Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

14.6k

Users

16

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

lucky_lakshmi thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#21

Oh Its getting mixed reactions...

I have said this before n repeat...Making a film out of Fyodor Dostoevsky work is one herculean task doing which most will falter like it or not...Why That Man's name initself means The Gift Of God! 😳 😳 😳 shhhh How I love him n his books!!! 😳 😳 😳

N White Nights Is a POEM ON WRITING...The Most pure and beaiful Love Story I have ever read in my Life! 😳 😳 😳

But wait wait..Is Rani Mukherjee playing The NARRATOR??? πŸ˜• well thats one Big change Sanjay made...In the story, its Ranbir's character who narrates...I feel that its better if that was so I mean you can get his emotions right like that...

But of course Dostoevsky Is Dostoevsky... 😳 😳 But Sanjay..Plz Plz u cant have ruined such a beautiful innocent tale!😳😭 After that truly splendid 'Black', we believe u are the best director now!πŸ˜‰

well as Subhash K. Jha says..It HAS TO BE SUBTLE..Coz the story itself is such a subtle one...

Oh I do hope it isnt that bad..The reviews are disappoiting coz I expected it to be much much more..But what am I saying I havent even seen it πŸ˜† πŸ˜† πŸ˜†

PS: but for a world of critics who love all kinda masala movies, Tis just maybe too aesthetic what say??? (Well Indian Masses ki choice ki baat nahiin ki jaaye toh behtar hai...πŸ˜†)

Edited by lucky_lakshmi - 18 years ago
ProdigalStudent thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#22

User Movie Reviews Average Rating: 2.56

Sort By : Date (Asc/Desc) - Rating (Asc/Desc) - Most Helpful (Asc/Desc) - User Name (Asc/Desc)

| Write your own review |

By sheby sulaiman, November 9, 2007 - 11:32 IST
it is a bluish back ground film which passing in nail speed. the film has excellent set and commandable performance by ranbir raj(ranbir kapoor). but from the biginning part it...

[ Full Review ]

1.5



By sohn Von GOTT D, November 9, 2007 - 11:19 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
one of d best film!!! only those who understand films will be able to appreciate d movie!!! RANBIR 10/10 wat a dude!!! d guy is made to reign in d film industry!!!

[ Full Review ]

5



By hasan ahmed, November 9, 2007 - 11:14 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Movie rocks and i can't say anythink to taran that what happen to you man last year you did same think against Don and Jaaneman and Don was hit but this time i can understand...

[ Full Review ]

4.5



By Adnan Khan, November 9, 2007 - 10:54 IST
A totally bakwaaaaaas movie..... hey dears "Shah rukh Khan" is the king of bollywood. OsO will b the biggest hit of 2007. dont waste ur money & time for Saawarya. mst watch...

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By Nisa Ali, November 9, 2007 - 09:08 IST
1 of 3 people found this review helpful
BAKWASSSSSSSS SLB shouldn't have released the movie during Diwali, its a week of celebration & happiness, just dont understand whats wrong with SLB

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By Ashish Patel, November 9, 2007 - 08:50 IST
A nurtal critic would say "How could a well renowed and well established and polished director can make such a worst movie?"...there is a small line between confidence and...

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By pritn futn, November 9, 2007 - 08:03 IST
2 of 3 people found this review helpful
beautiful movie just as good as i had expected wonderful! watch it! it is beautiful, different and very sweet! a must see for everyone! forget om shanti om ive seen it and...

[ Full Review ]

5



By Aryan Khanna, November 9, 2007 - 07:02 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Saawariya is an awesome film; a film only SLB could have made - something that has never been seen before. It is not for meant for people who like their masala movies. Its more...

[ Full Review ]

3.5



By Ksang Tenzin, November 9, 2007 - 05:06 IST
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Oh my god..Luv this movie..U know Shahrukh is an overact..he is a showoff..Ranbir and Sonam's gonna be a huge superstar..Sanjay Leela Bhansali have again proved that he is one...

[ Full Review ]

5



By Kamran qureshi, November 9, 2007 - 04:58 IST
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
SETS = 10 / 10 Ranbir Kapoor = 10 / 10 Sonam Kapoor = 5 / 10 Story = 7 / 10 Director = 10 / 10 Music = 10 / 10 On the whole Movie was Ok but the story seems to be...

[ Full Review ]

By s g, November 9, 2007 - 04:11 IST
SLB has lost his mind. I don't know what he was trying to make, but surely not a movie. After Aishwarya's marriage, SLB has turned Gay and he showed Ranbir naked (100%...

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By shrutika vasudeva, November 9, 2007 - 01:57 IST
REALLy great movie!

[ Full Review ]

5



By jony roy, November 9, 2007 - 01:22 IST
sawariya is the most foul film of this year.no storyline.but ranbir is good but if the storyline is not good then acting is going to dull.the most dissapointment film of the...

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By sougato basu, November 9, 2007 - 01:16 IST
pathetic movie sawaariya!! boring. not to see.

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By sofi kuaja, November 9, 2007 - 00:51 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Great movie...unlike any other bollywood film..a must see atleast once to know what good cinema looks like!

[ Full Review ]

5



By bangali fua, November 9, 2007 - 00:46 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Saawariya doesn't meet the expectation. SLB concentration was more on the colors then the main story, wish the new comers best of luck for future on other hand OSO is winner all...

[ Full Review ]

1



By Manu Singh, November 9, 2007 - 00:34 IST
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Any Sanjay Leela Bhansali's movie is a pleasure and this is no different. Cinematography is awesome. Person who admires great direction, great visuals and class act direction...

