-Enigma- THREAD 6 - Page 38

Created

Last reply

Replies

788

Views

161.5k

Users

190

Likes

2.9k

Frequent Posters

shanky18 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Ambibamby

Sorry guys, I can understand your frustration but pls update. We luv u guy's ff and hate that someone has the audacity to copy ur work. Mods should shut them down.

no offence yar...Fairy did nt copy...she is inspired ...she hav her own thouths n storyline to countiue wiv...she have 7 thread in jt 2 - 4 months...n u think is copy?????????...
have u read Fairy FF or nt???????????
ppl are upset...its painful as ur work be claiming others...most writers have left IF or stop writing FF cuz of criticing n blame of plagiarism
-Deepzz- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
@BadGirlKiss

My POV...

I have read all the 3 authors stories...MuskanP, FireSafirefire and fairlyland_1234 ...I find all 3 have distinct writing styles...and the stories presented are also different...I would not call it a copy at all...Some ideas may resemble some things...but they may be inspired from anywhere not necessarily from Muskanp or Keyama's works ...

Plaigarism is a serious offense...It is discouraging to the authors who are trying their best...Before alleging somebody in public please think a few times .




Edited by kadydeep - 14 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Noori93

Hey Kemya,

I thought i would take the time to point out, that if you were copying Muskan di.Then I am pretty sure,she would tell you.Although she does not think that way,as she most probably reads your story. Do not feel disheartened,because if she was truly a fan of muskan di,then she would never say such a thing.I find it highly offensive, because you make the effort to make us happy.
I just want you to know that your story IS TOTALY different then hers, because she did not have such characters.I love reading your stories!So please do continue, people don't realize how rude it is to tell a writer that they are copying someone!<3Love loads
-noor



she is taking about fairy here- not me...
i am so confused now.. OO
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago
i really don't know whats going on here,
but i am very upset with everything...
so sorry to all my readers..
i don't know when i will update
but badgirlkiss could you reply quick to me... along with muskanup.
something gone very serious here,
i agree fairy is inspiared, but pls do reply, as i am stuck!!!

notfadedaway thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago


I DO NOT think she is copying your work AT ALL! I don't know what badgirlkiss is saying. she is mistaken and she is making a huge deal about it! :( I hate to see this ppl are believing her...

read the comments in ur gall and fairy girl...

everyone reads both muskaan and ur FF..but we never found similarities..

I dunno why you are confsued. I DO NOT see any similarities AT ALL! :(

remorse WAS TOTALLY diff from fairy's FF! TOTALLLYY!
Edited by ayeshaaa. - 14 years ago
ninand thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
Hi, you wouldnt know me, but seeing your title I jumped in here to read the note out of pure curiosity.
and am i glad😆.. I read what the other girl said, it may sound confusing, so I'll try and clarify.

She(badgirl...) is saying that the other girl the fairy... has copied from your and muskanp 's ff's.
Now I dont know what and how much shes copied from your ff's but I can say for certain that shes copied from muskanp's 'deewangi' like crazy.!!. infact the entire first few chapters are a straight rip off...
I couldnt read more than a few chapters cause I didnt agree with the author at all.. its humble of muskan to not take offence but if the author has copied from your ff too, then its not at all right or acceptable.

She should atleast mention you guys as inspirations and take due permissions. I am surprised at the number of readers who have read muskans ff and fairy's ff's and yet complimented fairy.. without reserve , knowing full well that it wasn't her idea to begin with.
THat I didnt like her treatment of the ff, or her thinking, is a completely different thing I wouldnt get into.😆
Edited by ninand - 14 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ayeshaaa.



I DO NOT think she is copying your work AT ALL! I don't know what badgirlkiss is saying. she is mistaken and she is making a huge deal about it! :( I hate to see this ppl are believing her...

read the comments in ur gall and fairy girl...

everyone reads both muskaan and ur FF..but we never found similarities..

I dunno why you are confsued. I DO NOT see any similarities AT ALL! :(

remorse WAS TOTALLY diff from fairy's FF! TOTALLLYY!



aysha its not about my remorse- as its complete dark story in no way thats a copy for sure... she is talking about how i explain my love scn... which idk what to say.. i will ask my reader.. i am fine with it &, of course i am confused, what i to say.. getting PM after PM... saying she copied muskan ff.. then now she is criss crossing with some ideas of our ff...
ugh.. me very p-off..

& pls do not accuse me, bcs i have no clue whats going on here.
i am still asking badgirlkiss to give me reason... so i can say she is wrong...
7 to any other reader pls do give me some reason here in which way she copied
Edited by FIRESafiReFIRE - 14 years ago
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ninand

Hi, you wouldnt know me, but seeing your title I jumped in here to read the note out of pure curiosity.

and am i glad😆.. I read what the other girl said, it may sound confusing, so I'll try and clarify.

She(badgirl...) is saying that the other girl the fairy... has copied from your and muskanp 's ff's.
Now I dont know what and how much shes copied from your ff's but I can say for certain that shes copied from muskanp's 'deewangi' like crazy.!!. infact the entire first few chapters are a straight rip off.
I couldnt read more than a few chapters cause I didnt agree with the author at all.. its humble of muskan to not take offence but if the author has copied from your ff too, then its not right all.

She should atleast mention you guys as inspirations and take due permissions. I am surprised at the number of readers who have read muskans ff and fairy's ff's and yet complimented fairy.. without reserve knowing well that its not her idea at all.
THat I didnt like her treatment of the ff, or her thinking, is a completely different thing I wouldnt get into.😆




i would love to know where she copied... i am gn read her first part... then talk to muskan. 🤢
why i am getting draged in to this... ugg.. me no like this.
notfadedaway thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
Keyama! You know how much I love your work!
I am not accusing you!

I know muskaan di will say she did not copy!
Becus evryone is saying all three of ur guys
writing is totally difff! :(

Updtsoon!

And I don't know why I don't really see what Did fairy
exactly copy frm remorse? :(
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: ayeshaaa.

Keyama! You know how much I love your work!
I am not accusing you!

I know muskaan di will say she did not copy!
Becus evryone is saying all three of ur guys
writing is totally difff! :(

Updtsoon!

And I don't know why I don't really see what Did fairy
exactly copy frm remorse? :(



its not exact copy.. as she hhave mentioned is inspired ff..
which allot of readers think its coppied... badgirl just pointed out while we get PM...
remorse, its somthing to do with S** which i have explained to fairy & badgirl...
nothing to worry there..
but i can't argue behalf of muskan here.. she needs to come here & point out where she actually was inspired.. as she is inspired.. there bound to be somthig similar.. i have read many comments, poeple saying nothing is similar, well thast wrong, i still give main credit to muskanup here. its her idea & it grew from there.

& of course we type different & thats why people like our ff, but its not just badgirl here, there are many readers, & we getting non stop pm.

i come here to chill & enjoy ff, not to argue about this stuff... i am already worried, now this, i am very P-OFF.

Related Topics

Fan Fictions Thumbnail

Posted by: Koeli

5 years ago

Comment Migration Request Thread #1

Hey guys, This is the place where you can request for comment migration. Please know that FFEs are going to migrate your comments. Rules - You...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".