Maryada: Vidya-Gaurav FF - Updates. p. 145 (6/29) - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

111.4k

Users

56

Likes

3.5k

Frequent Posters

-Aarya- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

"If a man says he is lying, is he telling the truth? Yes or no?"


There is no such paradox here, cause it's not true that the man always lies and it does not mean that he never lies. If he lies sometimes, just likes everyone else and if he would have said this itself is a a lie than that would be a paradox!

Very nice take, Devi!

ps. for such scenarios to be true it can never be spoken out loud..:)

538783 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: night13


"If a man says he is lying, is he telling the truth? Yes or no?"


There is no such paradox here, cause it's not true that the man always lies and it does not mean that he never lies. If he lies sometimes, just likes everyone else and if he would have said this itself is a a lie than that would be a paradox!

Very nice take, Devi!

ps. for such scenarios to be true it can never be spoken out loud..:)



Lol...I agree, but she asked him a yes/no question. She is also not asking him for the 'truth' of the matter, merely whether the man is telling the truth if he says he is lying.

btw, this is one of the oldest paradoxes in the world...
Edited by sridevi27 - 14 years ago
-Sookie- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
Devi changed careers? Maths? Whaaa....?

What happened to your Victorian/Edwardian novella?

:-) Nice going Devi. Will drop by sometime :-)
538783 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago


Chapter 21: Killing Me Softly

They had met at a coffee house just by chance.

She had dropped her coffee cup in what he had later found out was uncharacteristic clumsiness and he had turned around to help her. He had gone and told the manager and had then come back with napkins to wipe up the mess on the floor. He would have likely done that for anyone who had had a similar fate; it had been nothing special about her that had drawn his attention or his assistance. Until of course, he noticed that her hands which held the napkins were trembling slightly. He had only looked up to her face then, but she had still not looked at him. She seemed to want to draw no notice to her at all and he had a feeling that maybe he frightened her. And thus he had picked up the wet napkins and had walked away without saying anything else to her. He had doubted that she had even noticed what he looked like, but evidently she had, as she told him later. She had said that it was the first time anyone had offered her help without expecting anything in return. And he had told her that there were many others who would do the same as what he did, that what he had done was not anything special at all. And she had disagreed. She had told him that a truly unselfish human being, one who would do something with no expectation in return, not even a word of gratitude, was nearly impossible to find. She had told him that even the Gods wished for gratitude, so what chance did a mere mortal stand? He had thought that she was overly pessimistic, not that he could blame her. And she had wondered how he could be so optimistic when he had a sire who was the most amoral brute this side of the state. He had said nothing in response, as he himself had not known the answer to that…

He is always lying, no matter what…

He now thought that maybe optimism was a manner of lying… in face of all evidence to support otherwise, if you insisted on holding out hope for something that would most likely never be… isn't that lying?

He saw his wife's face in his mind suddenly… the vulnerability that he had seen in her eyes when he had pressed her to remain with him and to indulge him in one of her puzzles…

What the hell had he been doing?

He had relaxed too much into their camaraderie with each other that he had allowed himself to forget that they were not just friends in truth, that there was another tie that bound them that had not exactly come about from free will… he was lying again… he told himself to stop. He was a grown man; no one could get him to do anything that he did not want to do. He should just admit to himself that no matter how infinitesimal, there had been a part of him that had acknowledged that he was dying slowly from loving Salome…


Edited by sridevi27 - 14 years ago
-Aarya- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

The tragic situation is that Gaurav's conscience is weak when he needs it the most...(Oh! Confess!) Who is to judge what is right vs wrong.. when dealing with guilt conscience!

***
The title brought back some old memories..

Strumming my pain with his fingers
Singing my life with his words
Killing me softly with his song
Telling my whole life with his words
Killing me softly with his song
BheegiBasanti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
Very interesting paradoxes. 🤓
579908 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
Great stuff Devi ⭐️ I always look forward to these puzzles when reading this FF ...they definitely make the chapters more enjoyable to read.

By the way just like I never watched the show Shiv and Gauri were in, I thought I'd also let you know that I don't watch Maryada either.... so if I read your FFs it's not because of the characters but because your just that good as a writer 👏

I know I haven't posted any long comments in a while, but what can I do life has gotten very hectic in the past weeks, just know that I do still read your works, I just figured a one worded comment was better than no comment at all! 😆

Keep up the great work 😃
538783 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Lip-a-Licious

Great stuff Devi ⭐️ I always look forward to these puzzles when reading this FF ...they definitely make the chapters more enjoyable to read.

By the way just like I never watched the show Shiv and Gauri were in, I thought I'd also let you know that I don't watch Maryada either.... so if I read your FFs it's not because of the characters but because your just that good as a writer 👏

I know I haven't posted any long comments in a while, but what can I do life has gotten very hectic in the past weeks, just know that I do still read your works, I just figured a one worded comment was better than no comment at all! 😆

Keep up the great work 😃


Thank you Nadia :) :)
Edited by sridevi27 - 14 years ago
Sur_10 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
nice to read more about salome...
I wonder if Gaurav even knows what he is doing... and where did this paradox come to vidya's mind of all the places? I think we know...
It seems strange that Gaurav was careless enough to hand her a laptop with Salome's photos to Vidya...
Going good
nikipuki thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
lovely update. Just when I think I figured out all your bag of tricks I discover that there is an another bag hidden in the current one😃. Great work as usual. 👏
Edited by nikipuki - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".