[ Full Review ]

5



By dnishadp pp, November 8, 2007 - 23:22 IST
bakwas movie...Sanjay the director should come out of his dreams and make sensible stories and then add his imagination to stories..This has no storyline...and its tooo boring....

[ Full Review ]

0.5



By kate m, November 8, 2007 - 21:58 IST
Saawariya disappoints!!!!.. Ranbir and Sonam are good but the movie is not so great.. story is dull and quite boring. Expected something much much better.. The only plus point...

[ Full Review ]

1



By N D, November 8, 2007 - 21:49 IST
totally self-indulging movie. very poor

[ Full Review ]

Source: http://www.indiafm.com/movies/userreviews/12780/index2.html

Overall Om Shanti Om did better in the user reviews and got a rating of 3.55 in User Reviews compared to Saawariya's 2.56

Edited by meteora_smt - 18 years ago
darkness_123 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Fashion_2005


Hey darkness, can you please small review, audience reaction and what went wrong in the movie?



*Possible mild spoilers. They don't reveal anything about the plot; it's just a few details*

Saawariya. About 15.5 hours have lapsed since I've seen the movie. I slept for 12 hours of those. I got up today, hoping it was just one big nightmare. Sadly,this was not the case.

The problem with Saawariya? Where do I even begin? Maybe like all the reviews state, it's way all the Raj Kapoor "odes" are shoved in our face. Again and again and again. We get it. He's the dude's grandson. GOT IT. NOW STOP.

Maybe it's the lack of reasons given for ANYTHING. Like one question that come to mind is: What was this "oh so important work" Salman's character does "for the country"???

Also the sheer idiocy at points. Sakina's blind grandmother keeps her SAFETY PINNED to her at all times. Yes, this is not a metaphorical use of the term "Safety Pinned", if there is such a thing. The girl's skirt is perpetually pinned to her Granny's. Which leads to quite an embarrassing situation for Sakina, when she in a haste to see Iman (Salman), pulls too hard against the pin, rips her skirt and lands on the floor with her freakishly long leg exposed. But does the safety pinning stop Sakina from sneaking out every night and crying on the bridge?? No, the wily minx just safety pins her maid to the granny. Smart. πŸ‘ 🀒

And the sheer number of prostitutes in the town. The town's population consisted of 80% prostitutes. The only other MEN I saw in the town were Ranbir's character and these three shady drunkards who pursued Sakina in her very first scene.One of the dunkards makes a reappearance to sneeze in a lewd manner, aiming at Sakina. Who was going to avail of the services of these women? Not Raj for sure. He was one of the "Prostitutes are friends, not sex objects" people, the only one in the town. Most everyone else in the town is female ("Lilipop" [sweet, adorable Zohra Seghal has never been more aggravating in the history of cinema], Sakina, Sakina's grandmom, Sakina's aunt/maid whatever, some random Khala of Sakina she meets in the street, etc)

A very pertinent question: Why is EVERYTHING blue? Why? Why??? Blue being one of my favorite colours, is something I loathe now. Thank you SLB.

The only scenes I found that made me smile, or go aww, or touched me even a little bit, were the three scenes Salman Khan was in. *Highlight to read possible spoiler* The scene where Sakina falls asleep next to him fanning him, and wakes up to find her self safety pinned to him was sweet. It showed that though the character seemed aloof and "khadooos", he wasn't. He was mischevious and had a kooky sense of fun.πŸ˜› Also the scene where *Highlight* Sakina finds out Iman has to leave and goes running and... uh.. faints? dies? I dunno what.... in his arms.... And he lays her down gently and they just stay there like that, her lying down, him bending over her, the both pressing cheek to cheek, Sakina's cheeks slick with tears. Very very well done.πŸ‘ A shining light in a power cut fest. There was no obvious/overt sexuality, like kissing or groping or desperate looks, but it was a passionate and sensual scene that made you go "awwwwwwww", not embarassed to watch with your parents or anything....

Rani Mukherjee's character. Her English was ANNOYING. One of her first sentences is "Jab yeh Razia ki Lalli roti hai, mujhe bada sad sad feel hota hai. I DONT LIKES." That one line was enough to make to want to kill myself, coz I knew anything else she said was going to be in this form. She exudes these pearls of wisdom, but fails to take her own advice at times. She tells Raj "Dont love someone so much, that you begin to hate yourself"... Which is what ultimately happens to her... Sad. Not really, but I'm sure that's what SLB wanted us to feel for her. Didn't really work.

Ranbir carries the movie off on his shoulder, with very little support from Sonam. The girl is pretty, no doubt, but she aint no actress. Or maybe she is, and this just isn't the script for her. Ranbir is ok to watch, good in some parts, over the top with the weird expressions in others. Most of the parts where he's contorting his face are in the promos. Which is a shame. He has plenty of good parts, which wouldn't make people think he was retarded in the movie (like I did)... He's definitely a guy with potential, who just needs to find the right kind of role for himself...

The innate problem with Saawariya is that it tries too hard to be all "poetry in motion".. Yes, the story does have a slight flowy, fairy-tale-ish side to it, but SLB plays up that aspect so much, that the plot and basic logic take a hit. It ends up looking very pseudo intelletual. The sets, the music, the costumes, the dialogues, even the over the top flowery ways the characters move (watch Sakina and Raj jump around potholes like they're playing kabbadi, the over the top way she swoons into Iman's arms, the smack you int the face dance-y undertones as they both lean into each other under the bridge in the Masha-Allah song....),everything is so over the top that sometimes you feel claustrohobic and overwhelmed. Yet it makes you feel like something is vey much lacking.

