ramayna even before it actually took place, why Geet a human can not forgive and give Dev respect...
As per Islam, the sin of idol worship which is considered highest level of sin can be forgiven if one seek forgiveness.


I agree😊
Yazzi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: happygolucky


On the issue of who is worng. I think both of them r wrong for the entire mess but they will be back soon. Manneet can't stay away from each other😳

THANK YOU!!
At last some one realises it's not just Geet or it's not just Maan, it's both of them. What's that saying in Hindi "Taali ek haath se nahin baj thi". 😕
Yes, Geet is wrong, but she's not entirely wrong. She's not wrong in forgiving Dev, because that shows her strength, however she is wrong in forgetting about what he did which shows how naive she really is Maan is not wrong in hating the fact that she's forgiving Dev after what he did, but he is wrong in saying that she has no self respect 😭 That's very hurtful, and what women would want to hear that coming from her own husband ?? 😕
The CVs are really screwing up the show big time 🤢😡
rabia04ful thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#38
well..
i will just say tht maan in anger dont really realize wht does he do or say..
previously in anger maan mishandled geet n later regret tht act of his..
now this time too...nothing can work in his anger..
i m bit disappointed the way cvz hv tried to create MU...there could hv been some other plot than this..
maan saying such harsh words...even he didnt mean them..but still it was way harsh when nothing much has happened...
i felt bad for geet...
Silentsoul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: AnuN

You are totally mistaken.. As per all religions, sins are forgiven.. crime is just a legal term for the same. Even killing some one is a sin not just crime. And Hell is for ppl who dont seek forgiveness.. like Hiranakashayap.. since its Holi time, remember his example..
When God can melt and make you a rishi from a brutal murderer and give you devine respect of being able to write Ramayna even before it actually took place, why Geet a human can not forgive and give Dev respect...
As per Islam, the sin of idol worship which is considered highest level of sin can be forgiven if one seek forgiveness.

Firstly we have lost the focus if i see now then Geet has but a single mention & rest seems religious preaching, too much of it makes it demeaning religion & i plead not to use them as don't know when we cross our supposed limitation & end up offending someone ...sure thats the last thing we want to do.

No i'm not mistaken ..as i said to each their own, as they see things , as they believe it.

Killing some one is is a crime be it in eyes of law or religion,

Indeed hell is for people who do not seek forgiveness & are hence punished for eternity . But again who decides that the redemption has been aptly done.

Being a woman i could never show respect to a man who had stripped me of my self respect & treated me as a flesh alone. Thats what Geet has faced from Dev..no amount of redemption can give her back what she lost.

Respect..well my question never was that Geet is right or wrong in giving respect to Dev. I only pointed did Dev deserve this respect. Never.

Rape victim i've personally known cringe at the remembarance of it, i though wanted to ask her this but felt it insesitive & brutal to to push this question on her as to who could she react , could she show respect to the man who robbed her of her virginity.

I don't want to blindly fight just to win esp. not in context with religion it was nice till it lasted discussing with you
AnuN thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: kuls11

Firstly we have lost the focus if i see now then Geet has but a single mention & rest seems religious preaching, too much of it makes it demeaning religion & i plead not to use them as don't know when we cross our supposed limitation & end up offending someone ...sure thats the last thing we want to do.

No i'm not mistaken ..as i said to each their own, as they see things , as they believe it.

Killing some one is is a crime be it in eyes of law or religion,

Indeed hell is for people who do not seek forgiveness & are hence punished for eternity . But again who decides that the redemption has been aptly done.

Being a woman i could never show respect to a man who had stripped me of my self respect & treated me as a flesh alone. Thats what Geet has faced from Dev..no amount of redemption can give her back what she lost.

Respect..well my question never was that Geet is right or wrong in giving respect to Dev. I only pointed did Dev deserve this respect. Never.

Rape victim i've personally known cringe at the remembarance of it, i though wanted to ask her this but felt it insesitive & brutal to to push this question on her as to who could she react , could she show respect to the man who robbed her of her virginity.

I don't want to blindly fight just to win esp. not in context with religion it was nice till it lasted discussing with you

I have not lost any focus. I am talking about Geet forgiving Dev and why its right. For your information, word crime does not exist in any religious book. They refers to all such acts as sins.
I dont need to worry what you could have done or what not, I need to know what God would have told us to do and thats why I quoted religion as thats the most right way to decided b/w right and wrong at least for me.. And just refering to religion for issues does not demean it. You are again mistaken. Religion is meant to be an ultimate guide to all issues. And yes, regarding your question, who decides if the repentence is true, as a human Geet can just believe what she sees Dev is doing. If he is being hypocryte.. then God is there to take care of such ppl. I always believe such ppl will then get more right punishment there then.
Also, just to let you know, I know we are not here to win or loose.. these are fictional chars.. All I was trying to understand is diff b/w right and wrong. I still feel forgiveness is a great virtue..
on a side note, I'm a huge fan of Maan and Geet both.. Because they make maaneet for which I watched this show till now.
Also, the reason, why I'm overly attached to religions is, I'm a hindu, from panjab so have been to gurudwara's also a lot, now married to a muslim.. and used to live near a church before when I was in NJ and some nuns used to visit me often and teach things from bible too.. So I have been attached to 4 religions very much and equally respect them and love them
Edited by AnuN - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee · 10 months ago

Prologue The Khurana mansion, a symbol of power and legacy, stood quietly under the darkened sky. But within its walls, peace had become a...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

She met him in an unfavorable time when she was running behind the time to save him. Save the only one member of his family whom she call his...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 1 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan · 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m · 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".