Roop Tera Mastana

Just wondering which one do you guys think was better

i know we arent suppose to compare but...maaneet are too HOT!!

Maan-Geet was better. I've 2 problems with Kitni...
1. They are too mechanical. Their emotions are not that of love but of lust.
2. Kitni is using remix version of the old song so for me the whole sensuousness has gone.
GC-DD portrayed it better as they were showing love (not lust), attraction & passion for each other.
Kitni... seems to be more skin show... it's like watching any other hollowood movie where hero jumps over heroine.
In Geet there was a touch of innocence was there. But I don't know the storyline of Kitni so I can't say.... It might be the demand of the story but as far as I know Ekta doesn't cater to the demands of the story... she just delivers what sells...😡

Originally posted by: misty85

Maan-Geet was better. I've 2 problems with Kitni...
1. They are too mechanical. Their emotions are not that of love but of lust.
2. Kitni is using remix version of the old song so for me the whole sensuousness has gone.
GC-DD portrayed it better as they were showing love (not lust), attraction & passion for each other.
Kitni... seems to be more skin show... it's like watching any other hollowood movie where hero jumps over heroine.
In Geet there was a touch of innocence was there. But I don't know the storyline of Kitni so I can't say.... It might be the demand of the story but as far as I know Ekta doesn't cater to the demands of the story... she just delivers what sells...😡

I agree... I wanted to write but did not know how to put it... You have put up everything very nicely... 👏

Originally posted by: Azmatazz

I agree... I wanted to write but did not know how to put it... You have put up everything very nicely... 👏

Its more of Love VS Lust , passion and innocence (at the same time) VS desires

Thanxs for ur appriciation. Well I'm not a blind follower of Geet so I just wanted to see things logically. These things look sensuous when there is a touch of innocence in it. You can also feel for the actors on screen. In the original song sequence Rajesh Khanna didn't touch Sharmila (in the first part) but even then it was very sensuous. The reason is same.

Originally posted by: misty85

Maan-Geet was better. I've 2 problems with Kitni...
1. They are too mechanical. Their emotions are not that of love but of lust.
2. Kitni is using remix version of the old song so for me the whole sensuousness has gone.
GC-DD portrayed it better as they were showing love (not lust), attraction & passion for each other.
Kitni... seems to be more skin show... it's like watching any other hollowood movie where hero jumps over heroine.
In Geet there was a touch of innocence was there. But I don't know the storyline of Kitni so I can't say.... It might be the demand of the story but as far as I know Ekta doesn't cater to the demands of the story... she just delivers what sells...😡

yes i agree with every point........you have stated.....