Audience reaction. Well, most of the people I watched it with seemed as disappointed as I was. Everyone was questioning one or another part of the movie for a lapse in reasoning. Half the people looked relieved when the movie got over, rubbing their eyes like they had gotten up from a particularly boring class. My friend who I watched it with, said "Ranbir was okay, but the rest of it was bull. I want my money back". Don't we all, lovely friend? Don't we all?
Edited by darkness_123 - 18 years ago
darkness_123 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#24

Here's a professionally written review I found on rediff that echoed every single sentiment in my head while watching the movie.
Link: https://specials.rediff.com/movies/2007/nov/08sd1.htm

|

Next

Sitting through Saawariya

What follows does not purport to be a review of Saawariya -- the premiere last night, at the Adlabs theatre in Wadala, left me in too enfeebled a condition to attempt such a hazardous task. So what you get are random riffs, a selection of isolated thoughts that occurred while I was watching the film. With that for preamble, here goes: Sanjay Leela Bhansali's latest film, Saawariya, raises the bar of the cinema aesthetic to dizzying heights. Using a predominantly blue palette leavened on rare occasions with greens and magentas, writer-director Bhansali and art directors Omung and Vanita Kumar Bhandula have created a surreal backdrop against which the director, aided by nuanced performances by raw yet surprisingly competent lead stars, uses magic realism, surrealism and other forms that haven't even been invented yet to tell a stirring story of love, hope, longing, loss and redemption...

At some point in the future -- the very distant future, because the evolution of sensibility is a painfully slow process -- a film historian might write in that vein about the latest from the SLB dream factory. What contemporary historians and the paying public, not similarly gifted with 20/20 hindsight, will say is likely unprintable.

|

Back | Next

Sitting through Saawariya

The world of Saawariya, architecturally speaking, is the misbegotten offspring of a one-night stand between the Gothic and Saracenic styles, when both were vacationing in Venice. Thus, you have winding canals on which ply -- at times with no visible means of propulsion -- sawn-off versions of Venetian gondolas. Lining the canals in neat arrays are homes largely Gothic in shape, with the odd cupola, minaret and such betraying the Saracenic side of its parentage. The polyglot nature of this world is underlined by the neon-lit names adorning the structures: Khaikhomer, Windermere, Capitol, Gulgulshan... It is a well-lit world, with antique street lamps and blazing neon and, despite the incessant rain that pours down at the drop of a clapper-board, bright fires burning in huge barrels at street corners; these have been strategically placed by the far-sighted municipal corporation just in case anyone has any letters to burn.

The latest census indicates that over 50 per cent of the population is prostitutes. There are a few yuppie BPO types who can be found in the town's sole nightclub; a smattering of elderly ladies who are someone's grandmother; and a man who scares the crap out of girls by stalking them down dark alleys or popping out of nowhere to sneeze in their faces. Prostitutes, however, far outnumber these other categories.

|

Back | Next

Sitting through Saawariya

Prostitutes are typically an oppressed bunch, eking out a precarious living by turning tricks day and night -- but in Saawariya-land, Utopian conditions prevail. Probably because there are very few men there (and one of those few men is too busy sneezing to be of much use to a girl), they don't have to burden themselves with customers. Thus, they spend most of their time lolling around in their beds, probably reading short stories written by Fyodor Dostoevsky, and come out into the open air only to play impromptu games of freestyle soccer with the male lead, or to dance at the birthday party of their reigning diva Gulabji, who, if you excavate beneath the shitload of makeup, bears a passing resemblance to Rani Mukerji.

On such occasions, they are dressed entirely in blue - owing, as an upcoming story in The Economist will point out, to a fiscally-savvy madam who figured out buying saris of identical color by the gross is cost-effective. The two latest recruits, by the way, are dressed in green; the madam is reportedly waiting for 22 more girls to join the gang, so she can buy blues for them in one cheap job lot.

Don't for a moment imagine that their life is all jam. Reminders that life is grim and earnest come from the occasional tears, largely prompted by the male lead's idiocies, and the close-up of one call girl's face sporting a perfectly-placed burn mark.

|

Back | Next

Sitting through Saawariya

Your heart goes out to the male lead, from the moment you first set eyes on him. Poor darling -- he is parentless, homeless, penniless (having spent all he owned on more chains than you find on prisoners condemned to death, and those nifty diamond studs in his ears), friendless... And witless. Until he stumbles on a presumably senile old lady (Zohra Sehgal, wasted in a role she will have a tough time living down) to adopt him, he sleeps in the open with a soccer ball for a pillow. Trouble is, the soccer ball is round (big surprise, that), and keeps rolling away, causing the poor fellow to crack his head on the unfeeling stone and wake up to see Rani's painted face leering down at him. If only he had friends, they would have advised him to let half the air out of the ball to keep it from rolling away, but never mind that. He is a good-looking boy, Ranbir Kapoor is, and his most striking feature is the cleft in his chin. You get a good view of that feature, because the camera zooms up close, very close, a good bit of the time. In fact, the camera gets so close, and his face is consequently so magnified, that to your fevered imagination that cleft seems to be the size of a bathtub in a luxury resort. You've got to love the boy, for more reasons than one. There is the bowler hat and, on occasion, the borrowed umbrella that brings home to you, with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer, that the Raj Kapoor legacy has found its latest torchbearer (In case you missed that message, one of the buildings sports an outsize neon sign that says, with touching simplicity, 'RK'). There is the endearing earnestness with which he mouths the silliest dialogues ever penned, often struggling to be heard against the background music. A brief segue about the music, which at its best is needlessly loud and at its worst, unbearably cacophonous. At times it so loud, it measures a good 7.0 on the Richter scale. The theatre shakes under that unrelenting assault -- though on second thoughts, those tremors could have been caused by Dostoevsky turning over, and over, and over in his grave, poor fellow. Never mind that, let's continue with the reasons why you should love the latest roll-out from the Kapoor khandaan. There is his toned bod, and the cute butt you almost see when he uses the flimsy towel around his waist like a matador's cape. My spies tell me audiences in the US can actually see the whole butt and nothing but the butt -- a circumstance that earns this film the dubious distinction of being India's first to merit a PG rating. (I wish we had the PG rating here - my parents, always concerned for my well-being, would have guided me away -- far away -- from this movie.)

Continuing the list of reasons to like Ranbir, there is the faux Hrithik Roshan dancing style where you throw your hands and legs about like you don't want them anymore, and the random fits of epilepsy that make his lady love laugh and the rest of us cry.

To be serious for a minute, it would be terribly unfair to judge this boy on the basis of this film; he deserves a better litmus test than a hackneyed script, inept dialogues, and a director who let his incompetent evil twin take over the helm can provide.

|

Back | Next

Sitting through Saawariya

Sonam Kapoor has 'it' -- that indefinable something that is not talent, or looks, or voice, or anything you can put a name to but which can, given the right circumstances, strike sparks off an audience. In fact, she has so much of 'it' that it shows even despite Bhansali's best attempts to reduce her to a cardboard cutout. She lives in a haveli with a blind grandmother who keeps her captive through the wildly original medium of outsize safety pins, and an aunt or some such about whom the less said the better. The family business is making carpets; at this, the family is a disastrous failure, judging by the rows upon rows of unsold, dust-covered carpets that Sonam beats up with a stick when she is particularly frustrated by the atrocities the script inflicts on her. The role requires her to run the gamut of expressions from A to B. There are times when she giggles and there are times when she cries, and there are times when she gigglers and cries at the same time, creating facial effects that would have interested the late Marcel Marceau.

Like Ranbir, she is more to be pitied than censured; it is not her fault that her debut vehicle turned out to be a leaky boat.

|

Back | More

Sitting through Saawariya

I could go on, but never mind - you get the point: Saawariya is a tragic waste of all the time, effort, money (reportedly Rs 35 crore) and creative talent that went into its making. At a press conference, back in the days before he stopped promoting the film, Salman Khan maintained that Saawariya is based not on Le Notti Blanche, the Luchino Visconti film of 1961 vintage (or, presumably, even on the 1971 French version, Quatre nuits d'un r'veur, or Four Nights of a Dreamer, helmed by Robert Bresson), but on White Nights, the 1848 short story written by Fyodor Dostoevsky (that is acknowledged also in the title credits). (Incidentally, fans of Tamil movies will recall a 2003 film starring Arunkumar and Seema Biswas, called Iyarkai, that won for producer VR Kumar and director Jananathan the 2004 National Award for best regional feature film.) I am glad he cleared that up - not so much for the clarification itself, as for the implicit evidence that Salman is not the muscle-bound stud everyone takes him for. To hit the remaining high spots, it felt good to see the Torch Lady, the iconic Columbia Pictures logo, introducing an Indian film; it felt bad when the premiere began without the national anthem being played. When the film came to an end, one member of the houseful audience clapped, another joined and then a third. Most of us whirled around to see who was making the noise -- and even those three celebrants promptly lapsed into silence. Go to enough premieres and you will realize how significant that is -- preview audiences will stand to almost any film, given the slightest excuse. That the audience didn't, here, is the best litmus test for the appeal of Bhansali's latest.

The movie reminded me of a devastating critique I once read, somewhere. Referring to a total turkey, the reviewer wrote: 'This film has a certain elusive appeal - it eluded those of us who saw it.' Amen.

Edited by darkness_123 - 18 years ago
mandy0310 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 18 years ago
#25

Saawariya
Cast: Ranbir Kapoor, Sonam Kapoor, Zohra Sehgal, Rani Mukherjee, Salman Khan (sp. Appearance)
Direction: Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Critic rating:
< id=voteresult name=voteresult align=top marginWidth=0 marginHeight=0 src="https://www.india-forums.com/showrating.cms?msid=2530237&voteid=2530237&random=172617" Border=0 width=200 scrolling=no height=60></>

<>downshowrating=1 One half of the two major releases this Diwali, there are major expectations from Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Saawariya ; one reason being that it marks the debuts of Anil Kapoor's daughter Sonam and Rishi Kapoor's son Ranbir. Do the youngsters live up to the acting prowess of their parents? Read on...

Cutting through the chase, Saawariya is a visual brilliance even though the plotline is very thin. The sets are very imaginative and the larger than life experience that Sanjay Leela Bhansali's gives the audience in every film is now down to earth but with something really magical. The performances are beautiful and though you cannot include this to be out of the world cinema, it does relocate you into another world.

Ranbir Raj (Ranbir Kapoor) is a young musician in a very artistic city. Always zestful towards life he is the lead singer in RK Bar. He may not have much money but like he says, he has the will to spread joy. Befriending the local prostitute Gulab (Rani Mukherjee), he gets to stay at an old lady's (Zohra Sehgal) place. One fine day he comes across someone who completely takes his breath away. She is crying and waiting for someone. Who is this girl that Raj has been mesmerized by? As he pursues her, he finds out that she is Sakina (Sonam Kapoor) who is on the lookout for something. Mysterious in nature, Sakina is all that Raj yearns for. Using his genuine boyish charms he makes friends with Sakina but his wonderful world comes crashing down when she reveals to him about her lover (Salman Khan) who promised to come back to her after a year's time. Raj is shattered but at the same time doubts the credentials of her lover. Has he run away after making an empty promise of returning?

The highlight of the film is the young innocence present in the two main characters. They dance to choreographed songs with extras behind them; they are in love but it's not two way; It's all been seen before but not like this. That's where the screenplay comes into play. Small things and incidents between the two characters radiate so much bloom that it's difficult not to fall in love with the two.

Rishi Kapoor made a huge splash in Bobby and his son doesn't let him down. Ranbir makes the debut of a life-time and it is evident that another member of the Kapoor clan has arrived. He is not the polished clean-shaven stud but a young boy with a heart of gold who is deeply in love. Here's a new-comer to definitely watch out for. Sonam too emotes perfect expressions for her part and looks very beautiful. Kudos to Sanjay Leela Bhansali for getting the best of out the two.

Visually this is Sanjay Leela Bhansali's best film to date. A very simple story told in a beautiful way and Bhansali lives up to his tag of being a master craftsman. In fact you get a theatrical feel while watching the film. The sets are beautiful and you just cannot keep your eyes of them. The dialogues are simplistic- just what is required in this film. No high dosage of heavy dialogues here.

However, there are excessive songs in the film. In an age where anything above 15 reels gets boring, Saawariya could have easily been shortened by at least 30 minutes. However, Monty's music is pleasing to the ears and it's good to hear melody rather than DJ remixes after a long time.

Rani plays a prostitute once again after Laaga Chunari Mein Daag and manages to do a much better job this time though one cannot completely explain her presence in the film. Salman Khan reminds you of his other special appearance in Saawan, Garv- Pride and Honour and numerous other serious films that he has acted in before- nothing new. Zohra Sehgal is terrific once again after Cheeni Kum .

Sweet innocence has returned once again to Bollywood and Ranbir and Sonam are part of it. Though the film is slow at several places, one cannot forget that there is freshness in Saawariya that hasn't been seen in a very long time. If you loved the purity of Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak , then you are bound to love film as well.

https://movies.indiatimes.com/moviereview/2530237.cms

mandy0310 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 18 years ago
#26

Producer: Sanjay Leela Bhansali and SPE Films India Pvt. Ltd.
Director: Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Starring: Ranbir Kapoor, Sonam Kapoor, Salman Khan, Rani Mukherjee, Zohra Sehgal, and Begum Para
Music: Monty Sharma, Sanjay Leela Bhansali (Guest)
Lyrics: Sameer, Nusrat Badr, and Sandeep Nath
Genre: Romantic
Recommended Audience: General
Approximate Running Time: 2 hrs 30 min
Film Released on: 09 November 2007
Reviewed by: Samir Dave
Reviewer's Rating: 8.5 / 10

Once upon a time there was a movie that touched the senses, the soul, and the heart. Sanjay Leela Bhansali's "Saawariya" is an eternal film that transports the viewers across time and space into a world that exists just beyond our ordinary lives. The film is like an ethereal spirit that lovingly brushes the back of your heart in the dark and leaves a haunting impression upon your soul.

The movie has been brought to us by the man who may arguably be India's best director, Sanjay Leela Bhansali. The director has been responsible for some of the most beautiful cinema that Bollywood audiences have seen. Movies such as "Khamoshi", "Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam", "Devdas" and "Black" have left an indelible mark on Hindi movie fans all across the world. His previous movies have been praised for his artistic vision and uncompromising dedication to the craft of movie making. If ever there were a director that Raj Kapoor has passed the baton to, it is Mr. Sanjay Leela Bhansali. The director is known for his perfectionism in everything from cinematography to the music score. "Saawariya" is a highly anticipated film by fans, as people wonder whether the director has been able to create another masterpiece or not. The movie is co-produced by Sony film's Columbia Pictures and has been given a PG rating (for a bit of nudity) by the Motion Picture Association of America. This highly touted and anticipated film releases worldwide on Diwali (November 9th, 2007) and features the debut of Ranbir Kapoor (Raj Kapoor's grandson and son of Rishi Kapoor), Sonam Kapoor (Anil Kapoor's daughter). The supporting cast includes Zora Sehgal with appearances by Salman Khan and Rani Mukherjee. Special mention must be made of the biggest character in the film, which sometimes overshadows even the flesh and blood actors: the small, magical, sleepy blue/green hued town that provides the canvas on which Sanjay Leela Bansali paints his characters over the course of four nights. The film centers around a lovable vagabond that appears in town one night, and quickly wins over the heart of "working girl" Gulabji (Rani Mukherjee) who falls in love with the charm, innocence and seeming naivet of Ranbir Raj (Ranbir Kapoor). He has no family, no history, and seeks the love of those around him to fill the solitude that exists within his heart. After winning over the hearts of the town's prostitutes by re-assuring them that angels will take away their sorrow, he captures the heart of Lillipop (Zora Sehgal) by bringing back the happiness that she lost when her son left her thirty seven years before. He does this by offering her that which she has not had in a long, long time…a warm and loving hug. Once he has befriended the most unlikely of characters, he happens upon a beautiful woman that steals his soul away within the breath of his lonely darkness. Raj, is used to fighting life on his own, and is willing to box with sadness/fate even though life may try it's best to knock him down. Once he sees Sakina (Sonam Kapoor), he truly feels that he for once is not alone. He is enamored, thrilled, crazy, and mad with a love and passion that makes him write Sakina's name on the walls across town. Little does he know that though he has fallen in love with her, her heart belongs to another man and she only sees poor Raj as a friend with whom to share her loneliness until her beloved returns. Imaan (Salman Khan) has stolen Sakina's heart, but had to leave her behind until he can return to her on the eve of Eid. Raj's heart is torn to shreds as he tries to convince his beloved Sakina that he is truly the man for her. Unfortunately, he finds that the woman he loves has no room in her heart for him. Will Sakina choose Raj over Imaan? Will Raj be heartbroken by losing Sakina to Imaan? Will Lillipop break out into song and dance? Will Gulabji sacrifice her secret love for Raj, so that he can be happy? For the answers to those questions and more, I'm afraid you'll have to go out and see this beautifully filmed movie. "Saawariya" is as much a story about the magical town that surrounds the actors as it is about the characters themselves. Sanjay Leela Bhansali and cinematrographer Ravi K. Chandran have draped the entire town in blue and green hues, giving every scene a wispy ethereal look that leaves the audience enraptured. Each frame/scene is like a painting and the viewer doesn't know where to look first. These hues combine with the magnificently detailed sets designed by art director, Omung Kumar. If there's any one complaint, it's that each frame has so much going on in the background that it can get a bit distracting at times. It's a testament to Mr. Bhansali, that he has tried a completely different technique in filming this movie. The closest comparisons I can make to "Saawariya's" distinct look are to films that are directed by Hollywood director Tim Burton who prefers filming completely on indoor sets as Bhansali has done in this film. Though the sets seem visually realistic, the viewer is left quite conscious of the fact that something is just a bit off. This works to the film's advantage as the town takes on a magical look. It becomes both "everywhere" and "nowhere" within India. In fact, the town is never even properly identified within the movie. The hues which are provided by space lights (the first use of these atmospheric lights in a Hindi film) and the use of blue/green paint, add to the creation of a character which I call "magical reality". Everywhere you look, there are artistic flourishes such as neon signs in subdued hues, a statue of Buddha, Mona Lisa drapes, Persian rug patterns, and a beautiful bridge with a river running underneath it all combine to form the centerpiece of this emotional tale. Bhansali's dedication to his craft is evident throughout the movie, and he re-affirms himself as the best director that India has to offer. Sanjay Leela Bhansali's "Saawariya" is as much homage to his distinct style of filmmaking as it is to the bygone Raj Kapoor movies of yesteryear. In fact, Ranbir Kapoor's character Ranbir Raj's anscestry can be traced back to the beloved vagabond clown that Raj Kapoor performed in movies like "Shree 420". He's pure, friend to all, beloved by all, a loser in love, yet never gives up hope for a better future. The legacy of Raj Kapoor can be felt all through the movie, culminating in Ranbir and Sonam's re-enactment of the RK Films logo (sculpted after the famous scene of Raj Kapoor holding Nargis as she looks up at him) Ranbir Kapoor rises up to the challenge of living up to his grandfather's legacy by delivering a multi-layered nuanced performance that covers the broad range of emotions that is the human psyche. He makes you laugh, he makes you cry, but most of all he creates a distinct character that charms the audience. He's not afraid to be cheeky, and by that I don't mean, ahem, cheeky in any sense but the literal. For you see, not only does he act well, he makes what may very well be Bollywood history by being the first male actor to flash his sculpted nude behind. I can almost imagine the sighs from the ladies in the audience when they see him in all his cheeky glory. Don't worry though, it's not a cheesecake shot, but rather filmed very artistically by the director and showcases the character's ability to be completely free and happy in his love. (Female viewers in India may be a bit disappointed, as the scene will probably be edited by the Censor Board). It is on Ranbir's acting "shoulders" that this movie rests as he has more screen time than any of the others. I have to say, that for his first movie, he has displayed an unusual grace both within his acting range and dancing style. If there is one minor complaint, it's that a few of his expressions need work, as his unconventional looks sometimes result in expressions that make him look a bit foolish. It's quite obvious that Sanjay Leela Bhansali has worked very hard in molding this young actor to produce such a stellar performance. So far, the movie has three stars: The first star in the film is the director himself, the second are the town sets, and the third is the discovery of a new star in Ranbir Kapoor. But, what about Sonam Kapoor, you might ask? Honestly, she almost fades into the background at times and suffers from the usual lack of strong writing for female characters. Her character never comes across as more than a pining love-sick woman. The range of her performance is limited to laughing, crying or looking coquettish towards Ranbir and Imaan. What's lacking is a certain finesse and nuance that should have been brought to the performance. It's not to say that she is bad, it's just that the viewer keeps expecting more than what her performance provides. She does bring the necessary innocence and beauty to the role, and her costumes are ethnically beautiful; however, one wishes that she brought a bit more to the film. Sonam has made a commendable first effort that is a bit overshadowed by the other actors. The one thing that she shares with Ranbir, is a very good chemistry that brings out the joyfulness of youth and first loves. What adds to Sonam Kapoor almost being lost within this movie is that the supporting actors are all so wonderful. One of the most elegant of performances is provided by Zora Sehgal. Her character is heartwarming and she displays such emotion within her eyes. From the pain of extreme loneliness, to the weight of a life-time of experiences, she is the sensitive soul that balances our beloved clown Ranbir. Rani Mukherjee provides the glamour in a strong performance as the prostitute Gulabji who has the strength and courage to fight for her happiness, yet knows no end to the depths of her sadness as she lets go of the man she has fallen in love with. Her dialogue delivery is charming as she mixes up bad street-wise Hindi with skewed English. What's that you say? What about Salman Khan? The actor is in the movie for perhaps a total of five minutes, but gives a very strong yet restrained performance as Imaan, the man who Sakina falls madly in love with. He proves that he is a superstar as he lights up the screen with his acting persona in each frame he is in. His is a pivotal character, upon which hangs the fate of both Ranbir and Sakina. Monty Sharma's situational songs and background score help move the story forward throughout the film. The title track, "Saawariya" is wonderfully visualized and powerfully introduces Ranbir Kapoor to the world. "Pari" is full of hope as Ranbir impresses Gulabji with his belief that things will always get better. "Masha-Allah" is beautifully realized by Bhansali and frames how a woman can completely take a man's breath away. "Thode Badmash" showcases Sonam Kapoor's beauty and visualizes how a woman can see the man she loves on so many different levels. "Chabeela" plays to Rani Mukherjee's graceful dancing and expressive emotions. The choreography is very well done for this song, and is a must see. The music is enhanced by the visuals within the film and the viewer will gain a new found respect for the soundtrack by the end of the movie.

This is one of those films that will take you to the magical world that exists within director Sanjay Leela Bhansali's fevered mind. It's a love story taken to another level. Unrequited love never looked or felt so good. The film is spellbinding, heartwarming, and yes, heartbreaking as well. Is it his best film? No, it's not Sanjay Leela Bhansali's best film. It is; however on par with his previous movies and will not disappoint his fans. The only thing that might go against it having mass appeal is that the movie is truly like a classical painting, in that the viewer has to open their mind and have the patience to appreciate true beauty. I highly recommend that you see the movie in a movie theater to appreciate the beautiful direction, backgrounds, and fine nuanced performances. "Saawariya" is a film that will prompt discussion, will be appreciated as a classic and will be one of those movies that will get better upon repeated viewings. It truly is like an ethereal spirit that lovingly brushes the back of your heart in the dark and leaves a haunting impression upon your soul. The film is a magical spectacle of visual and emotional delight.

https://www.planetbollywood.com/displayReview.php?id=11070705 0629

ProdigalStudent thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#27
Review: Saawariya fails to strike the chord

Rajeev Masand / CNN-IBN



Published on Friday , November 09, 2007 at 22:13 in Entertainment section

Tags: Rajeev Masand, Movie Review , Cast
E-mail this report | Print this report
Kareena Kapoor
Your Favourite Stars All Here. Know More Ear Training
Name any note or chord - by EAR! Proven at 2 leading universities.

Ads by Google


Cast: Ranbir Kapoor and Sonam Kapoor


Director: Sanjay Leela Bhansali


In a nameless picturesque town straight out of Baz Luhrmann's Moulin Rouge, a free-spirited dreamer befriends a melancholic girl who spends three nights at the bridge waiting patiently for someone to return. By the time our hero learns that she already has a lover for whom she waits, it's too late, because over the course of these three nights, singing and dancing with her, teasing and playing with her, he's fallen deeply in love.


Determined to charm her off her feet and to make her choose him over a man who may never return, his love is put to the ultimate test when she asks him to help unite her with the man she's pledged her heart to.


Starring newcomers Ranbir Kapoor and Sonam Kapoor as Raj and Sakina, the protagonists in question, director Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Saawariya is a glossed-up, all song-and-dance take on Dostoevsky's classic tale White Nights, and also borrows judiciously from Luchino Visconti's 1957 film version. But where Visconti's black-and-white film stays faithful to the story's intimate set-up and stark feel, Bhansali goes for a larger-than-life, almost kingsize scale, throwing in dazzling colours, opulent sets, imaginatively choreographed musical numbers, a half-dozen references to Raj Kapoor's films, and the kind of melodrama you can expect only in a Sanjay Leela Bhansali film - remember Devdas?


Well, the problem with varnishing a simple love story with all those embellishments is that the very simplicity of the plot, the fragility of the characters' emotions is lost amidst all that showing-off. What you get as a result, is a love story without soul.


An expensive and indulgent experiment, Saawariya doesn't quite work because the writing is flawed and the director doesn't seem to notice. Once a master manipulator of human emotions, Bhansali now fails to invest in his characters even the smallest dose of believability. Like cardboard caricatures, lifeless and dull, they rattle off ridiculous dialogues trying to sound like they have something profound to say. How you cringe in that scene where Ranbir convinces Zohra Sehgal to lease him a room, or that one in which he likens being sad to losing a boxing match.


There, my friends, lies the biggest problem - Saawariya comes off contrived and fake, and fails to strike a chord. You feel nothing for its characters, at best sympathy for the two young actors trapped in this pathetic, pretentious pap.


Arbitrary, disjointed and leaving too many questions unanswered, Saawariya is easily Bhansali's most self-indulgent exercise yet. Too busy taking himself too seriously, the director decides he has no obligations to tell us where or when this story unfolds. Is this a period piece, or are we in the present day? Pray tell us, where in the world is this idyllic town -- bathed in neon glow and littered with windmills and clock-towers and a Venetian canal in the middle of a town square?


Where prostitutes in colour-coordinated ensembles inhabit every corner and break into song at will. Where street after cobbled street leads to nowhere in particular, and where it rains one day and snows another. Welcome to the fantastical world of Sanjay Leela Bhansali where images speak a thousand words, even if they're of little relevance to the plot of the film. Gobsmackingly photographed by Ravi K Chandran, what stays with you after you've left the cinema are those images after all, picture-postcard images that are embedded in your memory because they breathe more life than the characters do.


Of the cast, the usually feisty Zohra Sehgal hams like she's trapped between two slices of bread, and throws in an irritating Anglicized accent that comes in the way of your taking her seriously. As Iman, the mysterious stranger who's vital to this jigsaw puzzle of a film, Salman Khan is mercifully restrained, his two and a half scenes requiring him only to stare fixedly and mumble inaudibly.


Rani Mukherjee playing Gulabji the hooker with a heart of gold, is the only character whose pathos is relatable, and despite the cheesy dialogue she touches your heart with a performance that is inherently earnest.

And now, on to the two debutants - as Sakina, the child-woman going through myriad emotions, Sonam Kapoor manages to hold her own despite the fact that hers is clearly the weakest written role. It's a wishy-washy character that's part-annoying part-ridiculous, and it's unfair that the young actress must wrestle to make sense of such a distinctly unlikable part. Ranbir Kapoor, meanwhile, when he isn't struggling to ape his grandfather's mannerisms, displays an an affable charm. Grabbing your attention when he's dancing on screen, he's got that star quality to him which is so rare to find.


Like all of Bhansali's previous pictures, Saawariya too is a visual spectacle. Few filmmakers' can match his attention to detail, his magnificent use of lighting and colour, and his sharp ear for music. But in the end, it's not about the sweeping scale or the lilting melodies, Saawariya fails to touch your heart, it's an exercise in excess. I'm going with one out of five for Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Saawariya, a fall from grace for the country's most celebrated filmmaker.


Rating: 1 / 5 (Poor)

Source: http://www.ibnlive.com/news/review-saawariya-fails-to-strike -the-chord/52035-8.html
Chippeshwini thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#28
man reviews are mad dissapointing I'll still give the movie a go though...
thanks for the reviews 😊
mandy0310 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 18 years ago
#29

Cast: Ranbir Kapoor, Sonam Kapoor, Rani Mukerji, Beghum Para, Zohra Sehgal, Salman Khan
Director: Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Rating: *****

This work of art doesn't have the in-your-face flamboyance of "Devdas" or "Black" where almost every shot reached a crescendo, every passion peaked like a mid-summer sun, and every movement denoted drama. But "Saawariya" is Sanjay Leela Bhansali's most tender ode to love yet.

Taking Fyodor Dostoevsky's minuscule play "White Nights", Bhansali has built huge but unimposing emotions classified by dollops of awe-inspiring studio-erected architecture that represents feelings rather than physical forms.

This is the director's most subtle and mellow creation.

Prakash Kapadia's dialogues let Ranbir's character of Ranbir Raj speak in a language that is modern and yet timelessly lovelorn.

The plot, if one may call it that, is a story of unrequited love told in shades of blue. Bhansali's narrative spins its sensuous web around chance encounters in and around a square set in a timeless land where clocks chime to the rhythm of a besotted heart and neon signs straight out of a bright Broadway pay cheeky homage to Bollywood's past, including Raj Kapoor, of course.

Ranbir Raj sings and performs at a club called Raj's Bar when he isn't chasing the enigmatic Sakina (Sonam Kapoor) across an arched bridge that symbolises the end of hope and the beginning of love.

Sakina, if you must know, is on an eternal wait. A stranger (Salman Khan) walked into her home and life, walked out and promised to return. The lacuna between longing and fulfilment is filled by a young man who dances, sings, makes faces, writes love letters, protects Sakina from the rain, but alas, cannot protect himself from the heartbreak that awaits him under the bridge.

You can see reflections of Raj Kapoor's persona from "Sri 420" and "Chhalia" in Ranbir's acting in "Saawariya". And his relationship with his outwardly harsh landlady -- played by the gloriously spirited Zohra Sehgal -- is a wonderful recreation of the bond between Raj Kapoor and Lalita Pawar in "Anari".

Ranbir's acting is a dangerously extravagant and bravura performance that could've toppled over under the weight of the character's inherent exhibitionism. But with his director's help, Ranbir succeeds.

The emotions that run across the gossamer frames of this fragilely structured play-on-celluloid are woven with the delicacy that one associates with Kashmiri carpets.

Ironically, though requiring more attention than all his earlier works, "Saawariya" is Bhansali's simplest story to date. The age-old boy-meets-girl format has been taken to the plane of purest expressionism.

The enchanting encounters shown in the film furnish the slim but haunting plot with the feeling of a play where the characters forget they are on stage.

The film's consciously created staginess is its biggest virtue. It lends an otherworldly quality to the frames. The wispy characters may or may not exist outside the prostitute-narrator Rani Mukerji's playful mind.

Maybe she's making up this beautiful tale of one-sided love and perhaps the boy-man she took under her wings is just a figment of her imagination.

The disarming delicacy with which art directors Omang and Vinita Kumar and cinematographer Ravi Chandran have built the blue foundations of the film's ravishingly romantic imagination lifts Dostoevsky's play to the sphere of poetry.

Monty Sharma's soul-stirring music adds an entirely new dimension to the story of waiting and suffering.

As expected from a Bhansali creation, the film is bathed in visuals that overpower the senses. The sequence where Sonam runs across a gauntlet of perpendicularly hung carpets beating a dust storm out of their beautiful fabric is a moment of sensual eruption.

In "Saawariya", Sonam does not know what or whom she is running from or what she will run into. She is Nutan in "Bandini", Aishwarya in "Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam" and Waheeda Rehman in "Pyasa".

"Saawariya" is like a dream where the characters themselves live in a dream world. Escape from this world is akin to death. No one dies in Bhansali's majestic make-belief world and nothing wilts. Not even love when it is taken away from the boy who loves to entertain the unhappy girl in distress.

http://www.bollywoodworld.com/news/bwnews.php?subaction=show full&id=1194615765&archive=&start_from=&ucat =1&

mandy0310 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 18 years ago
#30
This film is definately getting mixed reviews, I still plan to watch it though. I like to judge the film for myself 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".